March 2010: Sandra tried to join the Youth Explorers program at 12, but she was on the standby list. She began participating in the program in the spring of 2010. June 4, 2015, Sandra graduated from Stoughton High School. High School Announcement
Tragically, in 2016, both Claire and Denise passed away, with Sandra losing her mother first and her grandmother just a month later. Denise F. McKain Birchmore on May 18, 2016 and Claire G. Coughlin Gaudet on June 24, 2016.
Sandra Birchmore, originally from Stoughton, moved to Canton in 2020. She was discovered deceased in her Windsor Woods apartment on February 4, 2021, after her employer requested a well-being check because she had been absent from work for several days. Matthew Farwell was the last person known to have seen Sandra alive and was captured on surveillance footage leaving her apartment building on February 1, 2021. Sandra was pregnant at the time of her death. DNA testing later excluded Farwell as the biological father, although federal prosecutors allege Sandra and Farwell believed he was the father during the pregnancy. Sandra’s death was originally ruled a suicide by hanging. In 2026, the Massachusetts Office of the Chief Medical Examiner amended the death certificate, changing the cause of death to asphyxia and the manner of death to undetermined. Here is her story.
Sandra’s early years, family relationships, education and involvement in the Stoughton Police Explorers Program are documented in the chronology below.
- Sandra Marie Birchmore was born to Denise F. McKain Birchmore and took her mother’s last name.
- Sandra Birchmore’s biological maternal grandmother, Grace Theresa Coughlin McKain, died in 2001. Following Grace’s death, Grace’s sister, Claire G. (Coughlin) Gaudet, Sandra’s great-aunt, stepped into a maternal role and provided Sandra with grandmotherly care. Source
- Chief Cachopa’s decision: Chief Manuel Cachopa selected Robert Devine, who had been advising the Explorers Program since at least 1999, to take full leadership of the program in 2002.
- Robert Devine had fully integrated Matthew and William Farwell into the Explorers Program’s core activities. Source
- According to witness testimony later unearthed through investigative reporting (referenced in the Case podcast), the Farwell brothers were frequently seen spending extended time in the middle school gym alongside Robert Devine. These interactions, while initially framed as mentoring, were later scrutinized for their appropriateness and the dynamics they fostered. Source
- The Explorers Program, once a promising initiative, came to be shadowed by questions about boundaries and oversight. The Farwell brothers’ journey from troubled students to influential figures within the program reflected both the potential for growth and the challenges of unchecked authority in youth mentorship initiatives.
- Witness testimony (via Case Podcast) alleges the Farwell brothers frequently spent time in the middle school gym with Devine.
- Matthew Farwell earns a high school equivalency diploma in Maine.
- He enlists in the Army and is trained as an explosives expert.
- Matthew Farwell brothers transitioned from participants to guest instructors. Source
- Sandra Birchmore, at age 8, attends the Respect Program.
- Matthew Farwell completed basic training at Fort Jackson, South Carolina
- Advanced Individual Training at Redstone Arsenal, Alabama, and Eglin Air Force Base, Florida
- Qualified for Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) training
- Assigned to Fort Bliss, Texas
- Promoted to Private First Class
- Matthew Farwell deploys to Afghanistan for six months. First to Bagram and then to Jalalabad, where he joined Task Force (TF) Paladin.
- Sandra Birchmore, 9, and her mother, Denise Birchmore, were featured in the Stoughton Journal after completing the 14-week Strengthening Families Program at the First Congregational Church in Stoughton. Denise said she and Sandra were “very close” but enrolled because she wanted to learn additional parenting skills and strengthen their relationship. Sandra said the program taught her about safety rules, manners, and how to walk away from strangers, and said she enjoyed the activities and receiving a certificate. The program was designed for families with children ages 6–11 and focused on strengthening family relationships while reducing risk factors associated with substance abuse, depression, violence, aggression, delinquency, and school failure. Source
- Matthew Farwell returned to Fort Bliss, Texas – Promoted to Sergeant and Selected as team leader
- Matthew Farwell was medically separated from the Army due to migraines and neck pain and moved back to Massachusetts.
- Attended and graduated from police academy. Joined the Wellesley Police Department
- Matthew Farwell volunteered with local youth programs and earned several commendations, including one in 2012 for performing CPR at a gym.
- Matthew Farwell (Wellesley PD) and William Farwell (Army) volunteer as instructors for the Explorers Program.
- Denise Birchmore moved from 231 Lincoln Street, Apartment 3, Stoughton, Massachusetts, to 499 Park Street, Stoughton, Massachusetts. Sandra Birchmore, then 11, moved with her mother. Source
-
Matthew Farwell was among its instructors. Source
- At age 12, Sandra Birchmore applied to participate in the Stoughton Police Explorers Program. Source
- The Stoughton Police Department executed an Annual Memorandum of Understanding with Learning for Life to operate a Police Explorers post. The agreement formalized SPD’s participation and governance obligations for the Explorers Program. Robert C. Devine signed the memorandum on SPD’s behalf. The memorandum set requirements for training, screening, supervision, insurance, and evaluation. Source
-
Sandra Birchmore underwent shoulder surgery, according to an earlier medical-history record. This is separate from the shoulder surgery described in summer 2020. Source
- Sandra joined the Explorers Program. Source
- Matthew Farwell volunteers with the Police Explorers Program.
- Sandra and her family attend orientation and sign-ups for the 2012 Explorers Academy, held at the Stoughton Police Station.
- Matthew Farwell was hired by the Stoughton Police Department. After joining the Stoughton Police Department, he served as a Police Explorers instructor. He held several instructor roles, including teaching firearms and explosives safety and conducting canine demonstrations. Source
-
Matthew Farwell conducted physical fitness and classroom instruction.
-
Sandra participated in classroom exercises and physical training. Although she struggled with some physical requirements, she continued pushing herself to participate.A program photograph showed Holloway on the far left wearing pink shoes and Sandra on the far right. Sandra was also photographed wearing her Police Explorers shirt. The photographs and a 2012 program syllabus were preserved as evidence
- Matthew Farwell sent Birchmore a Facebook “friend request.” Source
- Farwell’s engagement to his fiancée: Source
December 27, 2012After working late “Matt woke me up to let me know he was home as he usually does and when he did I felt something on my finger. While I was sleeping he slipped the ring on my finger so it would be there when I woke up. Once I woke up and was crying because I saw it he popped the question.” Source
- Matt Farwell removed Sandra Birchmore as a friend. Source
- Farwell began tutoring Sandra at a local library while she was 15 years old. Source
- Sandra Birchmore’s medical records documented that she was receiving academic assistance at the Stoughton Public Library from a “local police officer.” Source
- Birchmore tells others that Farwell is helping her with homework.
- Sandra, then 15, and 27-year-old Matthew Farwell had sexual intercourse. Farwell later acknowledged in text messages with Sandra that he took her virginity. Other messages between them discussed sexual contact that occurred before April 2013. Source
- Matthew Farwell and Michelle Chisholm participated in a pre-wedding photoshoot. Source
- Sandra Birchmore asked a doctor for birth control on May 1, 2013, several weeks after Matthew Farwell began sexually exploiting her when she was 15 years old. Source
- Matthew Farwell and Michelle Chisholm were married. The wedding took place at the Omni Mount Washington Resort. Source
- Sandra participated in CPR training associated with the Stoughton Police Explorers Program.
- During her OBGYN appointment, Sandra told a doctor that she was sexually active. Source
- In a Facebook post, the Stoughton Police Department wrote, “Smile Birchmore,” Matthew Farwell had sex with Birchmore when she was a minor, starting in or around April 2013, when Birchmore was 15 and Matthew Farwell was 27. Source
- Matthew Farwell received certified training related to firearms simulation instruction. Source
- Sandra documented sexual activity with Farwell in a notebook entry. Source
- Denise Birchmore, Sandra Birchmore’s mother, was photographed participating in the Stoughton Community Garden, which was part of the Stoughton Youth Commission’s Community Garden Project. The program brought together local youth, seniors, families, and community members through the garden at the Youth Commission/Council on Aging property on Rockland Street. Source
- Sandra attended Police Explorers Source
- Sandra attended the 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Class. Source
- 2:25 PM, the Stoughton Police Department published a photograph of Sandra Birchmore participating in a group physical training exercise with the Stoughton Police Explorers. The department announced that its 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Class was underway, posting: “And the 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Class is off and running!!!” Source
- Denise Birchmore sent a letter to Robert Devine. In the letter, Denise Birchmore thanked the Stoughton Police Department, and in particular Devine, for running the police Explorers program. Source
- Sandra Birchmore sent Matthew Farwell a Facebook friend request. Farwell rejected the request. Source
- Matthew Farwell received formal narcotics investigation training. Source
-
2:25 PM, the Stoughton Police Department published a photograph of Sandra Birchmore participating in a group physical training exercise with the Stoughton Police Explorers. The department announced that its 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Class was underway, posting: “And the 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Class is off and running!!!” Source
- Sandra Graduated from Stoughton High School. Source
-
Sandra Birchmore participated in the 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Class final examination. The photograph shows participants conducting an exercise involving a vehicle in a parking lot, with a marked Stoughton Police cruiser nearby. The department subsequently congratulated the class on completing its final examination. Source
- 10:48 AM, the Stoughton Police Department published a photograph from the previous evening’s final examination, announcing: “Last night 13th explorers class had their ‘final exam’ well done class!” The post included the hashtag #graduation. Source
- Sandra Birchmore participated in the 13th Stoughton Police Explorers Academy graduation ceremony. Source
- The Stoughton Police Department published a photograph showing Sandra and two fellow Explorers holding their certificates of recognition.
- The department congratulated the graduating class, posting: “13th SPD Explorers Academy Graduation! Well done!” Source
- Shortly after graduating from Stoughton High School, Sandra Marie Birchmore began basic training for the U.S. Army Reserve. Motivated by a strong sense of service and a desire to gain experience that would support her ultimate goal of becoming a police officer, Sandra saw military training as a vital step in her career path.
- Police Chief Paul Shastany placed Devine on administrative leave while an internal affairs consultant looked into the matter
- Sandra had returned home. She told those around her that she had been discharged from service due to asthma, a medical condition that prevented her from completing the rigorous demands of basic training.
- Sandra’s notebook entries documented an ongoing relationship and sexual activity with Farwell during August 2015. Source
- Sandra wrote a handwritten letter concerning a different romantic partner named “Matt.” Sandra’s writings therefore reference more than one person named Matt. Source
- Sandra wrote another handwritten letter concerning the same romantic partner named “Matt.” Source
- Devine resumed service as a patrol officer after the agreed-upon suspension period. Source
- Sandra Birchmore enrolled at Massasoit Community College in Brockton to pursue an Associate’s Degree in Criminal Justice
- Denise Birchmore suffered a stroke. Source
- Denise F. (McKain) Birchmore, 52, died at the Tufts Medical Center in Boston after a long illness. Source
- Sandra Marie Birchmore experienced another profound tragedy: the death of her grandmother, Claire G. Coughlin Gaudet. Mrs. Gaudet was the aunt of the late Denise Birchmore. This loss came just one month after the death of her mother, Denise F. McKain Birchmore, who passed away in May 2016. Source
Stoughton High School Class 2015 – Sandra Birchmore
June 4, 2015, Sandra graduated from high school – Stoughton High School Class of 2015. High School Announcement
On June 4, 2015, Sandra graduated from Stoughton High School and proudly joined the Class of 2015. The ceremony marked the culmination of her high school journey, a time filled with learning, growth, and meaningful friendships. Sandra’s graduation celebrated her accomplishments and marked the start of a new chapter as she prepared to step into adulthood and pursue her goals. Source
2016 – Sandra Birchmore
May 18, 2016 Denise F. (McKain) Birchmore
Denise F. (McKain) Birchmore, 52, died Wednesday, May 18, 2016, at the Tufts Medical Center in Boston after a long illness. Born in Tewksbury, she was raised in Dorchester and Stoughton and graduated from Stoughton High School, Class of 1982.
Denise was a longtime Stoughton resident. Mrs. Birchmore worked as a payroll clerk at Howard Johnson’s in Milton for several years. She lost her husband, Warren Birchmore, in 1995. In her free time, she enjoyed spending time with her daughter Sandra Birchmore and her family. Source
June 24, 2016 – Sandra Birchmore
After Sandra Birchmore’s maternal grandmother, Grace Theresa Coughlin, died in 2001, Grace’s sister, Claire G. (Coughlin) Gaudet, stepped in and became an important maternal and grandmotherly figure in Sandra’s life. Claire was therefore Sandra’s great-aunt, not her biological grandmother. Claire was born in Boston and raised and educated in South Boston. She lived in Stoughton for more than 50 years and was a homemaker. She enjoyed crossword puzzles, shopping, trips to D.W. Field Park in Brockton, the beach, Castle Island, and spending time with her family. Source Claire died unexpectedly at Brockton Hospital on June 24, 2016, at age 89. She was the wife of the late Gerald V. Gaudet and the aunt of Alice McKain and Darlene Smith. Claire’s death came just over a month after Sandra’s mother, Denise Birchmore, died on May 18, 2016. SourceSandra Birchmore case file
June 24, 2016- Sandra took the Massachusetts Civil Service exam and was placed on the eligibility list for the Stoughton police force. (Note: According to The Globe)
- Sandra’s mother died following a serious illness. Sandra was 19 years old.
- Approximately one month later, Sandra’s grandmother also died.
- Sandra was deeply affected by both losses and disclosed to Lindsey Crean that she had engaged in cutting her arms.
- Sandra subsequently contacted her former therapist, Diala Alkahalil, seeking to resume treatment.
- Alkahalil initially had a full caseload but agreed to assess Sandra after Sandra said she would not see another therapist.
- Sandra reported grief, panic attacks, difficulty getting out of bed, and drinking more alcohol than she wanted as a way of coping.
- Alkahalil began seeing Sandra weekly.
- Her diagnoses during this treatment period included ADHD, anxiety disorder, and panic disorder.
- Alkahalil believed Sandra experienced a period of symptoms consistent with major depressive disorder near 2016.
- Sandra discussed difficulty adjusting to life without her mother and grandmother, her principal sources of support.
- Sandra was also involved in a relationship with William Kilroy around the period following her mother’s death.
- Alkahalil’s notes showed a previous incident, before 2016, in which Sandra had swallowed pills, including a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medication, and immediately vomited them.
- Sandra wrote a journal entry expressing serious suicidal thoughts while struggling with grief. Source
- Her journals and notebooks were later preserved as evidence in the federal case. Source
- Sandra experienced family conflict, including a dispute that led her aunt to require her to leave the home. She documented family difficulties in a journal. Source
- Sandra reconnected with Donyea Holloway, who returned to Massachusetts and worked as a Navy recruiter in Quincy to discuss military career opportunities and renew their friendship. Source
- William Farwell becomes a Stoughton police officer. Source
- Sandra Birchmore began employment with JLW Donuts, LLC at a Dunkin’ Donuts store located at 5 Stockwell Drive, Avon, Norfolk County, Massachusetts. Source
- Sandra Birchmore wrote a handwritten page titled “ways to do it,” listing numerous methods of suicide. Beneath it, she wrote “why do it?” and listed reasons including feeling unwanted, believing no one cared, feeling “used,” “treated like shit,” a burden and an inconvenience, having “no purpose,” feeling like a failure, and believing she was not acknowledged or recognized for anything she did well. She also wrote “abuse take → like a punching bag” and “I’m a speck.” On a separate “why not to?” list, Sandra identified reasons to live, including being almost done with school, the possibility that someone cared, having a house, food and heat, her math tutor, friends and family, “kitty friends,” being in shape, having goals, and affirmations including “I’m wonderful” and “I’m amazing.” Source
- Sandra wrote a handwritten note dated 7/1/17 beginning, “To whom it may concern,” apologizing to people who might be hurt and writing that she did not feel she had “a place here any longer.” She wrote that she had been “treated like shit” and did not have the support system she needed, asked loved ones to cherish their memories with her, and concluded, “Please don’t grieve me but celebrate my life.” Source
- Sandra Birchmore left work early due to illness. Source
- Birchmore suffered a medical incident while working at the Dunkin’ Donuts store. Sandra Birchmore received medical care. Source
- JLW Donuts terminated Birchmore’s employment. A manager texted Birchmore, “Your off the schedule.” Source
- Records document a suicide attempt involving Sandra. Additional reports and emails concerning the incident were created the same day. Source
-
Sandra contacted Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara about obtaining a license to carry a firearm. McNamara did not help Sandra obtain the license. Source
- Sandra Birchmore filed a civil complaint in Norfolk Superior Court against JLW Donuts, LLC. Source
- Birchmore alleged:
- Disability discrimination under Massachusetts General Laws c. 151B, § 4(16).
- Violation of Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
- Negligence.
- Intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- Negligent infliction of emotional distress.
- Retaliation and discipline under Massachusetts earned sick time law, G.L. c. 148, § 149C(h).
- Additional records concerning Sandra’s mental-health history were created. Source
- Sandra Birchmore graduated from Massasoit Community College with an associate’s degree in criminal justice. Source
- Sandra Birchmore was listed among the Stoughton graduates in Massasoit Community College’s Class of 2018. The graduation list was published by The Patriot Ledger in its June 2-3, 2018 edition as part of its coverage of Massasoit Community College’s 51st commencement ceremony. Source
- A stipulation of dismissal with prejudice was filed in Norfolk Superior Court in Sandra Birchmore v. JLW Donuts, LLC, Civil Action No. 1882CV00253. Source
- The case resulted in a $12,500 settlement, with $5,000 paid in legal fees and $7,500 received by Sandra. Source
- Later, Sandra worked as an Uber Driver to support herself.
- Sandra asked Lindsey Crean about potentially co-signing a vehicle purchase.
- Crean declined because she did not believe her own credit was sufficient.
- Sandra and Farwell were engaged in an active sexual relationship. Their surviving electronic communications begin during this period and continue through Sandra’s death. The records document more than 50 meetings between them over the next 23 months, many while Farwell worked as a Stoughton police officer. Source
- A University of Massachusetts Dartmouth Police Department report concerning Sandra was created while she was attending UMass Dartmouth. Source
- UMass Dartmouth completed a mental-health concern form concerning Sandra. Source
- Sandra Birchmore and Matthew Farwell exchanged sexually explicit messages about when their attraction began. Sandra said she had wanted a sexual relationship with Farwell from the first time she saw him but had been scared. Farwell responded with an explicit description of how he would have reacted. Source
- Sandra and Farwell discussed having a child together. Farwell told Sandra that he did not object to her stopping birth control and reassured her that he would continue having sex with her if she became pregnant. Source
- Farwell reminded Sandra in text messages that he had ejaculated inside her “for years” and had asked her to stop taking birth control. Source
- Sandra told Farwell she was afraid he would not support her if she became pregnant. Their text exchange continued to address what would happen if Sandra became pregnant. Source
- Sandra took the Massachusetts Civil Service exam and was placed on the eligibility list for the Stoughton police force. (Note: According to the Globe)
- Sandra Birchmore met Joshua Heal when she came to the shelter to adopt a cat. They became friends and later engaged in a consensual sex act once after working hours at the animal shelter. Sandra began confiding in him about intimate details of her life, including her relationship with Farwell brothers and Devine. According to Joshua, they engaged in a consensual sex act once after working hours at the animal. Joshua Heal is friends with Sandra on Facebook
- Sandra lost her favorite aunt, Alice.
- Farwell attended a Massachusetts State Police homicide conference that included training on investigating hanging deaths. The training covered ligature furrows, knot placement, and the fact that complete suspension is not required for death to occur in a hanging. Source
- Sandra completed a UMass Dartmouth leave-of-absence form. Source
- UMass Dartmouth issued a letter concerning Sandra’s leave of absence. Source
- At age 22, Sandra Birchmore contacted Jason Pickard through Facebook. Source
- .Pickard responded with a standard U.S. Army recruitment message.
- Their conversation included military recruitment paperwork, Sandra’s allergies, and questions about which recruiter she had worked with previously.
- Pickard was married at the time.
- Sandra and Jason Pickard began a sexual relationship. Source
- They communicated through Facebook, text messages, and Snapchat. Their relationship and communication continued until Sandra’s death in February 2021. Source
- Sandra told Pickard that she had been sexually involved with Matthew Farwell since she was a minor. Source
- Sandra said she met Farwell when she was 13 and that he had taken her virginity when she was approximately 15 or 16. Source
- She identified Farwell as a married Stoughton police officer. Source
- Pickard encouraged Sandra to report the relationship. He did not report it himself, explaining that he feared the consequences for his military career because he was married with children and his relationship with a recruit violated military rules. Source
- Sandra discussed her family history, including that she had never known her father and that her mother and grandmother had died. Source
- Sandra also described engaging in self-harm around the time of her grandmother’s death, including cutting her thighs and, to a lesser extent, her arms. Source
- Pickard described Sandra as outgoing, sweet, straightforward, and sometimes demanding of attention. He said she experienced financial difficulties and lived paycheck to paycheck. Source
-
Sandra Birchmore reported that her last menstrual period began on December 3, 2020, and that she was trying to conceive. She also discussed a family history of twins with her physician. Source
- During a text-message exchange, Farwell acknowledged taking Sandra’s virginity when she was 15 years old. Their surviving messages also contained discussions of earlier sexual contact between them. Source
- Sandra sent Matthew Farwell an emotional message expressing anxiety, distress, and fear that he would be angry with her. She referred to “KMS,” which stands for “kill myself”, she apologized repeatedly, and said she was afraid Farwell would hate her after they spoke. Source
- Matthew Farwell texts Birchmore, “I’m going to sneak away from work quick.” This is part of an alleged pattern in which Farwell would shirk his police duties while on the clock to meet up with Birchmore.
- Sandra exchanged Facebook messages with Lindsey Crean about family conflict, financial difficulties, and her desire to establish an independent household. Source
- Sandra described feeling emotionally overwhelmed and said she wanted a family of her own.
- Sandra said the COVID-19 pandemic had disrupted her ability to work and save money.
- Sandra discussed her aunt’s plans to move and said she would not be permitted to move with her.
- Sandra expressed frustration that her aunt considered her an adult and no longer her responsibility.
- Sandra discussed wanting to move out and save money for an apartment.
- Stoughton Police were called to 40 Holbrook Avenue, Sandra’s family residence. A CAD dispatch log, call records, and a police report concerning Sandra were created. Records from the same date also include an application for Sandra’s involuntary hospitalization. Source
- 2:02 p.m., Sandra Birchmore was discharged from a hospital emergency department. Sandra communicated with Farwell while she was at the hospital. She told him that her aunt had called the police, resulting in her being taken to the emergency department. Sandra denied being suicidal, expressed anger over the situation, and said her aunt had told her to leave and find somewhere else to stay. Sandra described Farwell as her “best friend,” said she urgently needed his emotional support, and told him she wanted to see him later that day to explain what had happened. Source
- Sandra contacted her therapist, Diala Alkahalil, during a conflict with her aunt, Darlene Smith.
- Sandra said her aunt was attempting to have her involuntarily hospitalized under Massachusetts law.
- Sandra was transported to a hospital in Brockton for a mental health evaluation.
- Sandra told Alkahalil that she had been evaluated and discharged after several hours.
- During their subsequent conversation, Sandra denied experiencing suicidal thoughts. Source
- The police were called to Sandra Birchmore’s home for a well-being check. Source
- A dispatcher informed the officers that Birchmore was expressing a desire to harm herself, according to police radio call recordings.
- According to police records and information disclosed by a friend, on that day, Birchmore had gotten into a fight with a family member, who called the police and reported Birchmore was going to harm herself. The police took Birchmore to the hospital, where she was evaluated and deemed not at risk for self-harm. She was released a few hours later. IA Report
- Sandra was transported by ambulance to a hospital after reportedly being found unconscious. The existing case chronology associates the incident with possible anxiety, but the medical cause is not established by the trial reporting reviewed. Source
- In a message to Matthew Farwell, Sandra described being in tears, struggling emotionally, and experiencing severe anxiety. She used “KMS” in the message while telling Farwell she was scared he would be angry with her and “hate me after we talk.” Source
- Sandra Birchmore underwent shoulder surgery. Source
-
Matthew Farwell saved a draft letter in the Notes app on his phone addressed to a senator or representative about proposed changes to Massachusetts laws affecting police officers. The draft included the statement, “Chokeholds are nonlethal.” Farwell was serving as a police union president. Source
- Sandra Birchmore was hired at Sharon East Elementary School as a teacher’s aide, or instructional assistant. Source
- Sandra applied for housing and secured her own place. (Note: Statement from Apartment Complex manager)
- Sandra began working at Sharon East Elementary School, where she worked closely with a third-grade student. Source
- Sandra moved out of the family residence after learning that the home was being sold. She initially stayed with a friend, and then Sandra moved into a hotel temporarily before obtaining her apartment in Canton, Massachusetts. Source
- Sandra and Pickard resumed their sexual relationship after a period of separation during their approximately 14-month relationship. Source
- Joshua Heal informs Sandra Birchmore that Matthew Farwell’s wife is pregnant with the couple’s third child. He tells her the baby is expected to be born in February 2021
- In response: Birchmore states she intends to tell Farwell’s wife that he had been having sex with her for nearly ten years. Source
- That same day: Birchmore drafts a message addressed to Farwell’s wife
- She sends a copy of the drafted message to Joshua Heal
- 7:00 PM – Farwell allegedly met Sandra in person while on duty and agreed to attempt to impregnate her. Prosecutors alleged that he made the agreement to prevent Sandra from disclosing his conduct. Source
- Sandra Birchmore presents Matthew Farwell with an ultimatum regarding their relationship. Source
- According to court records: Birchmore tells Farwell he must agree to engage in unprotected sex with the goal of conceiving a child. In return, she states she will not disclose their relationship. Source
- At the time, Birchmore had already disclosed to others that Farwell had been having sex with her since before she was 16 years old. She knew this conduct constituted a criminal offense. Birchmore also knew Farwell had been leaving work while on duty as a Stoughton police officer to meet her for sexual encounters. Source
- Sandra downloaded applications designed to track ovulation and menstrual cycles. Source
- Sandra Birchmore exchanged messages with Matthew Farwell about her plans to move into her own apartment and whether he wanted a key. Sandra wrote, “Once it’s all finalized, I’ll tell you where I’m going. Did you decide if you want a key?” Farwell said he didn’t think it was a good idea and asked whether she was living with someone. Sandra explained that her plans had changed and she had secured her own apartment because her friend was moving. Farwell reiterated that he did not think having a key was a good idea but said they could discuss it in person. Source
-
Sandra asked Matthew Farwell whether he would be comfortable if she became pregnant. Farwell replied that he was not comfortable but believed Sandra had left him no choice. The messages were presented to jurors during the federal trial. Source
- Sandra asked Farwell if they could try again that month or whether they would need to talk “in person about that.” Farwell responded, “That’s an in-person discussion.” Source
- Farwell and Birchmore discussed an upcoming sexual encounter: Birchmore asked Farwell if he had given any more thought to their prior conversation and told him that she thought of a way they could both be happy. Source
- Apartment-leasing records document Sandra’s efforts to obtain her own housing. Source
- Sandra completed an application for an apartment at Canton Woods. Source
- About 21 minutes after the foregoing text messages, Farwell told Birchmore he was at her apartment, and subsequent text messages indicate she let him in.
- Approximately 25 minutes later, Birchmore asked Farwell via text message whether he enjoyed having vaginal sex with her again, and he responded, “yeah.”
- Birchmore asked Farwell if he would be on duty when they were scheduled to meet. Farwell responded by texting her, “Yes, I will be on the clock.”
- Sandra spoke with Robert Devine, aka Marty Riggs, via Facebook Messenger. Source
- Sandra Birchmore wrote a handwritten breakup letter to Matthew Farwell.
- Sandra Birchmore signed a residential lease agreement for an apartment at Canton Woods in Canton, Massachusetts. The lease began on December 1, 2020, and was scheduled to end on November 30, 2021. Source
- She was excited about having her own residence and showed Pickard her one-bedroom apartment. Note: The date is approximate and based on testimony presented during trial. The exact date has not been independently established. Source
- Pickard visited her apartment, sometimes contacting her by text or through the building’s entry system. Note: The date is approximate and based on testimony presented during trial. The exact date has not been independently established. Source
- Sandra provided Pickard with the building’s entry code.
- Pickard remembered Sandra wearing an arm sling in a photograph. A flamingo pendant was visible in that photograph; Sandra’s family later recovered a broken flamingo pendant from the floor.
-
Sandra’s last menstrual period began on this date, according to the history she subsequently provided to Dr. Priyanka Venkataraman. Source
- During a medical appointment, Sandra reported that she was trying to conceive and identified December 3, 2020, as the first day of her last menstrual period. She told her physician that her mother and partner were twins, information documented as part of her reproductive history. Source
- Sandra Birchmore texted Rebecca Chandler that she needed to tell her how a doctor’s appointment had gone. Source
- Chandler asked whether Sandra was pregnant. Sandra responded, “Hopefully.” Source
- Sandra spoke via Facebook Messenger with Robert Devine, who was on duty for the Stoughton Police Department. He asked Birchmore to meet him at the Chateau restaurant. When Devine arrived, he sent Sandra another message asking her where she was; she indicated she was on the way. Source
- Sandra informed therapist Diala Alkahalil that she was pregnant and identified Matthew Farwell as the father.
- Sandra was extremely excited and immediately began planning for motherhood.
- She discussed baby clothes, a baby shower, a stroller, a pregnancy announcement, a gender reveal, and future activities with her child.
- Sandra wanted to teach her child Spanish.
- Sandra discussed raising the baby as a single mother if necessary.
- Sandra considered applying for public assistance, Section 8 housing, or a housing voucher.
- Sandra wanted her child to have a father figure because she had grown up without knowing her own father.
- Alkahalil considered Sandra’s pregnancy, attachment to her cats, future plans, and engagement in treatment to be important protective factors.
- Sandra continued expressing hope about her future despite financial difficulties and relationship problems.
- A blood test confirmed Sandra Birchmore’s pregnancy. The medical record described her as approximately one to two weeks pregnant
- 9:30 p.m. Sandra Birchmore and Matthew Farwell exchanged messages about her pregnancy. Sandra informed him that she was approximately 3.5 weeks pregnant and was uncertain when conception had occurred. She sent him a photo of a poster she had made to celebrate the pregnancy. Sandra insisted that Farwell participate in decisions concerning the baby and sign the birth certificate. She expressed anger about his response and threatened to tell his wife about the pregnancy. Farwell refused to discuss the situation through text messages and objected to being contacted while working. Source
- Sandra contacted Shauna Eck about arranging her hair for maternity photographs. She said she had learned she was pregnant the previous day, asked whether she would need a fresh haircut, and said she intended to invite Eck to the baby shower. Source
- Sandra contacted Mackenzie Palma, a childhood friend who sold custom artwork, about designing a pregnancy-announcement sign. Sandra provided reference designs and detailed feedback. She also requested custom baby clothing. Palma subsequently made a onesie bearing the words “made with love.” The exact dates of the order and completion were not established in the reporting reviewed. Source
- Sandra prepared a letter to Matthew Farwell from the perspective of their expected baby. The letter asked him to stay involved, help raise the child, help choose a name, and participate in their lives. Sandra offered him an apartment key and promised to accommodate his expectations
- Later: Farwell visited Sandra at her apartment. Sandra showed him a pregnancy poster she had made for him. Source
- After the meeting, Sandra texted Farwell that something he did during the visit made her afraid of him. Farwell accused Sandra of manipulation, extortion, and blackmail. Sandra expressed emotional distress and questioned whether it would have been better if she had never been born. Farwell stated that he should have walked away and let Sandra hurt herself. Sandra responded, “Okay, maybe I will hurt myself then.” Source
- Sandra also communicated with at least three friends about the encounter and expressed concerns for herself and her unborn child. She told one friend that Farwell grabbed her phone, took her computer, and shoved her. Source
December 30, 2020Sandra Birchmore: it made me really uncomfortable and stressed out and scared when you were next to me because I thought you were gonna hit me after you said what you said and took things out of my hand. That’s why I was crying. I know you wouldn’t but it still scared me.
- Sandra visited a hair salon to prepare for a New Year’s Eve celebration. Source
- Sandra Birchmore informed Matthew Farwell that she and her cousin had finalized matters concerning a legal dispute. Sandra stated that her attorney believed she would be satisfied with a proposed counteroffer and knew she would not accept less than $10,000. She asked Farwell to review the offer later that day. Source
- Note: During Farwell’s federal trial on October 19, 2026, testimony identified a separate legal action involving the sale of Sandra’s mother’s home, which resulted in Sandra receiving $10,000
- Matthew Farwell became noticeably stressed and flustered toward the end of 2020 and into early 2021. Source
- Stoughton Police Detective Daniel Barber observed Farwell texting incessantly, taking telephone calls outside Barber’s presence, and leaving rooms to speak on the phone. Barber and Farwell were close friends who worked together, traveled for police business, and socialized outside work. Barber described Farwell as a very straightforward police officer. Source
- During a work trip to Taunton to serve a warrant, Barber noticed Farwell repeatedly texting and asked whether everything was okay. Source
- According to Barber, Farwell repeatedly said, “I got to put crazy back in the bag,” and reassured himself that everything would be all right. Source
- Farwell was his training officer when he joined the Stoughton Police Department and never mentioned Sandra Birchmore. Source
- Barber was vice president of the Stoughton Police union while Farwell served as president. Source
-
Sandra contacted Karlie Williams, a former schoolmate, seeking assistance shoveling snow from around her vehicle. Source
-
Sandra disclosed that she was pregnant and asked Williams to keep the information confidential. Source
-
Sandra explained that her cousin had been helping with her cats’ litter boxes but was ill with COVID-19. She asked Williams whether she could help. Williams could not assist with the litter boxes because of her work schedule and upcoming vacation. She did not intend to charge Sandra for snow-removal assistance. Source
- Sandra informed Jason Pickard that she was pregnant. Source
- Pickard initially responded, “Congratulations?”
- Pickard was concerned that he might be the father because they had been sexually involved.
- Sandra repeatedly assured him that he was not the father and identified Matthew Farwell instead.
- Pickard described Sandra as ecstatic and joyful about the pregnancy. She frequently discussed becoming a mother.
- Sandra told Pickard that Farwell’s reactions to the pregnancy fluctuated between anger and excitement.
- Pickard became concerned about Sandra’s safety because of the behavior she described.
- Date clarification: Medical records presented during trial established that a blood test confirmed Sandra’s pregnancy on December 28, 2020. The exact date she informed Pickard has not been established.
- Sandra told Joshua Heal that Matthew Farwell regularly visited her apartment while on duty and had been there the previous week. Heal suggested Farwell would distance himself after the baby was born, and Sandra agreed she expected this. Source
- Sandra proposed a new parenting arrangement to Matthew Farwell. She offered not to require him to sign the birth certificate if the child could have his surname. She also offered not to move to Stoughton or Easton and requested that he see the child around holidays and attend the birth. However, he told her he would not discuss that issue via text message. Source
- Sandra researched and contacted attorneys concerning custody and financial support as she considered becoming a single mother. She told Farwell that she expected him to participate in the child’s life. Farwell increasingly refused to discuss baby-related matters by text and told Sandra they would discuss them in person. Source
- Sandra Birchmore told Matthew Farwell that she was going to the doctor the next day and asked if he wanted to know how the appointment went. Farwell did not directly respond to that question. Source
- Sandra attended prenatal appointments and received an ultrasound. An obstetric ultrasound record documented a gestational sac, yolk sac, fetal heart rate of 167 beats per minute, and estimated gestational age of 7 weeks and 6 days, with an estimated delivery date of September 9, 2021. Source
- Sandra researched baby names, planned a pregnancy announcement and gender reveal, researched baby-shower venues and newborn photographers, purchased a car seat and baby clothes, and ordered a handmade birth-announcement canvas and personalized onesies. Sandra told at least 85 people that she was pregnant. Source
- Sandra Birchmore asked Matthew Farwell to come to her apartment to discuss her estimated due date, the anticipated week of her first ultrasound, her conversation with her doctor, and her first prenatal appointment. Farwell did not directly respond to her request. Source
- Birchmore also began asking Farwell questions about what their family would look like following the birth of their child. Source
- Sandra Birchmore and Matthew Farwell Messages:
- 11:19:15 AM, Sandra told Farwell she had done a lot of thinking and, if he was willing to give in on certain areas, she was willing to be “extremely flexible.” Source
- 11:21:21 AM, Farwell told Sandra he never said she was not trying. At 11:21:28 AM, he asked what she had come up with. Source
- 11:22:17 AM, Sandra proposed that Farwell would not have to sign the birth certificate if she could list him and the child could have his last name. She also agreed not to move to Stoughton or Easton. Source
- 11:23:24 AM, Sandra said she would not complain about holidays but wanted Farwell to visit a few days before Christmas and Easter so he could see what she gave the child. She said they could discuss financial support, but she wanted him to see the child. Source
- 11:24:06 AM, Sandra said she felt she was being as fair as possible and told Farwell she wanted him present for labor, adding that she was “standing my ground on” that request. Source
- 11:25:09 AM, Farwell responded, “Ok we can discuss this more in person.” Source
- 11:25:32 AM, Sandra asked whether the proposed arrangement sounded okay to him. At 11:26:16 AM, Farwell replied that it was a lot to think about and “so much more than you have ever asked for.” Source
- 11:26:50 AM, Sandra said she understood it was a lot and emphasized that she was trying, noting that previously she had asked Farwell to actually sign documents. Source
- 11:27:51 AM, Sandra told Farwell she was trying to be flexible and work with him rather than against him. Source
- 11:34:35 AM, Sandra told Farwell, “I hope you can come later.” At 11:40:17 AM, she added that what she was requesting was “still less than what any other girl would ask for.” Source
- Sandra Birchmore met with Matthew Farwell at her apartment to discuss the pregnancy. They ended up arguing. Farwell pushed her, shoved her, and put her in a chokehold, and Sandra kicked him out of her apartment. Source
- Sandra told Dylan John Michael that the person she believed was her baby’s father had reacted badly to the pregnancy. She described arguments, threats, and incidents that caused her to fear for the baby’s safety. She said she was trying to resolve matters without involving the courts. Source
- Sandra told Joshua Heal that Farwell had taken her phone and computer from her hands and had used his body weight against her. She said she would consider court action if similar incidents happened again. Source
- Sandra discussed possible custody and visitation disputes with a friend. She believed she would have sole custody because she and Farwell were not married or dating and discussed the possibility that his wife would learn about the pregnancy. Source
- Sandra searched online for information about epidural injections and whether the numbing needles administered beforehand were painful. Source
- Sandra told Jimmy Newell that efforts to resolve the situation had failed and that she expected a court dispute.
-
Sandra underwent another quantitative hCG blood test. Her level had increased to 9,954, consistent with a progressing early pregnancy. SourceDuring an argument at her apartment, Farwell allegedly shoved Sandra and placed her in a chokehold before she made him leave. This incident is based on Sandra’s subsequent account. Source
- Sandra Birchmore called Joshua Heal and stated that, after telling Matthew Farwell about the baby, Matthew Farwell told her that “he wished just would die and he wants nothing to do with the baby.” According to the information Birchmore shared, Farwell put Birchmore in a headlock and grabbed her cell phone from her hand. Joshua Heal told Birchmore to distance herself from Matthew Farwell because he was dangerous, a police officer, and clearly did not care about the law. However, Matthew Farwell was also aware that Birchmore appeared to be attached to Matthew Farwell because he had taken her virginity when she was 15 years old. Source
- Sandra met with William Farwell in the parking lot of her apartment building after midnight. Source
- Canton Woods issued a letter concerning Sandra’s apartment. Source
- Sandra searched online for Valentine’s Day pregnancy-announcement ideas, baby onesies, and Valentine’s-themed baby clothing. Source
- Sandra discussed the possibility that Farwell’s wife would discover the pregnancy during a conversation with Joshua Nee. She suggested that Farwell would not want to face her in court because of information she possessed. Source
- Sandra discussed child support with Jason Pickard and said she intended to seek full child support from Matthew Farwell.
- Sandra texted Pickard: “What I am asking for in child support is nothing compared to what I should be getting.”
- Pickard described Farwell’s behavior, as Sandra had related it, as erratic and inconsistent.
- Sandra spoke with her friend about money she promised to repay a few months earlier. After receiving no response from Birchmore, her friend became irritated and asked Sandra why she stopped responding only when she asked Birchmore to repay her. Source
-
Sandra told Matthew Farwell that he had until January 31 to determine how many babies she was carrying and agree to one of two unspecified options. Sandra had considered the possibility of twins because her mother and Farwell were both twins. Source
- 3:41 AM, Sandra Birchmore messaged her medical provider, expressing concern about spotting. She reported no pain or cramping and said the spotting began after sexual intercourse the previous Tuesday. Source
- 3:44 AM, Sandra searched online for “Why do girls spot during pregnancy?” She also searched for bleeding during pregnancy at six weeks and early miscarriage information.
- 3:46 AM, Sandra searched for a six-week pregnancy ultrasound. Source
- 3:59 AM, Sandra searched for miscarriage findings on a six-week ultrasound. Source
- 4:02 AM, Sandra searched for “Early miscarriage.” Source
- 4:03 AM, Sandra searched for “Spotting during pregnancy.” She continued searching for related information, including whether holding urine could cause spotting. Source
- 9:41 AM, Sandra searched for “Baby yolk sac.” Source
- 10:45 AM, a caregiver documented a telephone conversation with Sandra. She reported that she was no longer spotting and expressed concern about the possibility of twins. A repeat ultrasound was planned. Source
- An ultrasound showed that Sandra Birchmore’s pregnancy was progressing, with the fetus measuring approximately six weeks. Dr. Venkataraman described the pregnancy as viable at that time and estimated a due date of September 9, 2021. Sandra also had a perigestational, or subchorionic, hemorrhage, prompting recommendations to avoid strenuous activity and sexual intercourse. Source
- Sandra contacted Farwell about an ultrasound and uncertainty over whether a finding near the baby represented another gestational structure or a yolk sac. She told him that another examination was scheduled for the following Monday at 4:15 p.m. Source
- Farwell responded that he was working. Sandra accused him of treating her differently and said she was better off keeping him uninformed about the pregnancy. Source
- Sandra sent Farwell approximately 27 messages following her ultrasound, including an ultrasound photograph, before receiving a response. Source
- Sandra researched baby shower locations and themes, including venues in Hingham and Plymouth, Lakeview Pavilion, outdoor venues, and Disney-themed baby shower ideas. Source
-
9:59 PM, Sandra searched for the Simmons University academic calendar. Source
- Sandra Birchmore paid $1,957.57 in rent. Source
- Sandra conducted pregnancy-related internet searches, including questions about food safety, bleeding during pregnancy, and a dentist in Stoughton. Source
-
She searched for Planned Parenthood ultrasound services and nearby locations. Source
-
Sandra continued researching baby shower venues and fetal heartbeat information. Source
-
Sandra emailed a bridal shop. The supplied notes do not establish the message’s contents. Source
-
Sandra Birchmore contacted hairstylist Shauna McGrath to borrow money to buy an EpiPen. McGrath could not lend Sandra the money. Source
- Sandra searched for attorneys whose names had been provided through referrals from Jessica Katz.Source
- Sandra Birchmore’s pregnancy-related bleeding had substantially decreased by this date. Source
- 5:20 p.m. One of Sandra’s friends, Julia Perlin, called the Stoughton Police Department and reported that Sandra was having sex with Officer Matthew Farwell. A department employee informed Farwell about the call. Farwell angrily told the employee never to mention it to him again and not to tell anyone else. Source
- Later that day, Matthew sent Birchmore text messages revealing his extreme anger. He sent her a series of text messages with expletives, telling Birchmore he thought no one knew about their relationship, that she had no clue how bad this was, and that he did not know whether he needed to worry about other disclosures.
- During a telehealth appointment with OB-GYN Dr. Priyanka Venkataraman, Sandra Birchmore completed a mental health screening and received a score of 17 out of 30. Although Birchmore did not report suicidal ideation, the physician believed she required additional mental health treatment and prescribed sertraline (Zoloft). After Birchmore reported feeling jittery in the following days, Venkataraman advised temporarily reducing the dosage from 50 milligrams to 25 milligrams, with a longer-term treatment goal of 150 milligrams. Source
- Sandra called her friend and told her that she didn’t respond to her because she had hit her head on her car door and then again on the pavement and had to go to the hospital.
- Sandra exchanged messages with a friend, Lindsey Crean, about obtaining baby clothes and supplies and spoke to her about her concerning depression. Source
- Sandra asked when she could collect the items Crean had offered.
- Sandra began taking Zoloft (sertraline) for anxiety and depressive symptoms. Sandra had previously resisted psychiatric medication because of negative experiences with medication during childhood and concerns about her mother’s dependence on medication. Sandra agreed to try Zoloft because she wanted to protect her pregnancy and improve her mental health.
- Sandra took a sick day for her first ultrasound. Source
- Note: The ultrasound was taped to her fridge when police found her body.
- Sandra searched online for Babies“R” Us and information about whether a patient’s intestines are removed during a cesarean section.
- She had texted Matthew Farwell a picture of the hand-scrawled sign.
- Sandra Birchmore and a friend went to Walmart to buy a baby stroller for Birchmore’s future child. Sandra Birchmore was excited about the baby and asked her to be the child’s godmother. In the conversation, Sandra Birchmore told her the day prior that Matthew Farwell had gotten angry with her for showing him a fetal sonogram, and he said, “That’s not my child. I don’t want anything really to do with you,” and then Matthew Farwell pushed her to the ground. Source
- Sandra searched for family-law and probate attorneys in her area. Source
- 8:15 p.m. Sandra asked Matthew Farwell when he would arrive at her apartment. Farwell said he would be there shortly and had purchased a soda for her. Source
- Farwell visited Sandra’s apartment for approximately one hour. Afterward, Sandra thanked him for coming and expressed hope that they could forgive each other and continue discussing their situation. Source
- Sandra offered to show Farwell how to enter the apartment building using the lobby keypad, so she would not have to come downstairs each time. She also offered to make him an apartment key, and Farwell agreed. Source
- During the visit, Farwell opened Sandra’s closet, looked inside her bathroom, and questioned why she had a doll. Source
- Sandra Birchmore exchanged messages with Rebecca Chandler concerning a visit by Matthew Farwell. Sandra wrote that Farwell had brought her ginger ale and expressed hope that the evening would go well. Sandra also told Chandler that she was consulting an attorney that day. Source
- 11:16 p.m., Sandra messaged Joshua Heal, “he asked for me for a key tonight for my apartment, not how I expected things to go.” Sandra told friends that Farwell had done a “complete 180.” Source
- 11:10 a.m. Sandra Birchmore paid $2.00 to have a key copied after Matthew Farwell requested a key for Birchmore’s apartment. Source
- Sandra gave him the passcode to her building’s front door and told him, “I have your key too when you want it.” Source
- Sandra told Jayson Pickard that Farwell’s behavior had changed dramatically during his visit the previous night. She said he had requested a key, discussed remaining involved with the baby if their situation remained secret, and brought her a birth certificate. Sandra believed he might be willing to sign it. Pickard expressed concern about Farwell’s behavior and communicated those concerns to Sandra. Source
- Sandra Birchmore exchanged messages with Becca Chandler about her recent interaction with Matthew Farwell. When Chandler asked whether things had gone well with him, Sandra replied, “It went well. He asked if he could have a key. He admitted I have the upper hand in the situation, which isn’t a good thing, but I’m not going to be that person.” When Chandler asked whether Sandra had made him a copy of the key, Sandra confirmed that she had but had not yet given it to him. Sandra also described Farwell’s behavior during a visit to her apartment the previous night, stating that he had opened her closet door, looked into her bathroom, and questioned why she had a doll. Sandra described the interaction as “weird” but said she was not upset. She explained that she had warned Farwell about the condition of her apartment and that she would need to rearrange everything because of the baby. Source
- Jason Pickard visited Sandra’s Canton apartment to help her prepare the residence for her baby, including babyproofing. Source
- This was the last time Pickard saw Sandra in person.
- Sandra discussed raising her child without the father’s involvement.
- Pickard reassured her that a newborn would not immediately be walking or talking and that she had time to prepare.
- Pickard described Sandra as anxious about becoming a single mother but did not consider her depressed.
- Sandra had not told Pickard that she was suicidal.
- Sandra Birchmore underwent a follow-up ultrasound examination establishing a gestational age of 7 weeks and 4 days. She reported anxiety and discussed a history of depression. Source
- Sandra was advised to continue pelvic rest, including avoiding sexual intercourse, and to report changes in bleeding or other symptoms. Source
- Sandra’s internet searches concerned miscarriage, spotting, ultrasounds, and pregnancy-related medical information. Source
- Sandra searched for a TEAS practice examination associated with admission to nursing and allied-health programs. She scheduled an examination through Assessment Technologies for February 6, 2021, for $113.69. Source
- Sandra contacted attorney Jessica Katz about probate-court representation and the cost of legal assistance. She explained that attempts to reach an agreement outside court were not working. Source
- Sandra Birchmore searched for baby names, including girl names, boy names, and middle names for “Madison” or “Mackenzie.” Sandra subsequently contacted Farwell. Source
- Sandra contacted Farwell to discuss possible baby names and asked for his input. Farwell did not respond to her messages about names. Source
- 8:45 p.m. Sandra continued researching baby names for 2021. Source
- Sandra searched online for information about how the uterus shrinks after childbirth. Source
-
Sandra asked Farwell whether they would see each other that evening and whether she should delay taking medication. Farwell explained that he was responding to a death while working and would let her know whether he was available. Source
- Sandra arranged a hair appointment for February 13 at 10:30 a.m. in preparation for a Valentine’s Day pregnancy announcement planned for February 14. Source
- Dr. Priyanka Venkataraman had her final documented communication with Sandra Birchmore. She requested that Sandra schedule another ultrasound and reiterated the recommendation to avoid sexual intercourse. Her pregnancy was considered high risk, and a referral to maternal-fetal medicine was being considered. Source
- Sandra contacted Karlie Williams again seeking help shoveling snow around her vehicle. Source
- 10:07 p.m., Farwell contacted Sandra to ask whether she was awake. Sandra confirmed that he could enter the building using code 4321, explaining that it was a general building code. Source
- Farwell visited Sandra’s apartment for approximately 40 minutes. Afterward, Sandra thanked him for the visit. Source
-
Following the visit, Sandra discussed anal intercourse with Farwell and searched online for ways to reduce pain during that activity.
-
Sandra communicated with Massasoit Community College admissions counselor Kathleen Beard about application materials and received confirmation that the required documents were available in her admissions portal. Source
-
Sandra and Farwell met at her apartment. Sandra was under doctor-ordered pelvic rest. During the visit, Farwell asked whether the apartment-door code Sandra had given him was unique to her apartment or whether other residents used the same code. Source
- Birchmore asked Farwell if she could tell him some of the baby names she is considering. Farwell says that he would rather discuss that in person. Source
- Sandra searched for gender-neutral baby onesies, children’s rain boots, Disney-themed clothing, infant bedding, and nursery organization supplies. Source
- 8:54 p.m. Sandra placed two orders through Kohl’s for baby-related merchandise. Source
-
Sandra contacted a photography business to inquire about newborn photography prices and discussed her tentative due date. Source
- Sandra registered and paid for a standardized test scheduled for February 6, 2021, at Massasoit Community College. She communicated with her obstetrician and gynecologist and scheduled future appointments, met with her therapist and scheduled additional appointments, researched baby names, communicated with a child-custody attorney, and booked a hair appointment for a planned Valentine’s Day pregnancy announcement and gender reveal. Source
- Sandra saw a Therapist. During this session, she was screened for depression and suicidal ideation, and the therapist concluded there were no signs of depression or suicidal ideation. Source
- Note: Throughout January 2021, Sandra’s counseling sessions with Diala Alkahalil increased from once weekly to twice weekly because of increased anxiety and emotional stress.
- Sandra was experiencing three principal stressors: grief over the absence of her mother and grandmother during pregnancy, fear of miscarriage, and conflict with Matthew Farwell.
- Sandra told Alkahalil that Farwell had initially wanted to conceive a child with her but was now disputing paternity.
- Sandra continued identifying Farwell as the father.
- Sandra discussed disputes over the birth certificate, financial support, and Farwell’s possible involvement in the child’s life.
- Sandra told Alkahalil that Farwell had pushed her during an argument at her apartment.
- Sandra also disclosed that Farwell had requested a key to her apartment and had not previously possessed one.
- Sandra remained focused on motherhood, nursing school, and preparing her home.
- Sandra was concerned about the possible effects of psychiatric medication during pregnancy but became willing to try treatment to protect herself and the baby.
- Sandra told Farwell that the school where she worked would dismiss early the next day because of the approaching blizzard. She asked whether he could shovel her car out. Farwell said he would not be available but did not tell Sandra that his wife was scheduled for a cesarean section early on February 2, 2021. Sandra Birchmore continued arranging snow-removal assistance with Karlie Williams, providing a description of her vehicle and a photograph showing where it was parked. Source
- 11:57 AM Sandra spoke with Daniel J. Source
- 7:16 PM Sandra called Daniel. Source
- 12:19 PM Birchmore sent Matthew Farwell text messages saying she would be released early (at 12:35 p.m.) from her job at Sharon Public Schools. Matthew Farwell told her that he would not be in the area that day. Source
- 12:35 PM: School Released Early. Once home, Sandra Birchmore ordered baby items. She used her computer; Birchmore had been taking classes to prepare to apply to nursing school. Source FBI Affidavit Source
- 12:51 p.m. Sandra entered her apartment building. She continued communicating with several people, including Farwell, and asked whether they would meet later in the week or whether he could come over that night. Farwell initially told her he was out of town but could “probably” meet later in the week. Source
- 1:25 p.m. She planned newborn photos, an official pregnancy announcement (which she planned to do on Valentine’s Day), and a gender reveal. She also planned for her immediate future, scheduling an OBGYN appointment for February 10, 2021, and had a load of wet clothes in the washing machine and another load drying in the dryer.
- 12:43 p.m. Sandra spoke by telephone with her aunt Darlene. The call lasted 18 minutes and 47 seconds. Source
- 1:10 p.m. Sandra returned to her apartment building. During the afternoon, Sandra searched online for information about dry mouth during pregnancy and bowel-related concerns during sexual activity. Source
- 1:31 p.m. During the afternoon, Sandra browsed baby items on Kohl’s website, ordered clothing, FaceTimed with a friend, spoke with her aunt by telephone, and ordered food through DoorDash. Source
- 4:43 p.m. Sandra placed a DoorDash dinner order. Source
- 4:52 PM, Stoughton Police Detective Sandra Barrett texted Matthew Farwell wishing him good luck with his wife’s planned cesarean section the following day. Farwell replied, “Thank you! Packing bags now. Lol.” Source
- 5:01 p.m. Sandra went to the lobby to retrieve a food delivery. Source
- 5:02 p.m. Sandra returned upstairs, resumed texting, submitted an admission form for Massasoit Community College, and reset her gas-company account password. Source
- 5:31 p.m., Sandra went outside with a snow brush. Her hair was in a bun, and she was wearing glasses. Source
- 5:33 p.m., Sandra returned with a snow brush. The last time Birchmore is seen alive on the video is on February 1, 2021, at 5:33 p.m. Source
- During the evening, Sandra used her phone and laptop to research an EMT/fire training course, baby names, pregnancy symptoms, and new vehicles. Source
- 6:00 p.m. Sandra charging her phone.
- 6:20 p.m. Sandra texted Farwell that she had received an early baby-shower gift. Source
- 6:32 p.m. and 7:49 PM, approximately 965 Instagram images were cached on Sandra’s device, including Boston Bruins images and two images concerning suicide. The forensic examination could not establish whether Sandra actually viewed the two suicide-related images. Source
- 6:57 p.m., Sandra searched online for “Cramping at 9 weeks.” Additional searches concerned nine-week pregnancy symptoms.
- 7:00 p.m. Sandra searched for information about cramping at nine weeks pregnant, pregnancy symptoms, Toyota Highlanders, and nearby automobile dealerships. Source
- 7:47 p.m. An image stored in Sandra’s iPhone cache was accessed. Source
- 7:55 p.m. A second cached image was accessed. The defense has identified the images as evidence concerning Sandra’s state of mind, while prosecutors dispute their relevance and characterization. Source
- 7:57 p.m. Birchmore texted a friend to obtain baby clothes from her. Source
- 8:25 p.m. Birchmore searched Google for “Cubby Kids” furniture. Source
- Sandra was doing laundry; she had the key to Matthew Farwell phone. Source
- 8:29 p.m. Sandra began a telephone conversation with Lesley Davis. The call lasted approximately 27 minutes, ending around 8:55 p.m. Source
- 9:00 p.m. Sandra spoke with a coworker asking for help shoveling out her car during the impending snowstorm. Source
- 9:03 p.m. that evening, she sent a message via Snapchat asking about a work schedule. Source
- 9:07 p.m. Farwell asked Sandra whether she was still awake and whether he could visit. Sandra agreed and told him the door would be open when he arrived. No further outgoing messages were recovered from Sandra’s phone after that exchange. Source
- 9:08 p.m. Farwell texted Sandra asking whether he could “come by for a second.” Source
- 9:10 p.m. Sandra replied that he could come over and told him her apartment door would be open. Source
- 9:10:43 p.m. Forensic records from Sandra Birchmore’s iPhone showed six steps recorded by the device.
- 9:13:37 p.m. Sandra’s cell phone locked. It was never unlocked again. Source
- 9:14:56 p.m. Farwell entered Sandra’s apartment building wearing a dark hoodie with the hood covering most of his head and a surgical mask. He avoided looking toward the ceiling-mounted surveillance camera while crossing the lobby. Source
- 9:18:03 p.m. Sandra’s locked phone captured a screenshot of its locked screen. Source
- 9:24 p.m. Sandra received a text message that remained unread. Subsequent messages also remained unread. Source
- 9:28 PM Sandra’s coworker replied to the Snapchat message, but Sandra did not open it.
- 9:40:19 p.m. Sandra’s phone recorded eight steps. The device never unlocked or recorded additional movement before Sandra was found dead three days later. Source
- 9:43:33 p.m. Farwell left Sandra’s apartment building, 29 minutes after entering. He was still wearing the hood and surgical mask and again avoided looking toward the surveillance camera. Source
Surveillance footage of Sandra Birchmore’s apartment complex, showing the last time she was seen alive and the last person to see her alive, Matthew Farwell, entering and leaving the building on February 1st, 2021.
Surveillance footage of Sandra Birchmore’s apartment complex, showing the last time she was seen alive and the last person to see her alive, Matthew Farwell, entering and leaving the building on February 1, 2021.
Weeks before Matthew Farwell arrived at Sandra Birchmore’s apartment, he instructed her to delete evidence of their sexual relationship, which included proof that he had raped her when she was 15 and had repeatedly engaged in sexual violence against her.
VIDEOMatthew Farwell told troopers he visited Birchmore’s apartment on the evening of February 1, 2021, telling her that he wasn’t the father of her baby, records show. Birchmore was upset, Farwell told the troopers, but didn’t make “any suicidal statements.”
“Matt said that he was straightforward in his conversation with her, and told her that it was all over and he was blocking her from all forms of communication,” Fanning wrote.
Surveillance footage from Birchmore’s apartment complex showed Matthew Farwell entering her apartment building and then exiting 28 minutes later, State Police records show.
READ MORESandra Birchmore
Surveillance Video – Matthew Farwell
February 1, 2021 – Matthew Farwell
On February 1, 2021, at 9:08 p.m., Farwell texted Birchmore to say he was on his way to her apartment. Despite his history of resisting COVID-19 mask mandates, he entered her apartment wearing a face mask. Once inside, Farwell murdered Birchmore, the 23-year-old pregnant woman he had exploited for years, by strangling her to death. Surveillance footage captured him leaving her apartment just minutes after committing the crime.
February 1, 2021: After leaving Sandra, Matthew Farwell drove to Newton-Wellesley Hospital, in a wealthy suburb 12 miles outside Boston, t see his wife at the hospital. On February 2, 2021, at 9:25 a.m., Michelle Farwell gave birth to a son.
Michelle Farwell gave birth to a baby boy at Newton-Wellesley Hospital
February 2, 2021 – 9:25 a.m. On the morning of February 2, 2021, at 9:25 a.m., Michelle Farwell gave birth to a baby boy at Newton-Wellesley Hospital, a well-regarded medical center located in a suburb about 12 miles outside of Boston. Her husband, Matthew Farwell, was by her side for the birth of their son, an event that would typically mark a joyful and intimate moment in a family’s life.
But that morning came under a cloud of growing concern. Just hours earlier, on February 1, surveillance cameras captured Matthew Farwell entering Sandra Birchmore’s apartment.
- Matthew Farwell sent an unusual message to a former Stoughton Police Department colleague asking whether the colleague was working and whether anything was happening at the department because Farwell was “bored as hell sitting in the hospital.” The witness told investigators this was the first and only time Farwell had shown interest in what was occurring at the department while he was off duty. Prosecutors cited the communication as evidence they contend is relevant to Farwell’s state of mind after Sandra’s death. Source
- 8:30 AM, Jason Pickard texted Sandra, “Are you okay?” Sandra did not respond. Source
- Sandra did not log in to work remotely. Source
- Karlie Williams texted Sandra Birchmore after not hearing from her. Sandra did not respond. Source
- Morning: Birchmore failed to show up for work, and a colleague called the police. School personnel attempted unsuccessfully to contact her before a school safety officer contacted police for a wellness check. Source
- 9:45 AM – Sharon Police School Resource Officer Michael Hocking contacted Canton School Resource Officer Ensley Cotard by cellphone and requested assistance conducting a well-being check on Sandra Birchmore. Hocking told Cotard that Sandra worked as an instructional assistant at East Middle School in Sharon, had not been coming to work or been seen or heard from for several days, was not responding to attempts to contact her, and school administrators could not reach the emergency contact they had on file. Hocking provided Sandra’s last known address as 3 Windsor Woods Lane in Canton but did not know her apartment number. Source
- Officer Cotard told Hocking that he would go to the Canton Woods leasing office, determine whether Sandra was a resident and, if confirmed, conduct a well-being check. Cotard then contacted Sergeant Michael Lank and advised him of the information and that he was responding to Canton Woods. Source
- 10:45 AM – Officer Cotard and assisting School Resource Officer Mike Brady spoke with Property Manager Erin Porter, who confirmed that Sandra lived in Apartment 3307. Porter stated that she had not seen or spoken with Sandra in several days. Porter attempted twice to call Sandra using the telephone number on file, but both calls went directly to voicemail. Source
- 11:00 AM – Officers Cotard and Brady knocked and announced their presence at Sandra’s apartment for several minutes but received no response. Cotard contacted Sergeant Lank, who instructed the officers to locate Sandra’s vehicle and, if it was present, enter the apartment. Lank provided the vehicle information: 2018 blue Chevrolet Cruze, Massachusetts registration 1YGB66. Source
- Officer Cotard located Sandra’s vehicle outside Building 3 and notified dispatch. Cotard and Brady observed snow on and around the vehicle that appeared undisturbed. Cotard noted that the most recent snowfall had occurred from February 1 into February 2. Sandra’s Sharon Public Schools identification card, bearing her name and photograph, was hanging from the rearview mirror. Source
- Officer Cotard requested a uniformed officer and obtained keys to Sandra’s apartment from Erin Porter. Officer Charles Yeaton arrived shortly afterward. The officers returned to Apartment 3307, again knocked and announced their presence several times, and received no response. Source
- Officers used the property-management key to enter Sandra’s apartment. They immediately observed that the apartment was disheveled and unkempt and that two cats were running around inside. Cotard first entered the bathroom, where the door was open and the lights were off, and cleared the room. Source
- Cotard then opened the closed bedroom door, where the lights were off, and found Sandra seated on the floor with what he described as a belt/lanyard/string/rope tightly around her neck and secured to the bedroom closet door handle. Cotard observed lividity of Sandra’s skin and face, rigor in her extremities, and a large pooling of dried blood around her mouth. Source
- Officer Yeaton contacted the Canton Police station and reported the discovery. Sergeant Lank instructed the officers to secure the scene, and the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office CPAC unit was notified and advised that it would respond. Source
- 11:09 AM – Detective Jonathan McCourt responded to Apartment 3307. Officers Yeaton, Cotard, and Brady told him Sandra was deceased and had apparently hanged herself. McCourt directed the officers to remain outside while he entered the apartment. Source
- McCourt observed Sandra seated on the bedroom floor with a dark-colored strap around her neck tied to the bedroom closet door handle. He documented obvious lividity of Sandra’s face, hands, and abdominal area and reported no visible trauma to her head or defensive abrasions on her hands. Source
- McCourt described the bedroom and apartment as unorganized and unkempt and reported observing no signs of a struggle. Source
- An ultrasound photograph bearing Sandra’s name and date of birth was visible on the kitchen counter. Source
- Sergeant Michael Lank arrived shortly after McCourt. Lank and McCourt were the only ones with access to the apartment while the scene was secured. Canton Fire/EMS, the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office/CPAC, the Massachusetts State Police, Crime Scene Services, and the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner were notified. Source
- While waiting for CPAC investigators, Sergeant Lank went to the rental office and met with Property Manager Erin Porter and Maintenance Supervisor Carlos Verissimo. Verissimo accessed the motion-activated surveillance system for Building 3, which captured the interior entrance. Source
- Sergeant Lank reviewed Sandra’s activity on the surveillance footage. He documented Sandra leaving the building at 9:51 AM while on the telephone, returning at 10:08 AM carrying a large box containing a baby car seat, leaving again at 10:11 AM, returning at 1:15 PM carrying two pizza boxes and talking on the telephone, leaving at 4:39 PM, and returning at 4:41 PM while texting on her telephone. Source
- Lank was subsequently informed by Verissimo that Sandra was captured on surveillance leaving the building again on Monday and returning at 5:46 PM while holding a snow brush. This was the last time Sandra was seen on the building’s surveillance footage. Source
- While reviewing the surveillance footage, Porter obtained Sandra’s tenant file and identified her aunt, Darlene Smith, as her emergency contact. Source
- 11:45 AM – Massachusetts State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne #3943 was notified by the Norfolk State Police Detective Unit desk officer that Canton Police officers and detectives were investigating the apparent suicide death of Sandra Birchmore. Dunne contacted Crime Scene Services and notified Trooper Kevin Tufts #4054, who was newly assigned to the unit and undergoing training. Dunne and Tufts proceeded to Sandra’s apartment. Source
- 11:46 AM – Canton Firefighter/Paramedic Daniel Whitley pronounced Sandra deceased. No lifesaving measures were performed. Whitley told Detective McCourt that he believed Sandra had been deceased for a few days. Source
- Troopers Dunne and Tufts arrived at the apartment and spoke with Sergeant Lank and Detective McCourt. Dunne learned that Sandra had not reported to work for several days, attempts to reach her by telephone had been unsuccessful, and Canton officers had entered the apartment with a key supplied by property management. Source
- Dunne observed a kitchenette immediately to the left of the apartment entrance, a living-room area directly ahead, a short hallway leading to the bathroom, and the single bedroom to the left of the hallway. He described the apartment as generally unorganized and unkempt. Source
- Dunne observed that the kitchenette countertops were almost completely covered with personal items, including postal correspondence, junk mail, medication, trash, and the ultrasound photograph. Source
- In the living room, Dunne observed trash and clumps of cat fur on the carpet and debris, trash, or personal belongings on virtually every horizontal surface. He documented two glass end tables, a dining-room table, a glass coffee table, couch, television stand and television, and a nook containing two recliners covered with personal effects and boxes. Source
- Dunne described the bathroom as generally neat and organized and reported finding nothing of note inside. Source
- In the bedroom, Dunne observed a desk lamp on and colored Christmas lights around the window. The room was cluttered and untidy, with items covering the desk and a plastic storage table with drawers. The bed was unmade, with a sheet over the mattress and the box spring exposed. Sandra’s eyeglasses were on top of the bed. Dunne also observed a U.S. Army ACU-pattern duffel bag among the bedroom items. Source
- Dunne reported finding no signs of a struggle in the apartment. He stated that despite the clutter, items appeared to be in their intended locations; nothing appeared knocked over or strewn about; the walls showed no scuff marks or indentations; and he observed no drag marks on the floor or carpeting. Source
- Sandra’s cellphone was found on the floor approximately 12 inches from her right hand and 6 inches from her right knee. Source
- Dunne examined Sandra for indications of physical abuse, including grab marks, scratches, markings consistent with being struck, and apparent defensive wounds. He reported finding none and documented no bruising, swelling, or external trauma. He also reported observing no markings on Sandra’s neck indicating an attempt or struggle to loosen or remove the ligature. Source
- Massachusetts State Police Crime Scene Services processed the apartment. Trooper Zach Clark #4097 documented Sandra and the scene with digital photographs. Source
- Officer Cotard contacted Officer Hocking and informed him that Sandra had been found deceased. Hocking said he would notify Sharon school administrators after receiving confirmation that Sandra’s next of kin had been notified. Hocking also told Cotard that he had contacted Stoughton School Resource Officer Sheanna Isabelle for information about Sandra before contacting Canton Police. Source
- Cotard contacted Officer Isabelle and informed her of Sandra’s death. Isabelle told Cotard she was familiar with Sandra, a former graduate and employee of Stoughton High School, and identified Sandra’s aunt, Darlene Smith, as the next of kin to contact. Source
- 12:44 PM – Officer Yeaton spoke with Office of the Chief Medical Examiner Intake Specialist Mercedes Robinson. After receiving the information concerning Sandra’s death, the OCME accepted jurisdiction and assigned Case #2021-2032. Source
- Trooper Dunne requested that Sandra’s next of kin be contacted and asked to respond to the apartment for questioning. Stoughton Police attempted to contact Sandra’s aunt, Darlene Smith, but she was not home. Smith contacted Canton Police shortly afterward, and Officer Nix notified her that Sandra had been found deceased. Smith was in New Hampshire and unable to respond to the scene. Her contact information was provided to Dunne. Source
- Darlene Smith told Officer Nix that Sandra’s death “did not make any sense to her.” Source
- Chris Adams and Caitlyn Bulger of the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner responded and took custody of Sandra’s body after investigators finished processing the scene. Sandra was transported to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. Her cause and manner of death were pending further study. Source
- After Sandra’s body was removed and CPAC and OCME personnel cleared the apartment, Detective McCourt located additional items inside a cardboard box in Sandra’s bedroom closet. Source
- Before clearing the apartment, Detective McCourt and Officer Brady arranged for Canton Animal Control to take custody of Sandra’s two cats. Officer Brady locked the apartment door after investigators cleared the scene. Source
-
Stoughton Police Detective Sandra Barrett learned of Sandra Birchmore’s death and contacted Matthew Farwell. Source
-
Barrett informed Farwell that Sandra had reportedly hanged herself. According to the courtroom notes, Farwell responded, “How was last night?” Source
- 7:03 PM – State investigators submitted a report identifying the investigation as “Birchmore/Suicide/Canton.” Source
- Evening – Property Manager Erin Porter emailed Sergeant Lank after reviewing surveillance footage and reported seeing an individual entering the building whom she believed might be Alexander Stenstrom, a friend of Sandra who had recently applied for housing with Sandra’s recommendation. Porter stated that she was not positive of the identification because the individual was wearing a face covering. Lank told Porter the matter would be examined when investigators could review the surveillance footage again. Source
- Note: A broken necklace was found down the front of Sandra’s body. According to a later federal court filing, the medical examiner was not informed about the broken necklace, and it was not preserved. Federal prosecutors later alleged that the broken necklace was consistent with a struggle. Source
Video from the apartment complex showed a man entering the lobby of Sandra’s building. Note: Detectives learned from maintenance worker Michael that the person in the video looked like the man who helped Sandra move into her apartment.
February 2021- Canton Police Report Birchmore Sandra Birchmore well being check on a party at 3307 Windsor Woods Way.
- Canton Police Report Birchmore Sandra Birchmore well being check on a party at 3307 Windsor Woods Way.
- Canton Police Report Birchmore Sandra Birchmore well being check on a party at 3307 Windsor Woods Way.
Sandra Birchmore Apartment: Responding Officers Timeline:
February 4, 2021 Crime Scene
- 11:00 a.m. Canton Police officers were dispatched to 3307 Windsor Woods Way, Canton, Massachusetts, to conduct a well-being check on Sandra Birchmore at the request of Sharon Police and Sharon Public Schools. Crime Scene
- Responding officers included Patrolman Charles Yeaton, Officer Ensley Cotard, and Officer Mike Brady.
- Property manager Erin Porter provided officers with a key to enter the apartment.
- Upon entry, officers found Sandra Birchmore seated on the bedroom floor with a scarf or strap around her neck, secured to the bedroom closet door handle.
- Officers observed lividity and discoloration, indicating she had been deceased for an extended period.
- Sgt. Michael Lank, the shift supervisor, responded, secured the scene, and notified the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office (CPAC).
- 11:09 a.m., Canton Police Detective Jonathan McCourt responded to the apartment for the well-being check.
- He was informed by first responding officers that Birchmore was deceased and appeared to have hanged herself.
- He observed Birchmore seated with a dark-colored strap tied to the bedroom closet door handle.
- He observed no visible trauma or defensive abrasions on her hands.
- 11:46 a.m., Canton Firefighter and Paramedic Daniel Whitley arrived on scene and pronounced Sandra Birchmore deceased.
- No life-saving measures were taken.
- Shortly After Initial Response, Massachusetts State Police and CPAC responded
- Trooper Mike Dunn, assigned to CPAC, responded to the scene.
- Trooper Zach Clark, Massachusetts State Police Crime Scene Services, responded to process and photograph the scene.
- Additional Massachusetts State Police personnel arrived from CPAC.
- A supplemental narrative later identified Trooper Matt Dunne and Trooper Kevin Tufts as CPAC responders.
- Massachusetts State Police Crime Scene Services personnel processed and documented the apartment.
- 12:44 p.m., the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner was contacted.
- OCME Intake Specialist Mercedes Robinson accepted jurisdiction over the death.
- The case was assigned OCME Case No. 2021-2032.
Scene Details:
Police Report: When officers entered Sandra Birchmore’s apartment on February 4, 2021, they found a living space in disarray.
- The small apartment was cluttered and unkempt, and two cats roamed inside.
- The bedroom door was closed, and when officers opened it, they noted a desk lamp and colored Christmas lights glowing softly around the window, both still on.
- The bed was unmade, consisting of a simple sheet over a mattress and an exposed box spring.
- On the bed, officers found Sandra’s eyeglasses, and scattered nearby was a U.S. Army ACU-pattern duffel bag, a subtle reminder of her brief military service.
- The most harrowing discovery lay on the floor of the bedroom, where Sandra was found seated, lifeless, with a scarf or strap tightly affixed around her neck. Note: Accounts from first responders varied; some referred to it as a scarf, others as a strap, but all agreed it was secured to the bedroom closet door handle.
- There were no visible signs of trauma to her head, nor were there defensive injuries on her hands. Note: However, Officer Ensley Cotard noted a large pool of dried blood around her mouth. The blue skin discoloration and lividity suggested Sandra had been deceased for a prolonged period before discovery.
- Her cell phone was found on the floor, about 12 inches from her right hand and 6 inches from her bent right knee.
- She was wearing the same clothing she wore on surveillance video when she entered her apartment on February 1, 2021, at approximately 5:33 p.m.
- State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne documented that there were no signs of physical abuse, no bruising, swelling, or external trauma that might suggest a struggle.
- Members of the Medical Examiner’s Office, Chris Adams and Caitlyn Bulger, took custody of her body.
- As part of the investigation, hair and fingernail clippings, clothing, and swabs from her body were collected for a sexual assault kit.
- Zach Clark #4097 from Crime Scene Services documented the victim and the scene with digital photographs.
- The victim was transported to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. The cause and manner of death are pending further study.
- Later: A toxicology report confirmed the presence of Sertraline, a commonly prescribed antidepressant.
Devices: Sandra Birchmore’s Phone & Health Data Activity
- Sandra’s phone was locked after she sent a final text message to Matthew Farwell stating that the door was unlocked on February 1, 2021 – 9:13 p.m.
- Sandra’s cell phone was found on the floor:
- Approximately 12 inches from her right hand
- About 6 inches from her bent right knee
- She was wearing the same clothing seen on surveillance footage at this exact moment.
- He is later seen leaving the building at approximately 9:43 State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne
- Post 9:40 p.m. – No Further Activity
- No additional movement or steps were recorded by Sandra’s phone after 9:40 p.m.
- The phone remained inactive until first responders recovered it on February 1, 2021.
- These recorded steps occurred while Matthew Farwell was still in Sandra Birchmore’s apartment. The phone recorded no additional p.m. time, and the time it was recovered by first responders on February 4, 2021.
- Occurred just minutes before Farwell exited the apartment building
Sandra’s family members found a significant detail overlooked in initial reports:
- A broken necklace on the bedroom floor. It was a thin gold chain with a pink flamingo charm, a piece known to belong to Sandra. The chain was broken, not at the clasp, and had a large clump of hair entangled in it.
- Crime scene photos showed that the necklace was still inside the apartment, and blue skin discoloration indicated she had been deceased for an extended period.
Sandra Birchmore – Interviews and Investigation
February 5, 2021- Dr. Maria Capó-Martinez performed Sandra Birchmore’s autopsy. The autopsy documented a prominent ligature furrow completely surrounding her neck, prominent petechial hemorrhages in the eyes and skin above the ligature, an abrasion on her chin, hemorrhage in the neck muscles, and a fracture of the right hyoid bone. Source
- Sandra was approximately ten weeks pregnant. According to Dr. Michael Baden’s later review, fetal tissue was not sent for DNA analysis to determine paternity. Source
- Sandra’s temporary death certificate initially listed her cause of death as “Pending” and manner of death as “Pending investigation.” Further toxicology testing and evaluation of the Sexual Assault Kit were requested. Source
- The Sexual Assault Kit contained vaginal, anal, and oral swabs, hair and fingernail clippings, and clothing, including underpants. Baden later wrote that the kit appeared not to have been tested. Source
- Toxicology testing showed sertraline. Source
- Evidence: Evidence associated with Sandra’s body included vaginal, genital, anal, and oral swabs, fingernail samples, a blood sample, underwear, and the ligature. Source
- Forensic examination did not identify sperm cells in the body swabs described in the notes.
- Screening of Sandra’s underwear identified multiple stains requiring further examination.
- Sample B1 produced an inconclusive result, while B2 did not reveal sperm cells.
- Additional extraction of sample J1 did not identify sperm cells, while J2 contained sperm cells.
- Sperm cells were also detected in stain E1, located on the exterior back of the underwear.
- The two stains containing sperm cells were preserved for DNA analysis. Their contributors were not identified by the screening examination.
- The forensic scientist collected possible trace material, including hair or fibers, from the ligature.
- The ligature was examined for possible transferred biological material, including areas near the closet door handle.
- The forensic scientist did not receive the associated duffel bag, did not swab the carabiner clip, and did not receive swabs from apartment surfaces such as the closet doorknob.
- The available records do not establish that all of these laboratory examinations occurred on February 6. Source
- 3:10 PM: State Police interview Matthew Farwell: Source
- Massachusetts State Police interview Matthew Farwell in the parking lot of a Stoughton elementary school.
- Farwell admits to a sexual relationship with Birchmore but falsely claims it began in 2020. He denies paternity of her unborn child, stating last intercourse was in October 2020; records contradict this: Text messages prove he visited her on January 29, 2021.
- Farwell claims he hadn’t seen her for a week before her death, except for a February 1, 2021 visit.
- Farwell claims Birchmore had been “sectioned” several times. Records show she was only once hospitalized, in May 2020, after a family argument. Evaluated and released the same day.
- Sandra’s Mother’s Cousin: Source
- Last saw Birchmore in person approximately two weeks before her death, when they spoke about her pregnancy.
- Believed the baby’s father had a key to Sandra’s apartment.
- Birchmore was not open to adoption and did not name the father.
- Said Birchmore had babysat for the man’s children, possibly recently.
- Could not obtain many details about the relationship.
- Detectives Interviewed Sandra’s Friend Source
- Recalled having breakfast and a long conversation with Sandra.
- Confirmed Sandra’s history in law enforcement-related youth programs: “Respect” program at age 8, Junior Officer at age 13.
- Stated Sandra began a relationship with Matthew Farwell at age 15.
- Claimed Billy Farwell (Matthew’s twin) had told Matthew’s wife about the affair.
- Sandra said Matthew’s wife confronted him, but he denied it.
- Sandra told this friend she was pressuring Matthew Farwell to sign the birth certificate.
- Interview with a Friend: Source
- Knew Sandra since they were 7 or 8 years old from a mother-child bonding program; later played volleyball together. Reconnected in summer 2020.
- Sandra asked if she could move in, citing issues with her aunt selling their shared home and concerns about pet care.
- Around December 12, 2020, Birchmore said she was pregnant and that the father was a married Stoughton detective, whom she did not name. Claimed he planned to divorce his wife but couldn’t due to COVID-19.
- Birchmore said she told him about the pregnancy just after Christmas, and he reacted negatively.
- Sandra said he told her: I wish you would kill yourself” or “I wish you were dead.” Note: 9:18 p.m. – Screenshot Logged.
- Birchmore wanted the father’s last name on the birth certificate and for him to be present in the delivery room. She said, “If he can be in the delivery room with his wife, then he can be there for me.”
- Around January 8, 2021, Birchmore had a second argument with the father. This friend had loaned Sandra money; when she asked for repayment:
- On January 16, 2021, Sandra promised to send $150 but did not follow through.
- Birchmore later claimed she was hospitalized after hitting her head on her car door and pavement.
- On January 20, 2021, this friend called Stoughton Police to report the debt.
- She was told the matter was civil; she then mentioned Birchmore was involved with an officer.
- Shortly after, Sandra called her, apparently aware of the report.
- Interview with Ex-Wife of Sandra’s Mother’s Cousin: Source
- Birchmore was distressed over her aunt selling the house and said the pregnancy would be an “uphill battle.”
- Said the father was a detective with two kids and a pregnant wife due in February.
- Noted that both the father and Sandra’s mother were twins, and they discussed the possibility of twins. After an ultrasound, Sandra confirmed it was a single pregnancy.
- Sandra expressed a strong desire for the father’s involvement but didn’t want his wife to find out.
- They also discussed daycare, a baby shower, and parenting plans.
- In January 2021, Birchmore told her she was pregnant but said the father was a “close friend.”
- On January 22, 2021, Birchmore claimed she had undergone multiple ultrasounds.
- Birchmore also shared drama involving the Stoughton Police Department, specifically claiming the chief was mistreating a particular officer.
- 10:58 AM Interview with Daniel J. Source
- Last spoke with Birchmore on Sunday, January 31, at 11:57 AM, and received a missed call that evening at 7:16 PM.
- Met Birchmore in late 2020 while both were taking classes at Massasoit.
- Spoke with her almost daily.
- Birchmore claimed she was about 12 weeks pregnant and planned to announce it publicly on February 14.
- She also said she was upset the baby’s father wanted children with his wife but not with her.
- Reported that while the father had raised his voice, she was unaware of any physical abuse.
- Birchmore also mentioned a court case involving a car crash.
- Detectives Interviewed Sandra’s Mother’s Cousin Source
- Last saw Birchmore in person approximately two weeks before her death, when they spoke about her pregnancy.
- Believed the baby’s father had a key to Sandra’s apartment.
- Birchmore was not open to adoption and did not name the father.
- Said Birchmore had babysat for the man’s children, possibly recently.
- Could not obtain many details about the relationship.
- Detectives Interviewed Sandra’s Friend
- Recalled having breakfast and a long conversation with Sandra.
- Confirmed Sandra’s history in law enforcement-related youth programs: “Respect” program at age 8, Junior Officer at age 13.
- Stated Sandra began a relationship with Matthew Farwell at age 15.
- Claimed Billy Farwell (Matthew’s twin) had told Matthew’s wife about the affair.
- Sandra said Matthew’s wife confronted him, but he denied it.
- Sandra told this friend she was pressuring Matthew Farwell to sign the birth certificate.
- Interview with Another Close Friend Source
- Knew Sandra since they were 7 or 8 years old from a mother-child bonding program; later played volleyball together.
- Reconnected in summer 2020.
- Sandra asked if she could move in, citing issues with her aunt selling their shared home and concerns about pet care.
- On December 12, 2020, Birchmore said she was pregnant and that the father was a married Stoughton detective, whom she did not name.
- Claimed he planned to divorce his wife but couldn’t due to COVID-19.
- Birchmore said she told him about the pregnancy just after Christmas, and he reacted negatively.
- Sandra said he told her, “I wish you would kill yourself” or “I wish you were dead.”
- Birchmore wanted the father’s last name on the birth certificate and for him to be present in the delivery room.
- She said, “If he can be in the delivery room with his wife, then he can be there for me.”
- January 8, 2021, Birchmore had a second argument with the father.
- This friend had loaned Sandra money; when she asked for repayment:
- January 16, 2021, Sandra promised to send $150 but did not follow through.
- Birchmore later claimed she was hospitalized after hitting her head on her car door and pavement.
- On January 20, 2021, this friend called Stoughton Police to report the debt.
- Told the matter was civil; she then mentioned Birchmore was involved with an officer.
- Shortly after, Sandra called her and said she was aware of the report.
- Interview with Ex-Wife of Sandra’s Mother’s Cousin
- Birchmore was distressed over her aunt selling the house and said the pregnancy would be an “uphill battle.”
- Said the father was a detective with two kids and a pregnant wife due in February.
- Noted that both the father and Sandra’s mother were twins, and they discussed the possibility of twins.
- After an ultrasound, Sandra confirmed it was a single pregnancy.
- Sandra expressed a strong desire for the father’s involvement but didn’t want his wife to find out.
- They also discussed daycare, a baby shower, and parenting plans.
- Detective Sandra Barrett contacted Detective Daniel Barber about a rumor alleging that Matthew Farwell had been involved in a sexual relationship with Sandra Birchmore. Source
- Barber telephoned Farwell and informed him of the allegation. Source
- Farwell denied the relationship and asked who else knew about the rumor. Source
- Barber described Farwell as sounding frantic and surprised. Source
- 11:22 PM, Farwell texted Barber, “I legit thought that this was just some crazy bitch.” Source
- Holmes authored the Internal Affairs report header memorandum. Holmes documented that the report would later be completed and submitted on August 29, 2022.
- Holmes noted an understanding with Massachusetts State Police that if evidence of criminal culpability involving anyone connected to the case was discovered, it would be referred to MSP. Source
- Holmes stated Chief McNamara received weekly updates pursuant to department policy.
- Holmes stated there was an early decision not to disclose certain allegations to identified employees to avoid jeopardizing the investigation.
- Interview with childhood friend: Source
- Knew Sandra for 17 years.
- Reconnected a month earlier via FaceTime after ~2 years of no contact.
- Birchmore said she was pregnant but unsure of the father.
- Sandra admitted to sleeping with twin brothers, one or both of whom she claimed were police officers.
- 2:00 PM: Detectives met with Matthew Farwell at the Norfolk District Attorney’s Office in Canton. Source
- Farwell Cell Phone: After retaining his personal phone for three days, Farwell declined to consent to a full search of the device. He later consented only to a limited search of messages between himself and Birchmore.
- Farwell says he had already deleted those messages after breaking up with Birchmore on February 1, 2021.
- Farwell searched for “can you revoke consent in Massachusetts” and “can delete message be recovered by Cellebrite.” Source
- 4:05 PM: Interview with William Farwell (Matthew’s twin brother) by Massachusetts State Police: Source
- William Farwell stated he met Sandra ~10 years earlier through the Police Explorers program, where he was a guest instructor.
- In 2018, while working a paid detail, Sandra approached him to talk about joining the Army.
- He referred her to Jason Thomas Pickard, an Army Recruiter, and they began talking regularly. Source
- Admitted to having a relationship with Sandra spanning roughly two years.
- Interview with a friend of Sandra Birchmore: Massachusetts State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne conducted a phone interview with a woman who contacted the Norfolk District Attorney’s Office with information concerning Birchmore’s death. Source
- The woman told investigators she and Birchmore had known each other for years, had fallen out of touch, and reconnected toward the end of high school when they were about 17 or 18. They attended volleyball open-court sessions together in Stoughton and continued seeing each other through volleyball over the years. Source
- She said Birchmore recently contacted her and disclosed that she was pregnant and had been sleeping with a married man, whom Birchmore identified as the father of the baby. Source
- The woman said she believed the baby’s father may not have wanted the pregnancy. She also told investigators that Birchmore “wasn’t trying to not get pregnant,” and said she believed Birchmore may have intentionally become pregnant. Source
- According to the woman, Birchmore told her that after the baby’s father expressed that he was unhappy about the pregnancy, the two argued. Source
- Birchmore reportedly told the man that she was going to tell his wife and his employer about their relationship. The woman told investigators that Birchmore understood doing so could get him into trouble. Source
- According to the woman’s account of what Birchmore told her, the baby’s father became angry and took Birchmore’s phone from her. She said this incident occurred approximately two weeks before Birchmore was found dead. Source
- The woman also recalled Birchmore saying that the man should leave his wife because “he loves me,” and that Birchmore believed he loved her more than his wife. Source
-
Sandra had a hair appointment scheduled with another stylist. The appointment was not attended because Sandra had died. Source
- Deputy Chief Holmes opened an Internal Affairs case file as a collection point for the Sandra Birchmore matter. Deputy Chief Holmes entered Sandra Birchmore’s name into the department’s internal investigation database known as IMC. After reviewing all records, he administratively locked access to those records, except for Chief McNamara and Detective Sergeant O’Connor. He verbally directed Detective Sergeant O’Connor that if any record requests arose regarding Sandra Birchmore, the Chief of Police was to be notified. Source
- Internal Affairs Findings Timeline – Source
- Case: Sandra Birchmore Case
- Agency: Stoughton Police Department
- Report: IA Report 21-1-IA
- Date: Report submitted August 29, 2022
- 2010, Sandra Birchmore joined the Stoughton Police Explorers Program at age 13.
- She is initially placed on a standby list and later becomes a full participant.
- 2011, Robert Devine assumes control of the Police Explorers Program after direction from then-Chief Manuel Cachopa.
- The program is restructured into a junior police academy model.
- Devine first meets Sandra Birchmore after she joins the program.
- April 10, 2013, Sandra Birchmore turns 15 years old.
- 2016: Birchmore graduates from Stoughton High School.
- She leaves the Explorers Program.
- 2018: William Farwell meets Birchmore when she expresses interest in joining the U.S. Army.
- He connects her with a recruiter and maintains ongoing contact.
- February 11, 2020: Matthew Farwell and Birchmore exchange text messages.
- Messages are later cited as evidence of ongoing communication while Birchmore was a minor.
- April 19, 2020: William Farwell is assigned to a midnight to 8:00 AM desk shift.
- He exchanges text messages with Birchmore beginning at 6:47 AM.
- Messages continue past the end of his shift.
- April 29, 2020, William Farwell is assigned to another midnight to 8:00 AM desk shift.
- He exchanges messages with Birchmore beginning at 4:39 AM.
- Messages continue past 8:00 AM.
- May 6, 2020, William Farwell is assigned to a midnight to 8:00 AM shift.
- He exchanges messages with Birchmore beginning at 6:42 AM.
- Messages continue until approximately 7:25 AM.
- June 7, 2020, Matthew Farwell exchanges messages with Birchmore while on duty.
- He asks her to meet him on Walnut Street.
- November 27, 2020: Robert Devine communicates with Birchmore via Facebook Messenger.
- Some communications occur while Devine is on duty.
- At least one exchange occurs while Devine is on duty on December 21, 2020.
- Messages reference plans to meet at the Chateau restaurant.
- December 21, 2020, William Farwell is assigned to a paid detail from 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM.
- He exchanges messages with Birchmore throughout the morning.
- Messages occur at 11:04 AM and 11:38 AM.
- February 4, 2021
- Canton Police conduct a well-being check at 40 Holbrook Avenue, Canton, Massachusetts.
- Sandra Birchmore is found deceased in her apartment.
- She is pronounced dead at the scene.
- February 5, 2021
- Massachusetts State Police notify Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara that Matthew Farwell had a prior romantic relationship with Birchmore.
- Chief McNamara directed Deputy Chief Holmes to open an Internal Affairs investigation into the unattended death of Sandra Birchmore. The directive included possible violations of policy, procedure, rules, or regulations by Stoughton Police Department employees.
- February 6, 2021
- Matthew Farwell is interviewed by Massachusetts State Police.
- He admits to a sexual relationship with Birchmore.
- He claims he last saw her on February 1, 2021.
- He states they argued around 9:30 PM.
- February 8, 2021
- Holmes authored the Internal Affairs report header memorandum.
- Holmes documented that the report would later be completed and submitted on August 29, 2022.
- Holmes noted an understanding with Massachusetts State Police that if evidence of criminal culpability involving anyone connected to the case was discovered, it would be referred to MSP.
- Holmes stated Chief McNamara received weekly updates pursuant to department policy.
- Holmes stated there was an early decision not to disclose certain allegations to identified employees to avoid jeopardizing the investigation.
- Detective Matthew Farwell was placed on paid administrative leave. Source
- Farwell turned in his issued equipment and department property pursuant to the administrative-leave memo.
- Deputy Chief Holmes retrieved an IMC access-control thumb drive belonging to Matthew Farwell. Source
- The evaluation of Sandra Birchmore’s Sexual Assault Kit was prepared approximately three weeks after her death. Baden later wrote that the kit appeared not to have been tested. Source
- Deputy Chief Holmes prepared an inventory of property taken from Matthew Farwell. Source
- The inventory was retained in the Internal Affairs case file.
- 11:00 AM Memorial service held for Sandra Birchmore. Source
- Location: Immaculate Conception Church
- The service announcement included:
- “May her memory be a blessing”
- Scheduled for Wednesday at 11:00 AM
- Death Certificate issued for Sandra Birchmore; the final death certificate listed the cause of death as “Hanging” and the manner of death as “Suicide.” Source
- Massachusetts State Police forensic scientist Stephanie Waite received evidence associated with Sandra’s death under laboratory case number 21-02589. Source
- The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner delivered the evidence, which included bodily swabs, fingernail samples, a known blood sample, underwear, and the ligature.
- The materials arrived separately packaged within an evidence collection box. Source
- Stephanie Waite began examining evidence associated with Sandra’s death. Source
- She examined Sandra’s underwear through visual inspection, alternate light source screening, and acid phosphatase testing. Source
- Stain E1 on the exterior back of the underwear contained sperm cells. Source
- Additional testing identified sperm cells in sample J2 from the interior crotch area. Sample J1 did not contain detectable sperm cells. Source
- The portions of the underwear containing sperm cells were preserved for DNA analysis. Source
- Waite collected potential biological material from the ligature and material resembling hair or fibers. Source
- Internal Affairs: Deputy Chief Holmes received communications from an individual whose name is redacted in the report. Source
- The individual provided documents that included letters written by Sandra Birchmore. Source
- The materials also included other communications authored by Birchmore. Source
- Holmes forwarded the materials in support of the Internal Affairs investigation. Source
- Deputy Chief Holmes documented that Sandra Birchmore’s property was recovered from her apartment. Source
- The property was placed into boxes.
- Holmes turned the boxes over to the Massachusetts State Police.
- Holmes retained handwritten notes he believed might be relevant.
- He reviewed documents from the boxes, which were mainly handwritten notes to people with whom Birchmore had personal relationships.
- Farwell’s department-issued phone was transferred to MSP. Source
- Holmes delivered Matthew Farwell’s department-issued cell phone to:
- Trooper Kevin Tufts.
- Sergeant Fanning of the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office.
- This transfer was done in cooperation with the Massachusetts State Police unattended death investigation.
- Laboratory Results: The Massachusetts State Police Crime Laboratory tested evidence recovered during the investigation into Sandra Birchmore’s death. Source
- Birchmore’s underwear tested positive for sperm cells. Source
- Fingernail clippings tested positive for DNA. Source
- The ligature recovered from around Birchmore’s neck tested positive for male DNA. Source
- Investigators did not obtain a DNA comparison sample from Matthew Farwell or any other potential contributor, leaving no known comparison sample available for the male DNA detected on the ligature. Source
- Cause and Manner of Death: The Massachusetts Office of the Chief Medical Examiner ruled Birchmore’s death a suicide. Source
- Birchmore was 23 years old and approximately three months pregnant when she died. Source
- The initial Massachusetts State Police investigation reported finding no evidence of foul play. Source
-
Matthew Farwell underwent a disability-benefits evaluation that recorded his account of a previous extramarital affair and his characterization of the woman’s death. The evaluation documented Farwell’s statements rather than independently establishing the circumstances of Sandra’s death. Source
- Evidence Review Meeting: Deputy Chief Holmes met with representatives of the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office and Massachusetts State Police concerning the Sandra Birchmore and Matthew Farwell investigation and the handling of evidence. Source
- Those present included the District Attorney and First Assistant District Attorney. Source
- Sergeant John Fanning and Lieutenant Gerard Matalano were also present. Source
- Massachusetts State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne attended the meeting. Source
- The meeting addressed the Birchmore and Farwell investigation and evidence-handling matters. Source
- Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office records indicate that its investigation into Sandra Birchmore’s death had officially closed by at least August 2021, if not earlier. Source
- Deputy Chief Holmes received a thumb drive from Sergeant Fanning of the MSP. Source
- The thumb drive contained evidence from the unattended-death investigation of Sandra Birchmore.
- Holmes labeled the thumb drive as “evidence” related to the victim.
September 6, 2021 – “BlacklightCaseBirchmore” PDF Created
- Another file was created that Holmes described as a PDF titled “BlacklightCaseBirchmore.” The file contained: Source
- Communications pulled from Birchmore’s computer.
- Computer screenshots.
- Emails.
- Text messages.
- Annotated communications.
- Preliminary Review of Digital Evidence: Holmes meets with MSP Sergeant Fanning and receives a thumb drive containing evidence from the unattended death investigation. He writes that one PDF, titled “BlacklightCaseBirchmore,” contained roughly 50,000 pages of communications pulled from Birchmore’s computer, which had reportedly been synchronized with her cell phone. He notes that the material included texts, iMessages, and other communications and was difficult to review because it was not chronological and messages were duplicated. Holmes states he conducted a preliminary review of the thumb drive the same day and observed many conversations of investigative significance. Source
- Holmes emailed Chief McNamara and the Town Manager stating he would be viewing the files.
- Sandra Birchmore’s Laptop: Deputy Chief Holmes met with Sergeant John Fanning at the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office. Source
- Holmes met with PI L’Italian. Source
- Holmes conducted a strategic review of a thumb drive.
- A file titled “blacklight report 2021-09-29-22-29-52.”
- Holmes noted the file had been downloaded from Birchmore’s computer and synchronized with her phone.
- Holmes reviewed:
- Conversations involving Matthew Farwell.
- Conversations involving William Farwell.
- Photographs and videos exchanged between Birchmore and Matthew Farwell.
- Holmes reviews archived SPD Explorers Program files from 2002 to 2014. Source
- Records include names of officers connected to Birchmore.
- Holmes continued reviewing documents from the Explorers program files. Source
- Holmes met with PI L’Italian and continued the Internal Affairs investigation. Source
- Holmes conferred with parties whose names were redacted in the report. Source
- Holmes served notice that additional investigative steps were being taken.
December 21 to December 22, 2021
- Holmes communicated the outcome of an interview and scheduled a continuation during the week of December 27, 2021. Source
- Holmes met with Lieutenant Fanning and received additional data files from MSP.
-
William “Billy” Farwell and his wife Angela moved to New Mexico after William resigned from the Stoughton Police Department. William was arrested in New Mexico in connection with a domestic violence incident. Source
January 10 to January 11, 2022
- Holmes contacted Detective Lieutenant Kenneth Heffernan of MSP Crime Scene Services. Source
- Holmes requested forensic analysis of a couch. (Joshua Heal)
- Holmes obtained authorization through MSP’s chain of command for assistance in the administrative investigation.
- Holmes arranged a unit response for January 14, 2022, at 10:00 hours.
- 9:45 a.m., Massachusetts State Police forensic scientist Jennifer J. Preisig arrived at 499 West Street, the Stoughton animal-control building, as part of laboratory case 22-01049 involving Sandra Birchmore. Source
- An alternate light source detected stains on the couch and office chair. Screening tests performed on the detected stains were negative for the substance identified in the laboratory report. Source
- The alternate light source detected no stains on the underside of the desk.
- The crime-laboratory report states that no evidence was submitted following the examination.
- Preisig examined a room at the front of the building containing animal cages, a couch near the front door, a desk, and an office chair.
- Massachusetts State Police Crime Laboratory Forensic Scientist Jennifer J. Preisig arrived at 499 West Street, identified as an animal control building. Source
- Animal Control Couch Examination:
- Animal cages positioned along two sides
- A couch located near the front door
- A desk and office chair positioned near the center of the room
- Forensic Examination Methods: Use of an alternate light source (ALS) to identify possible biological or trace evidence.
- Findings, Couch and Office Chair: Stains detected on: Couch, Office chair
- Screening test results:
- Tested for the presence of biological material (presumptive testing)
- Results were negative for the targeted substance (likely blood, based on standard ALS workflow)
- Findings, Desk Area
- No stains detected on the underside of the desk using ALS examination
- Evidence Handling
- No physical evidence was submitted to the laboratory for further testing
- Report Notes
- All observations, times, and measurements are approximate.
- Additional analysis could be conducted upon request.
- Holmes met with PI L’Italian and MSP personnel, including:
- Detective Lieutenant Heffernan.
- A forensic technician.
- The planned forensic activity was conducted.
- Matthew Farwell registered his own business with the Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth. Source
- Obtained a commercial driver’s license
- Purchased a semi-truck and trailer
- Took out a 10-year business loan
- The Massachusetts State Police Crime Laboratory issued its formal crime-scene report documenting the January 14, 2022 examination of the Stoughton animal-control building at 499 West Street. The report was directed to Deputy Chief Brian Holmes of the Stoughton Police Department and copied to ADA Lynn Beland of the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office. Source
- Holmes and PI L’Italian met with a witness at Abington Town Hall.
- The witness had legal representation present.
- Holmes discussed interview notification with Patrolmen’s Union President Barber.
- Matthew Farwell submitted his resignation from the Stoughton Police Department. Source
- Farwell’s resignation was effective April 1, 2022. Source
- Holmes left a message for a witness about scheduling an interview. Source
- The witness returned the call.
- The interview was scheduled for April 2, 2022, at 10:00 a.m.
- Holmes decided not to personally participate in Officer Robert Devine’s interview.
- PI L’Italian and PI Robert Fries were assigned to conduct Devine’s interview.
- Robert Devine Interview: Stoughton Police Department investigators conducted the scheduled interview of Officer Robert Devine as part of the Internal Affairs investigation. Source
- Witness Interview: Deputy Chief Holmes interviewed Angelique Pizozzoli at her residence as part of the Internal Affairs investigation into Sandra Birchmore and the Stoughton police officers involved. Source
- Holmes recorded the interview, which addressed Pizozzoli’s relationship with Birchmore and the circumstances surrounding her involvement in the investigation. Source
- Social Media Evidence: Holmes received a text message containing a screenshot of comments on a Facebook post discussing media coverage of Sandra Birchmore and Matthew Farwell. Source
- The comments alleged that Birchmore’s friends had been contacted, threatened, and accused of lying by members of the Stoughton Police Department following her death. Source
- Robert Devine Interview: Private investigators Paul L’Italien and Robert Fries interviewed Officer Robert Devine at the Massachusetts Police Training Council academy as part of the Internal Affairs investigation. Source
- Devine denied having a personal relationship or direct communications with Sandra Birchmore. Source
- Follow-Up Investigation: Holmes attempted to contact individuals associated with the Facebook comments concerning alleged threats against Birchmore’s friends. Source
- Holmes left messages asking potential witnesses to contact him to arrange interviews. Source
- Holmes subsequently received a voicemail indicating that a potential witness was retaining legal counsel. Source
- William Farwell: Chief Donna McNamara called William Farwell and directed him to report to the Stoughton Police Department. Source
- William Farwell reported to the police station and retrieved department equipment. Source
- Patrolmen’s Union President Barber was present. Source
- Potential August 2021 Crime: Deputy Chief Holmes received information concerning a potential crime allegedly involving Matthew Farwell in August 2021. Source
- Holmes conducted a recorded interview regarding the information. Source
- During the interview, Holmes stopped the questioning and contacted the Massachusetts State Police. Source
- Holmes downloaded the recorded interview and saved it to a thumb drive. Source
- Massachusetts State Police Referral: Holmes contacted Massachusetts State Police Trooper Kathleen Prince regarding the information received the previous day. Source
- Holmes hand-delivered an information packet to Trooper Prince at the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office in Canton. Source
- Internal Affairs Investigation: Holmes met with Lieutenant John Fanning and private investigator Michael Bates at the Massachusetts Police Training Council facility in Randolph to plan and strategize regarding the investigation. Source
- During the investigative review, Holmes identified a Facebook Messenger conversation believed to be associated with Officer Robert Devine. Source
- CJIS Audit: Deputy Chief Holmes requested a CJIS offline audit to identify all users who had queried Sandra Birchmore or her vehicle. Source
- Holmes also coordinated investigative interviews and the required union notifications. Source
- Holmes received the CJIS offline audit results and reviewed the findings. Source
- Holmes shared the audit results with private investigator Paul L’Italien. Source
- Social Media Allegation: Holmes documented a social media post alleging misconduct by a Stoughton police officer. Source
- Holmes attempted to contact the individual who made the post. Source
- Holmes preserved and logged the social media post as an exhibit in the Internal Affairs investigation. Source
- William Farwell Interview Notice: Holmes emailed William Farwell notice of an investigatory interview. Source
- Holmes received acknowledgment of the notice from MassCOP attorney Patrick Bryant. Source
- William Farwell resigned. Source
- Robert Devine Resignation: Robert Devine resigned from the Stoughton Police Department. Source
- Robert Devine Written Response: Deputy Chief Holmes received Devine’s written responses to questions that had been mailed to him as part of the Internal Affairs investigation. Source
- Devine claimed that his accounts had been hacked; Holmes rejected that explanation based on his review of the evidence. Source
- Holmes completed his credibility assessment of Devine and maintained his investigative findings. Source
- Deputy Chief Holmes submits Internal Affairs Report 21-1-IA.
- Findings sustain multiple violations against all three former officers.
Sustained Findings by Officer:
Matthew Farwell
- Conduct unbecoming an officer.
- Improper relationship with a minor.
- Lack of sound judgment.
- Failure to pay attention and devote to duty.
- Untruthfulness during a State Police interview.
William Farwell
- Conduct unbecoming an officer.
- Improper communications while on duty.
- Lack of sound judgment.
- Failure to pay attention and devote to duty.
- Untruthfulness during a State Police interview.
- Improper use of departmental computer systems.
Robert Devine
- Lack of sound judgment.
- Untruthfulness during an Internal Affairs interview.
- Failure to pay attention and devote to duty.
Investigation Scope and Methodology
- Parallel coordination with Massachusetts State Police.
Review of:
- Text messages
- Facebook Messenger communications
- Department attendance records
- Paid detail logs
- Explorers Program records
- Electronic device data
- Handwritten notes from Birchmore’s residence
Status
- All three officers resigned prior to formal disciplinary action.
- Internal Affairs did not file criminal charges based on its findings.
- Administrative findings were finalized on August 29, 2022.
Notes:
- This page reflects only administrative findings.
- Massachusetts State Police and the Norfolk County District Attorney’s Office conducted criminal investigations separately.
- Redactions remain in the public version of the Internal Affairs report.
- End of Internal Affairs Findings Timeline
Sandra Birchmore Investigation Timeline
2020 Investigation Timeline:
- Apr–Dec 2020: William Farwell exchanged sexually explicit texts with Sandra Birchmore, including nude photos and videos of his wife and others.
- Apr 10, 2020: Matthew Farwell texted Birchmore that he would “sneak away from work,” reflecting a pattern of meeting her while on duty.
- Spring 2020: Sandra became pregnant but suffered a miscarriage, deepening her grief.
- May 19, 2020: Police conducted a well-being check after Sandra argued with family and was reported suicidal. She was hospitalized, evaluated, and released.
- May 24, 2020: An ambulance brought Sandra to a hospital after she was found unconscious, likely from anxiety.
- Sep 2020: Sandra applied for housing and secured her own apartment.
- Oct 2020: Began working at East Elementary School, Sharon. Moved with Matthew Farwell’s assistance. His behavior became more controlling.
- Oct 5, 2020: Joshua Heal told Sandra that Farwell’s wife was pregnant with a third child (due Feb 2021). Sandra drafted a message to Farwell’s wife threatening to reveal their 10-year affair.
- Oct 12, 2020: Sandra confronted Farwell, demanding he have a child with her or she would expose him.
- Oct 14, 2020: Sandra offered Farwell a key to her new Canton apartment; he declined.
- Nov 3 & 5, 2020 Sandra pressed Farwell about having a baby; suggested he sign a birth certificate to “keep her safe.” Farwell deferred discussion.
- Nov 24, 2020 Sandra asked if Farwell would be on duty during a planned meeting. He replied yes.
- Nov 27, 2020 Sandra chatted with Robert Devine (aka Marty Riggs) via Facebook.
- Dec 21, 2020 Devine (on duty) messaged Sandra to meet him at the Chateau restaurant.
- In late Dec. 2020, Sandra told Farwell she was pregnant again. He lashed out, telling her, “I wish you would kill yourself.”
- Dec 28, 2020, Sandra texted Farwell a pregnancy announcement poster, saying she was 3½ weeks pregnant. They argued fiercely. Farwell called her “the worst person on the face of the earth.”
- Dec 29, 2020 Sandra told Farwell their in-person talk made her feel “scared” and “uncomfortable,” fearing he might hit her.
- Dec 30, 2020 Sandra went to a salon to prepare for New Year’s Eve.
2021 Investigation Timeline:
- Jan 3–6, 2021 Sandra asked Matthew Farwell about giving their child his last name, ultrasound dates, and family plans. He refused to discuss by text, insisting on in-person talks.
- Jan 8, 2021: Sandra and Farwell met at her apartment; an argument turned physical. She said he shoved her and put her in a chokehold before she kicked him out.
- Jan 9, 2021: Sandra told Joshua Heal that Farwell wished she “would die,” denied the baby, and assaulted her. Heal warned her to stay away, noting Farwell’s power as a police officer.
- Jan 10, 2021: Sandra met William Farwell for a sexual encounter in her apartment parking lot.
- Jan (mid), 2021: Sandra confided to friends that Farwell had been violent, pushing her down after she showed him a sonogram. She continued buying baby items and asked a friend to be the godmother.
- Jan 16, 2021: Dispute with a friend over unpaid money.
- Jan 20, 2021: That friend called Stoughton Police to report Sandra’s sexual relationship with Farwell. A department employee shared the tip with Farwell, who angrily texted Sandra: “Your f—ing friend called my job.”
- Jan 21, 2021 Sandra told friends about recent violence. She bought a baby stroller, made pregnancy plans, and excitedly discussed her child’s future.
- Jan 24–29, 2021 Farwell visited Sandra, brought her ginger ale, and asked for a key. Sandra had a copy made and gave him the building passcode. Farwell searched her apartment, inspecting her closet and bathroom.
- Jan 30–31, 2021 Sandra asked Farwell about baby names; he deferred. She ordered baby items, planned newborn photos, gender reveal, and booked an OBGYN appointment for Feb 10. On Jan 31, a therapist screened her and found no signs of depression or suicidal ideation.
February 1, 2021 – Final Day
- 12:19–1:31 p.m. Released early from her school job; ordered baby items, booked a newborn photo shoot, and planned Valentine’s Day announcements.
- 5:00–5:30 p.m. Seen on surveillance at her Canton apartment (DoorDash delivery; retrieving snow brush).
- 7:57–9:03 p.m. Texted friends about baby clothes, searched online for furniture, and messaged coworkers about schedules.
- 9:08 p.m. Farwell texted asking if he could “come by for a second.” Sandra replied that the door would be open.
- 9:13 p.m. Sandra sent her last message: “The door is unlocked.”
- 9:14 p.m. Farwell entered the building during a snowstorm, wearing a mask. He strangled Sandra, staging the scene to look like suicide (duffel bag strap tied to closet doorknob).
- 9:40–9:43 p.m. Sandra’s health app logged final steps; Farwell left the apartment minutes later.
- 9:25 a.m. The next morning, Michelle Farwell gave birth to her and Matthew Farwell’s third child at Newton-Wellesley Hospital.
February 4, 2021 – Discovery:
- 10:00 AM – School officials contacted the School Resource Officer to check on Sandra Birchmore, who had missed a few days of work.
- 10:00 AM – Officers Cotard, Brady, and Yeaton responded to 3307 Windsor Woods Way to make contact with Sandra. When they arrived, no one answered the door. Sandra’s vehicle was in the apartment complex parking lot, covered in snow, and had not been moved since the snowfall on Monday, 2/1/21. The officers spoke with a property manager, who provided a key to access the apartment.
- 11:46 AM, Officers found Sandra in the bedroom, deceased, with a black strap around her neck, tied to the bedroom closet door. Sandra was 10 weeks pregnant, and the cause of death was determined to be suicide. Report Updated Report p104
- 12:44 PM ME’s office accepted jurisdiction. Case #2021-2032 assigned. Report
Video from the apartment complex showed a man entering the lobby of Sandra’s building. Detectives learned from maintenance worker Michael that the person in the video looked like the man who helped Sandra move into her apartment.
- As the investigation unfolded, it became clear that Sandra had been victimized by those who were supposed to protect her.
- The man seen entering her apartment that night was Detective Matthew Farwell, the same man who had groomed, manipulated, and abused her for nearly a decade.
- The revelations that followed exposed a deeply troubling culture within the Stoughton Police Department, leaving a community in shock and raising questions that would haunt those who knew Sandra for years to come.
- In the weeks before her death, Sandra confided in friends that Farwell had assaulted her during discussions about her pregnancy.
- His disturbing fascination with violence against women was further revealed when investigators recovered incriminating images from his iCloud account.
- Canton Police Incident Report (Sudden Death)
- Time of Discovery: February 4, 2021, at approximately 11:00 a.m.
- Discovered By: Officers responding to a well-being check requested by Sharon Public Schools
- Victim: Sandra Birchmore (DOB: May 13, 1997, age 23)
- Location: 3307 Windsor Woods Way, Canton
- Cause of Death: Found seated on the floor, dark strap/scarf tied to the closet door handle, no signs of struggle; pronounced deceased at 11:46 a.m.
- Last Seen on Camera: January 31, 2021, at 4:41 p.m., returning to building
- Property Manager Erin Porter’s Observations: Video surveillance, concerning call from Tina Thompson indicating Sandra was dating a police officer and the officer threatened “to take care of the problem himself”
- Canton PD Sergeant received an e-mail from a witness who stated she had information regarding Sandra Birchmore’s death. Source
- This information was passed to MSP for action.
- Sandra Birchmore’s aunt stated she knew Sandra was pregnant and that the baby’s father was Stoughton Police Officer Matthew Farwell.
- Canton PD detectives conducted a follow-up investigation at Windsor Woods and interviewed a witness who advised Canton PD detectives that Birchmore was involved in an intimate relationship with a police officer, who was alleged to be the father of her unborn child. Source
- Canton PD detectives received information from a second witness who said Ms. Birchmore had been dating a police officer who did not want the baby, and if Ms. Birchmore did not get an abortion, he would take care of the problem himself.
- Canton PD and MSP coordinated a second review of video footage at Windsor Woods.
- After reviewing the video footage, investigators identified a male subject (later identified as Stoughton Police Detective Matthew Farwell) arriving at Windsor Woods on February 1, 2021, at 9:27 p.m. and departing at 9:56 p.m.
- Farwell was observed entering the apartment complex lobby and entering the elevator.
- Video revealed Mr. Farwell was at Windsor Woods for approximately 28 minutes. See Video
- Canton PD and MSP conducted a second search of Ms. Birchmore’s apartment.
February 8, 2021 Internal Affairs Investigation – Stoughton PD Report
- Report Filed by: Deputy Chief Holmes
- Scope: Investigated policy violations by SPD employees relating to Sandra Birchmore
- William Farwell was interviewed by the Massachusetts State Police as part of the Sandra Birchmore death investigation.
- During the interview, Willian Farwell stated that he first met Sandra “about ten years earlier” when she was in the “Explorer” program, and he was a guest instructor.
- In 2018, while he was assigned to a paid detail, Sandra approached him, and they began to talk about her interest in joining the Army. Farwell connected her with Jason Thomas Pickard, an Army recruiter, and Sandra began contacting him regularly.
- William Farwell admitted during his State Police interview that he and Sandra had been in a relationship for about two years.
February 17, 2021 MSP Redacted Report
- Redacted Interviews and Logs: Includes timelines, communications analysis, and interviews with coworkers, family, and other witnesses. Additional Names Noted:
- Alexander Stenstrom: Friend of Sandra, seen on surveillance footage entering building post-mortem
- Tina Thompson: Called property manager to warn that Sandra’s death was preceded by threats from a police officer
- Cellebrite Data: Full download and analysis from Sandra’s synced devices; thousands of texts retrieved
- Victim Background: Known to fabricate stories occasionally, aggressive when upset, but maintained steady communication with friends
- The state medical examiner determined that Birchmore, who was 23 years old and three months pregnant at the time, died by suicide. A subsequent State Police investigation found no evidence of foul play. Death Certificate Issued on March 4, 2021
- Massachusetts State Police Crime Laboratory:
- Collected and tested evidence from Sandra Birchmore’s apartment
- DNA was identified on multiple items, including:
- Ligature around her neck
- Underwear
- Fingernail clippings
- At that time:
- DNA was detected, including male DNA on the ligature
- No comparison sample existed, so no suspect could be identified
- William Farwell was placed on military leave to serve in the Middle East with the Army National Guard
October 6, 2021,
- Detective met with Sergeant Fanning at the Office of the District Attorney and received Sandra Birchmore’s MacBook Air.
November 4, 2021,
- Detectives identified, observed, and discussed conversations from Sandra’s laptop between Matthew Farwell, William Farwell, and a recruiter from the MA Army
December 21, 2021,
- Detectives interviewed Joshua Heal regarding the Sandra Birchmore investigation. Heal denied any sexual involvement. After about 30 minutes of questioning, he requested to stop the interview to consult legal counsel.
- Detectives reviewed Stoughton Animal Control Shelter records to locate pet adoption documents for Sandra Birchmore. No such documents were found.
- Cellebrite export of Birchmore’s data received from MSP.
Investigation Timeline:
January 11, 2022:- Detectives received authorization to conduct forensic analysis on a couch located in an office that may have evidentiary value.
- Detectives, along with MSP crime lab personnel Lt. Kenneth Heffernan and Jennifer Preisig, processed the couch for forensic evidence.
- Second interview conducted with Joshua Heal.
- Notice of interview sent to Matthew Farwell. His attorney confirms he will not participate.
- Matthew Farwell submits formal resignation (effective April 1).
- Interviews continue with witnesses; Devine’s involvement scrutinized.
- Matthew Farwell resigned from the Stoughton Police Department. He had been on paid administrative leave since February 24, 2021. During his leave, he obtained a CDL and launched a trucking company, DMJ Transportation LLC. Source.
- The Town of Stoughton placed William Farwell and Robert Devine on administrative leave. The move coincided with the end of William’s unrelated personal leave. Town Manager Release
- Angelique Pirozzi, Sandra’s mother’s cousin, was interviewed by MSP. She described a toxic and emotionally deteriorating relationship between Sandra and Matthew Farwell, and said Sandra had babysat for Farwell’s family and had pressured him to be involved in her pregnancy. MSP Report
- Detectives received a text message with a screenshot of the comments section of a Facebook post commenting on the recent Boston Globe article on the resignation of Matthew Farwell and of Sandra Birchmore. The post alleged that Birchmore’s friends had been contacted by members of the Stoughton Police Department after her death and that the friends were threatened and called liars.
- Chief McNamara’s delegates interviewed Robert Devine at the MPTC academy. He denied any relationship with Sandra and stated, “because you won’t find it” when told no communication had been discovered.
- Allegation of possible 2021 criminal act by Matthew Farwell referred to MSP; victim declines to cooperate.
- Detectives discovered a Facebook Messenger thread on Sandra’s laptop involving a user later identified as Devine using the alias “Marty Riggs”. The messages included discussions about meeting Sandra in his patrol car while on duty.
- Cellebrite data from Birchmore’s phones received and reviewed.
- FBI consulted on William Farwell’s suspicious CJIS queries; confirmed no federal violations.
- William Farwell retrieved personal items from the station.
- William Farwell submitted his resignation from the Stoughton Police Department.
- William Farwell’s resignation took effect on August 16, 2022.
- Robert Devine officially retired from the Stoughton Police Department.
- Cellebrite data archived, and thumb drives returned from private investigators. Internal Affairs Investigation Completed by Stoughton PD Report
- Detectives received a letter from Robert Devine. He claimed his accounts had been hacked. However, an internal IMC records check found no incident reports supporting this claim. Investigators maintained their assessment of his credibility.
- Chief Donna McNamara confirmed in an internal email that Matthew Farwell, William Farwell, and Robert Devine would not be returning to the department. Email
- Event: Stoughton Police Department IA report
- Details: The department released the results of a 19‑month internal affairs investigation. The report confirmed inappropriate relationships between Sandra and the two Farwell brothers and Devine. These findings undergirded the civil suit filed later in December
- The Abington Police Department placed Joshua Heal on administrative leave amid allegations of misconduct. He resigned prior to an internal interview. Investigators deemed him not credible and less than forthright. Press Release
- Internal Affairs Investigation: The Abington Police Department announced that it was aware of allegations of misconduct involving one of its officers. Source
- The department stated that the allegations were serious and would be thoroughly investigated. Source
- An Internal Affairs investigation was underway. Source
- The department placed the officer under investigation on paid administrative leave pending the outcome. Source
- The department stated that no additional details could be released because the investigation was ongoing. Source
- Norfolk District Attorney’s Office: The Norfolk District Attorney’s Office announced that the investigation into Sandra Birchmore’s death, including work by the medical examiner, Massachusetts State Police detectives, and State Police Crime Scene Services Section, did not produce evidence of criminality in her death. Source
- The investigation revealed activities by Stoughton Police officers that required further investigation by the Stoughton Police Department and outside investigators. Source
- The Norfolk District Attorney’s Office was reviewing the resulting 60-page report, including its conclusions and exhibits, to determine whether to bring criminal charges. Source
- Prosecutors said they were beginning a substantial review process that would take time. Source
- The Norfolk District Attorney urged anyone with direct knowledge of misconduct, or anyone who believed they had been a victim of similar misconduct, to contact the District Attorney’s Office directly. Source
- Investigation Contents Include: Source
- Digital forensic analyses
- Copies of internal memos and interviews
- Summarized evidence timeline
- Details consistent with and expanding upon the internal affairs report
- Investigators involved: Robert Fries, Paul L’Italien, Michael Bates
- Key Insight: Medical Examiner’s Office ruled Sandra’s death as undetermined; no conclusive evidence to charge any officer with a crime, though serious administrative violations were confirmed
- The estate of Sandra Birchmore filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Matthew Farwell and other former officers, as well as the Town of Stoughton.
- A two-alarm fire occurred at 40 Holbrook Avenue in Stoughton, the former Birchmore/Gaudet family home where Sandra Birchmore had lived before moving to Canton. Darlene Smith was documented as residing at 40 Holbrook Avenue less than two weeks before the fire. The property was subsequently recorded as land with no building value and was sold on May 10, 2023, for $213,000 to America Vitorino B., Trustee of the 40 Holbrook Avenue Realty Trust.
Internal Affairs Investigation – Stoughton PD Report
- Report Filed by: Deputy Chief Holmes
- Date Completed: August 29, 2022
- Scope: Investigated policy violations by SPD employees relating to Sandra Birchmore
- Findings:
- Matthew Farwell:
- Had a relationship with Sandra beginning when she was 15 years old (he was ~10 years older)
- Texts confirm sexually suggestive dialogue from 2020
- Last person to see her alive: Feb 1, 2021, 9:30 p.m.
- Sustained Violations: Conduct unbecoming, incompetence, untruthfulness, lack of devotion to duty
- Resigned: April 1, 2022
- William Farwell:
- Met Sandra when she was 13; began relationship around 2018
- Interviewed by MSP on Feb 11, 2021; admitted to prior sexual contact
- Resigned: August 1, 2022
- Robert Devine:
- Ran the Police Explorers program
- Had an inappropriate relationship with Sandra
- Acted as mentor and supervisor to both Farwell brothers
- Provided access and influence to the Explorers program from early teens through adulthood
- Conclusion: All three men exploited their positions to engage in long-term sexual misconduct with Sandra Birchmore, some beginning when she was a minor
- The Estate files a Second Amended Complaint in Norfolk Superior Court against Matthew Farwell, William Farwell, Robert Devine, Joshua Heal, and the Town of Stoughton.
- Joshua Heal resigns from the Abington Police Department “ahead of a scheduled interview with internal investigators,” after having been on leave since September 2022.
- Answers and a memorandum on behalf of William Farwell and Robert Devine are filed responding to the complaint. (Listed in the case file index; exact filings are reflected on the docket.)
- Matthew Farwell decertified by POST Commission. Details: The Massachusetts state-level police oversight body voted to revoke Matthew’s police certification. He agreed to be permanently barred from law enforcement and added to a national decertification index, although he did not admit to any allegations at that time
- Heal files a response and cross-claims in the civil case; a separate copy of a Heal response is available in the public case records.
- The Estate files its Opposition to the Town of Stoughton’s Motion to Dismiss, arguing the Town’s Rule 12(b)(6) motion should be denied. A docket mirror confirms the filing date.
- POST Commission initiates decertification of all three officers. Details: The Commission sought to strip authority from Matthew, William Farwell, and Robert Devine following evidence of sexual misconduct with Sandra and misuse of their official positions. The POST Commission initiated proceedings to revoke the law enforcement certifications of both Matthew and William Farwell.
-
Federal investigators began examining information concerning Sandra’s relationship with Stoughton police officers and the circumstances of her death. Source
- Affidavit Released. Details: Affidavit reveals Birchmore and Matthew Farwell exchanged 32,709 electronic messages between December 2019 and her death in February 2021
Dec 14, 2023
- The Estate files Amended Opposition to Defendant Robert Devine’s Motion to Dismiss.
- Pre-Hearing Conference in the Matter of Robert Devine (Case No. 2024-003).
-
FBI Special Agent Heidi Kelsch became involved in the federal investigation into Sandra Birchmore’s death. Source
-
Investigators continued efforts to access and extract data from Sandra’s Apple Watch while preserving the integrity of its contents.
-
Digital forensic specialist Jessica Hyde performed data extraction from the watch. The exact extraction date is not established in the supplied notes.
- Matthew Farwell agrees to be decertified by the POST Commission, barring him from law enforcement in Massachusetts.
- FBI conducts new interviews, gathering disclosures from people close to Birchmore about her history with Farwell. Source
- A protective order was entered in the Massachusetts POST Commission proceeding against former Stoughton Police officer Robert Devine. The order governed sensitive evidence and discovery being exchanged during the administrative case concerning Devine’s police certification. Source
- Dr. Michael M. Baden completed an independent forensic review of Sandra Birchmore’s death. He reviewed the autopsy and toxicology reports, scene and autopsy photographs, X-rays, the Complaint, the Protective Order for the Internal Affairs Report, and the unredacted August 29, 2022 Stoughton Police Department Internal Affairs Report. Source
- Baden noted that the autopsy photographs showed a tightly applied ligature crossing the middle of Sandra’s neck horizontally. He noted prominent petechial hemorrhages in the eyes and skin above the ligature, an abrasion on the chin, hemorrhage in the neck muscles, and a fracture of the right hyoid bone. Source
- Baden stated that these findings are commonly found in homicidal manual and ligature strangulation and not in suicidal hanging. He noted that a hyoid fracture is rare, if it occurs at all, in suicidal hanging and occurs in approximately half of homicidal strangulations of women. Source
- Baden noted that the ligature was entangled within Sandra’s hair. He stated that women committing suicide place the ligature against the skin beneath their hair, while entanglement within the hair occurs with resistance during homicidal strangulation. Source
- Baden concluded, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that Sandra did not die from suicidal hanging and that the findings were typical of homicidal manual and ligature strangulation and atypical for hanging. Source
- Baden concluded that Sandra would have lost consciousness within seconds after the ligature was fastened around her neck and died within a few minutes. Source
- Baden concluded that the neck ligature was tied to the doorknob to give the appearance of a suicidal hanging. He determined Sandra’s cause of death was “Strangulation,” and the manner of death was “Homicide.” Source
- Baden stated that the fetal tissue and Sexual Assault Kit could still be examined for DNA if they remained available. Source
- As part of the federal investigation, the FBI obtains a search warrant authorizing agents to collect a DNA sample from Matthew Farwell. Source
- Federal prosecutors state that Farwell’s DNA is then compared to DNA recovered from the ligature, Birchmore’s fingernails, and sperm found in her underwear.
- The filing states Farwell’s DNA was found on the ligature that tied Birchmore’s neck to a closet door handle.
- Prosecutors describe the ligature, a duffle bag strap, as the murder weapon and call the DNA evidence “highly inculpatory.”
- The same testing also excludes Farwell as Birchmore’s unborn son’s biological father.
- William “Billy” Farwell was represented by attorney David M. Bae during proceedings before the Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) Commission concerning the proposed revocation of his law enforcement certification.
- Bae requested that Sandra Birchmore’s identity and her involvement in the Stoughton Police Explorers Program be excluded from the disciplinary hearing, arguing that the information would unfairly prejudice the proceedings.
- POST attorney Shaun Martinez opposed the request, arguing that Sandra’s involvement in the Explorers Program and William Farwell’s knowledge of allegations involving his twin brother, Matthew Farwell, were relevant to the case. Source
- Government expert Dr. William Smock met with: Source
- Massachusetts OCME
- Massachusetts State Police
- FBI
- U.S. Attorney’s Office
- Federal authorities expressed disagreement with the suicide ruling
- A server Massachusetts State Police Trooper Nicholas Guarino was using to review the forensic extraction of Sandra Birchmore’s MacBook Air suffered what Farwell’s defense described in court as a complete failure. Defense attorney Joanne Daley said the failure resulted in the loss of the underlying raw laptop data, leaving investigators with a PDF extraction of the device. Daley told the court that Guarino had known about the loss for roughly two years, but the defense learned about it only in recent weeks. The server failure occurred four days before Farwell’s arrest. Source
- Farwell is federally indicted for killing a witness (Birchmore) to obstruct disclosure of his sexual relationship with her. Arrested, pleads not guilty. Source
- Consented to voluntary pretrial detention without prejudice. Source
- The United States District Court entered a Protective Order in United States v. Matthew Farwell. The Protective Order restricted dissemination of discovery materials in the federal murder case, including: Source
- Sandra Birchmore’s laptop extraction.
- Sandra Birchmore’s phone extraction.
- The Protective Order applied to third parties, including Matthew Farwell’s criminal defense attorneys.
- FBI affidavit unsealed, detailing allegations of grooming, long-term sexual abuse, and staging her death as suicide.
- A supplement to the protective order in Robert Devine’s POST Commission proceeding was entered to extend its protections to newly discovered and future discovery material. Source
- Case returns to court; trial date still not set. Federal prosecutors appeared in court in U.S. v. Matthew Farwell. Source
- The Massachusetts POST Commission began its evidentiary adjudicatory hearing in the matter of Robert Devine.
- According to the final decision, witnesses included Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara, Kingston Police Chief Brian Holmes, former Stoughton Police Explorer Hailey Hogan, and Devine himself.
- The Division of Police Standards offered 14 exhibits, and 12 were admitted. Devine submitted 19 exhibits, and eight were admitted.
- The proceedings were closed to the public pursuant to the protective orders governing the case. Source
- The POST Commission evidentiary hearing concerning Robert Devine continued. The case concerned allegations that Devine demonstrated a pattern of unprofessional police conduct and had repeated sustained internal-affairs complaints. Source
- Report confirms that after Birchmore’s death, Farwell allegedly staged her apartment to look like a suicide. Still part of the ongoing allegations in the indictment; no rulings yet.
- The evidentiary adjudicatory hearing in Robert Devine’s POST Commission case resumed. Evidence included material concerning allegations involving Sandra Birchmore and communications attributed to a Facebook account using the alias “Marty Riggs.” Source
- An FBI agent collected a cheek swab from Jason Pickard for DNA testing. Source
- Farwell faces the possibility of the death penalty. The indictment includes a charge (“killing a witness or victim”) for which sentencing could be death or life in prison.
- The POST Commission completed another day of evidentiary proceedings in Robert Devine’s certification case. Both sides later elected to submit written closing memoranda instead of presenting oral closing arguments. Source
- Abington/Stoughton POST Commission considers discipline of ex-official Joshua Heal, the fourth ex-Stoughton employee implicated in misconduct related to the Birchmore case. The Commission deliberations stem from earlier misconduct reporting in 2022.
- Robert Devine and the Division of Police Standards submitted closing memoranda, including proposed findings of fact, following the evidentiary hearing concerning Devine’s police certification. Source
- The hearing officer issued an Initial Decision in Robert Devine’s POST Commission case.
- The hearing officer found, by clear and convincing evidence, that Devine had a pattern of unprofessional police conduct that could escalate and had repeated, sustained internal-affairs complaints.
- The hearing officer also found that Devine had been untruthful about communications and a meeting with an individual identified in the proceeding as S.B., and that the evidence supported the conclusion that Devine communicated with Sandra using the Facebook alias “Marty Riggs.”
- The hearing officer recommended revoking Devine’s law-enforcement certification and reporting the revocation to the National Decertification Index. Source
- A hearing was held. Farwell did not appear. He has been held without bail, by agreement, since his indictment. The presiding judge set a hearing on a motion to dismiss for March 12, 2026, and scheduled Farwell’s trial to start on Oct. 5, 2026.
- U.S. District Judge Denise Casper also ordered federal prosecutors to file notice by Jan. 20 if they intend to pursue the death penalty against Farwell. The crime he is charged with, killing a witness or victim, is punishable by death. It carries a minimum sentence of life in prison. Casper essentially overrode both prosecutors and Farwell’s defense, who said there was no need to set deadlines at this stage. She also said the October trial date would stand whether or not Farwell is facing the death penalty.
- A former Stoughton police officer who was previously indicted for allegedly murdering Sandra Birchmore, a pregnant woman, to prevent her from disclosing information about his sexual exploitation of her beginning when she was a minor, has been indicted for allegedly causing the death of Birchmore’s unborn son. Source
- The new indictment filed in U.S. District Court for Massachusetts details about Birchmore’s pregnancy: the child was male, conceived about 8-10 weeks before. Indictment Source
- Robert Devine filed objections to the POST hearing officer’s Initial Decision. Devine disputed findings concerning his earlier internal-affairs matters and challenged the finding that he communicated with Sandra through the “Marty Riggs” account and met her for a sexual encounter while on duty. Source
- Devine filed an additional brief arguing that his due process rights were violated during the POST proceeding. Among his arguments, Devine challenged the use of evidence attributed to Sandra because she was deceased and therefore unavailable for cross-examination. Source
November 21, 2025 – Farwell waives his court appearance on new charges involving the death of Birchmore’s unborn baby.
- 11:00 AM: Former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell was scheduled to appear in federal court at 11 a.m. for arraignment on newly filed charges related to the death of Sandra Birchmore’s unborn child.
- Farwell waived his personal appearance, allowing the arraignment to proceed without him being physically present in court.
- The new charges expand the federal case and formally address the circumstances surrounding Birchmore’s pregnancy at the time of her death.
- The Division of Police Standards responded to Devine’s objections and argued that the evidence supported the findings against him.
- The Division specifically addressed communications attributed to the “Marty Riggs” Facebook account, arguing that the messages, username information, employment-related details, and work schedule supported the finding that Devine authored the communications. Source
December 9, 2025 – Federal prosecutors announce they will not seek the death penalty against Matthew Farwell. Source
- The United States Attorney for the District of Massachusetts filed a formal Notice Regarding the Death Penalty in case number 24-10259-DJC.
- The filing states that the Attorney General of the United States has directed the government not to seek the death penalty in the prosecution of Matthew Farwell.
- United States Attorney Leah B. Foley submitted the notice, along with Assistant United States Attorneys Elizabeth C. Riley, Brian A. Fogerty, and Torey B. Cummings.
- This decision removes capital punishment as a potential sentencing outcome in the federal witness-killing case connected to the death of Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child.
- The Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission issued its final decision in the case of Robert Devine.
- The Commission found by clear and convincing evidence that Devine had a pattern of unprofessional police conduct that could escalate and repeated, sustained internal-affairs complaints involving the same or different offenses.
- The Commission stated that it did not need to independently reach the hearing officer’s separate finding concerning Devine’s alleged untruthfulness because the other findings were sufficient to support disciplinary action.
- The Commission revoked Devine’s Massachusetts law-enforcement certification.
- The Commission directed its executive director to provide the revocation information to the National Decertification Index.
- Massachusetts law allowed Devine to seek judicial review in Superior Court within 30 days. Source
- Robert Devine files a Complaint for Judicial Review in Suffolk Superior Court. He seeks reversal of the POST decision, reinstatement of certification, and removal from the POST registry. Source
- Grounds for Appeal Asserted by Devine:
- Devine checks and asserts all statutory bases for judicial reversal, including:
- Violation of constitutional provisions
- Decision based on an error of law
- Unlawful procedure
- Unsupported by substantial evidence
- Arbitrary and capricious decision-making
- Excess of authority
- 11:00 AM – A hearing on the motion to change venue in the Matthew Farwell case is set for January 20, 2026.
- The hearing will be held in person in Courtroom 10 before Chief District Judge Denise J. Casper.
- Deadline for Pros to file a motion if they intend to pursue the death penalty against Farwell. The crime he is charged with, killing a witness or victim, is punishable by death. It carries a minimum sentence of life in prison.
- Chief U.S. District Judge Denise J. Casper denied Farwell’s motion to transfer the case out of Massachusetts, finding that he had not shown the level of pretrial prejudice required for a venue change. Source
- Deadline to file motion to dismiss – If Farwell’s defense files a motion to dismiss, it must do so by February 20, 2026.
- Judge Casper denied Farwell’s motion to dismiss the superseding indictment. The court rejected the defense argument that Count I failed to sufficiently allege the federal nexus required under 18 U.S.C. § 1512(a)(1)(C). Source
- Deadline to file Motion to suppress evidence.
- Defense files Opposition to Government’s Motion for Detention in United States v. Matthew Farwell in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts.
- The filing argues that pretrial release is required under the Bail Reform Act, asserting the government cannot meet its burden to prove:
- Risk of flight
- Risk of obstruction
- Danger to the community
- Defense proposes multiple conditions of release, including:
- Third-party custody (mother)
- Home confinement with electronic monitoring
- Travel restricted to Massachusetts
- No contact with witnesses
- Firearm prohibition
- $50,000 unsecured bond
- The motion emphasizes that “liberty is the norm” and detention is a limited exception, citing federal precedent.
- The filing identifies the central factual dispute in the case as:
- Whether Sandra Birchmore’s death was suicide or homicide
- Defense highlights forensic conflict, stating:
- The Massachusetts Office of the Chief Medical Examiner ruled the death a suicide
- A second federal forensic pathologist agreed with that determination
- The government relied on a third expert who concluded homicide
- The OCME has not changed its ruling
- The filing states that:
- Matthew Farwell was excluded as the father of Sandra Birchmore’s unborn child through DNA testing
- It references a confirmed biological father who has not been publicly named
- Separately, it notes Mr. Farwell’s brother is a named defendant in a related civil lawsuit
- “These include, according to the government’s own evidence, Mr. Farwell’s brother who is a named defendant in the civil lawsuit as well as the confirmed biological father of Ms. Birchmore’s fetus who has thus far not been publicly named.”
- Defense argues Farwell’s conduct over more than three years following Birchmore’s death (February 2021 to August 2024) demonstrates:
- No attempt to flee
- No obstruction of investigations
- Continued residence in Massachusetts
- Cooperation with law enforcement and legal proceedings
- The filing outlines Farwell’s background, including:
- U.S. Army service with deployment to Afghanistan
- Law enforcement career with commendations and promotion to detective
- No prior criminal record
- Strong family and community ties
- The defense concludes that:
- The government has not met the legal standard for detention
- Even if concerns exist, conditions of release can reasonably mitigate any risk, requiring pretrial release under federal law
- Federal prosecutors filed a supplemental memorandum opposing Matthew Farwell’s request for release from pretrial detention and disclosed significant additional evidence developed after his August 2024 arrest.
- Prosecutors stated that FBI testing found Farwell’s DNA on the ligature that had been around Sandra Birchmore’s neck. According to the filing, Massachusetts State Police testing in May 2021 had detected male DNA on the ligature, but investigators did not have a Farwell comparison sample at that time.
- The filing states that Farwell’s sperm cells were also identified in multiple locations on the underwear Sandra was wearing when her body was discovered on February 4, 2021. Prosecutors argued that this evidence contradicted Farwell’s statement to Massachusetts State Police that he had last had sex with Sandra in October 2020.
- Federal DNA testing excluded Matthew Farwell as the biological father of Sandra’s unborn son. Prosecutors nevertheless stated that communications between Sandra and Farwell indicated that both believed Farwell was the father during the pregnancy and that the government considered Farwell’s belief relevant to its alleged motive.
- Prosecutors disclosed additional medical evidence that they contend corroborates their allegation that Farwell sexually exploited Sandra when she was 15, including the May 1, 2013 birth-control request and the May 30, 2013 statement to a doctor that Sandra was sexually active.
- The government said investigators obtained additional evidence indicating that Sandra recognized herself as a victim of Farwell’s alleged crimes and referred to herself as such in communications with friends.
- According to prosecutors, after learning she was pregnant, Sandra became more assertive and resistant to Farwell’s manipulation.
- The filing states that Sandra contacted attorneys to begin planning for possible paternity, child-custody, and child-support proceedings.
- FBI interviews and Sandra’s communications indicated, according to prosecutors, that she intended to obtain financial support from Farwell for the child they both believed he fathered.
- Prosecutors also disclosed testimony from a former Stoughton Police Department employee who said Farwell became enraged after learning Sandra had disclosed their sexual relationship and allegedly instructed the employee not to discuss it with anyone.
- The government cited additional witness accounts concerning Farwell’s behavior in the months and weeks before Sandra’s death as evidence prosecutors contend supports their theory of premeditation.
- Prosecutors asked the court to keep Farwell detained pending trial, arguing that he presented a danger to the community and risks of obstruction and flight. Source
- 9:55 a.m., a detention hearing was held before U.S. Magistrate Judge M. Page Kelley on Matthew Farwell’s request for pretrial release. Farwell’s defense asked that he be released under conditions while preparing for trial. Federal prosecutors opposed his release, arguing that he posed a risk of obstruction, flight, and danger to the community. Source
- Farwell’s defense challenged the government’s characterization of DNA recovered from the ligature. Defense counsel said the strap contained a complex mixture involving at least four contributors and argued that the results did not establish the individual DNA match described by prosecutors. The defense also emphasized that Farwell was excluded as a contributor to DNA recovered from beneath Sandra Birchmore’s fingernails. Source
- The defense disputed the government’s characterization of sperm cells recovered from Sandra’s underwear. Defense counsel said testing identified mixtures involving at least three contributors in one area and at least four contributors in another, and argued that the evidence did not establish that Farwell lied when he told investigators he last had sex with Sandra in October 2020. Source
- Defense counsel said the Massachusetts Office of the Chief Medical Examiner continued to classify Sandra’s death as suicide despite meeting with federal prosecutors at least twice. The defense also said the director of the Armed Forces Medical Examiner System reviewed materials provided by the FBI and did not give an opinion contradicting the Massachusetts medical examiner’s conclusion. Source
- Prosecutors disclosed additional medical evidence concerning the beginning of Farwell’s alleged sexual relationship with Sandra. According to the government, in March 2013, Sandra told her pediatrician she was receiving tutoring from a local police officer at the library. On May 1, 2013, she asked about birth control, and on May 30, 2013, she told a doctor she was sexually active. Prosecutors alleged Farwell began having sex with Sandra when she was 15. Source
- Prosecutors disclosed that before Sandra’s death, Farwell attended a Massachusetts State Police homicide conference that included training on investigating hanging deaths. According to the government, the training covered ligature furrows, knot placement, and the fact that complete suspension is not required for death to occur in a hanging. Prosecutors alleged Farwell later used that specialized training to stage Sandra’s death as a suicide. Source
- Prosecutors said that on January 20, 2021, after a call was made to the Stoughton Police Department concerning his relationship with Sandra, Farwell allegedly told the call-taker, “Do not tell anybody about this and never mention it to me again.” Prosecutors said Farwell then texted Sandra about the report and questioned what else he needed to worry about. Source
- Prosecutors said Sandra spent February 1, 2021 making plans for her pregnancy and future, including ordering baby clothes, arranging to have her car shoveled so she could go to work, booking a maternity photo shoot and Valentine’s Day gender reveal, discussing her baby shower, doing laundry, ordering food, and communicating with multiple people who described her as happy and excited. Source
- Prosecutors provided additional context for Sandra’s February 1, 2021 Google search concerning the color of a suicide ribbon. According to the government, forensic analysis showed Sandra first saw an image with ribbons on her Facebook feed and then searched Google to determine what the ribbons represented. Source
- 9:08 p.m., prosecutors said Farwell texted Sandra asking to stop by. At 9:13 p.m., Sandra responded that he could come upstairs. Prosecutors said this was the final text message Sandra ever sent. Source
- 9:14 p.m., surveillance video showed Farwell, wearing a mask, entering Sandra’s apartment building. Source
- 9:40 p.m., Sandra’s phone recorded eight steps before being placed face down beneath the closet doorknob. Prosecutors said the phone was never moved, unlocked, or illuminated again. Farwell remained inside the apartment for another three minutes. Police next handled the phone when they discovered Sandra on February 4, 2021. Source
- Prosecutors described physical evidence they contend showed a struggle. Sandra’s hair had been taken down from the style visible earlier on surveillance video, bobby pins were found surrounding her body, and her hair was tangled through the strap and buckle. Prosecutors also described her flamingo necklace as broken at the chain rather than the clasp, with strands of hair caught in it. Source
- Prosecutors said Sandra suffered a fractured hyoid bone that they contend was more consistent with strangulation than suicide. They also described a patterned injury on Sandra’s chest that they said corresponded to the buckle of the ligature. According to the government, the buckle was ultimately found above Sandra’s head near the doorknob, which prosecutors argued showed the ligature had been positioned differently when the injury occurred and that Sandra’s body had been moved. Source
- Prosecutors said they performed both STR and Y-STR testing on the ligature. The government asserted that Farwell was the major contributor on the portion of the ligature away from Sandra’s neck that someone would have needed to handle while attaching it to the doorknob. Source
- On February 2, 2021, while Farwell was at the hospital after his wife had given birth, prosecutors said he contacted a Stoughton Police Department coworker and asked whether “anything is going on” at the station. The government argued Farwell was checking whether Sandra’s body had been discovered. Source
- Prosecutors disputed Farwell’s statement to Massachusetts State Police that Sandra had been “sectioned” multiple times. The government said federal investigators reviewed thousands of pages of Sandra’s medical records and interviewed medical and mental-health providers but found no record of a mental-health commitment. Source
- The defense disclosed a March 28, 2019 UMass Dartmouth record in which Sandra acknowledged a recent hospital visit for mental-health concerns and declined an aftercare appointment with the university’s Counseling and Student Development Center. Defense counsel said Sandra’s college records also contained suicide-related flags and disputed the government’s contention that her suicidal ideation was confined to 2017. Source
- Defense counsel said the flamingo necklace prosecutors discussed had not been preserved as evidence. The defense also maintained that the Massachusetts medical examiner continued to classify Sandra’s manner of death as suicide. Source
- 11:00 a.m., Judge Kelley took Farwell’s request for pretrial release under advisement, and the detention hearing concluded. Source
- The ME’s office has revised Sandra Birchmore’s cause of death from “asphyxia by hanging” to just “asphyxia” with the manner of death “undetermined”
- U.S. Magistrate Judge M. Page Kelley issued a written 9-page detention order ordering former Matthew Farwell to be held without bail pending trial in the federal case involving the death of Sandra Birchmore.
- Earlier that day, Farwell appeared in federal court in Boston wearing a prison jumpsuit and shackles during proceedings before Chief U.S. District Judge Denise J. Casper.
- The morning hearing focused on defense motions seeking to suppress or exclude evidence, along with a request for an evidentiary hearing regarding law enforcement’s handling of the investigation. Judge Casper indicated from the bench that she was likely to deny the evidentiary hearing request.
- Separate detention and bail arguments were handled before Magistrate Judge Kelley. Defense attorneys requested Farwell’s release on a $50,000 bond with GPS monitoring and proposed that he reside with his mother in Mansfield, Massachusetts, pending trial.
- Federal prosecutors opposed release, arguing that Farwell posed a danger to the community, a flight risk, and a risk of obstructing justice.
- In her written ruling, Judge Kelley concluded that Farwell should remain detained pending trial, finding:
- He posed “a danger to the community.”
- He posed “a risk of flight.”
- He posed “a risk of obstruction of justice.”
- Kelley further wrote that the government’s case appeared “very strong, if not overwhelming” at the pretrial stage, despite the absence of full cross-examination or trial testimony.
- The judge additionally found that “no condition or combination of conditions” could reasonably assure either community safety or Farwell’s appearance in court if released.
- The ruling noted that Farwell faces a mandatory life sentence if convicted on the federal charges.
- Judge Casper denied Farwell’s request to suppress evidence obtained from his phone and iCloud account. The memorandum explaining the ruling was filed under seal. Source
- Judge Casper denied Farwell’s motion for a bill of particulars seeking additional details about the alleged federal nexus of the charges. Source
- Paternity of Sandra Birchmore’s Unborn Son: U.S. Army recruiter Jason Pickard was identified as the biological father of Sandra Birchmore’s unborn baby boy.
- The paternity finding confirms that Matthew Farwell was not the child’s biological father. The issue had previously surfaced publicly in 2025, and federal court records acknowledge reporting that Farwell did not impregnate Birchmore.
- Farwell nevertheless remains charged with causing the death of a child in utero, in addition to the federal charge alleging he killed Birchmore to prevent her from communicating information concerning his alleged federal crimes. Source
- Final Pretrial Conference, U.S. District Court: Chief U.S. District Judge Denise J. Casper issued several significant evidentiary rulings ahead of Farwell’s October 5 trial. The judge granted the government’s request to admit certain out-of-court statements made by Sandra Birchmore before her death, over defense objections. The permitted evidence includes portions of:
- Birchmore’s electronic communications recovered from her cellphone and laptop.
- Social media communications.
- Statements Birchmore made to witnesses who will testify at trial.
- Excerpts from Birchmore’s handwritten journals.
- Judge Casper denied Farwell’s motions seeking to exclude opinion testimony from Birchmore’s mental-health provider and OB/GYN.
- The court also rejected the defense effort to prevent testimony from family members and friends who are expected to say they were surprised by Birchmore’s death and did not believe she was suicidal.
- The defense did obtain at least one favorable ruling. Judge Casper allowed its request to prevent FBI audio narration of text messages presented at trial.
- Additional evidentiary disputes remained under consideration during the final pretrial proceedings, including disputes involving expert testimony and hundreds of proposed exhibits.
- Jury selection and trial are scheduled to begin October 5, 2026, in U.S. District Court in Boston.
- A final witness list must be filed by Sept. 21, 2026.
- Farwell’s attorneys filed a renewed request to transfer the trial out of Massachusetts, arguing that recent local media coverage would prevent a fair trial in the district. Source
- Judge Casper moved the start of jury selection from October 5 to October 6 because other jury trials were already scheduled to begin on October 5. Source
- Judge Casper denied Farwell’s renewed motion to move the trial out of Massachusetts, again finding that the defense had not met the burden of showing that pretrial publicity would prevent a fair trial in the district. Source
- Matthew Farwell appeared before Chief U.S. District Judge Denise J. Casper at the John J. Moakley Federal Courthouse in Boston for the final pretrial conference before jury selection. Farwell initially entered the courtroom in a tan jail-issued jumpsuit and restraints. After his attorneys spoke with U.S. Marshals, he left the courtroom and returned wearing a dark gray suit and blue shirt, the type of clothing he is expected to wear during trial. Source
- Farwell’s defense disclosed the previously unreported loss of the underlying forensic data from Birchmore’s MacBook Air. Defense attorney Joanne Daley said Trooper Nicholas Guarino’s server crashed on August 24, 2024, and described the result to the court: “They lost everything.” According to the defense, only a PDF extraction of the laptop remained. Assistant U.S. Attorney Brian Fogerty told the court that the government would address the issue after the defense filed a motion concerning the loss. Source
- The laptop-data issue could become significant at trial because investigators recovered thousands of communications between Birchmore and Farwell from Birchmore’s devices. Farwell previously told investigators that he had deleted his communications with Birchmore. The defense’s digital-forensics expert, Daniel Loper, is expected to challenge aspects of law enforcement’s collection, preservation, and interpretation of digital evidence. Source
- Loper has analyzed more than 400 gigabytes of digital discovery produced by the government, including cellphone extractions, cloud-account information, Birchmore’s MacBook Air data, and Apple Health information. His proposed testimony includes issues involving Birchmore’s internet search for “what color is the suicide ribbon,” activity data recorded near the time prosecutors allege she was killed, surveillance-video timing, and information extracted from Farwell’s personal iPhone 11. Source
- Another unresolved issue involved Loper’s proposed testimony concerning a 9:41:43 p.m. event recorded by Birchmore’s laptop on February 1, 2021. According to court filings describing Loper’s proposed testimony, the MacBook experienced a four-second power on/off event at that time. The defense has also alleged that law enforcement’s digital-evidence collection resulted in the loss of laptop information after 9:10:52 p.m. Source
- Loper has also identified what the defense describes as a 12-minute, 57-second discrepancy between timestamps associated with surveillance footage and one of the iPhones collected during the investigation. The timing may be significant because prosecutors allege surveillance footage shows Farwell entering Birchmore’s apartment building at 9:14 p.m. and leaving at 9:43 p.m., while Birchmore’s phone recorded its final movement about three minutes before Farwell allegedly left the building. Source
- The parties also disputed the scope of Farwell’s consent for Massachusetts State Police to search his personal iPhone 11 following an unrecorded interview on February 9, 2021. Prosecutors maintained that Farwell consented only to a search for communications between himself and Birchmore. Investigators extracted the entire device but, according to prosecutors, reviewed only material they believed fell within that limited consent. Source
- Farwell’s defense disputed the government’s interpretation of the consent. Daley argued that Farwell’s signed consent form permitted investigators to search his phone for any digital evidence relevant to Birchmore’s death, rather than only communications between Farwell and Birchmore. When Judge Casper asked whether the defense was placing Farwell’s consent to such a search on the record in open court, Daley answered yes. Source
- Following that representation, Assistant U.S. Attorney Brian Fogerty said the government would conduct another review of Farwell’s extracted cellphone data for evidence related to Birchmore’s death. The review would exclude privileged material, including communications with Farwell’s attorneys, wife, therapist, or clergy. Source
- The cellphone dispute centers on proposed defense evidence that Birchmore’s former telephone number appeared in the blocked-number data on Farwell’s iPhone. The defense plans to have Loper testify that Farwell blocked Birchmore’s number on February 3, 2021, two days after prosecutors allege Farwell killed her on February 1, 2021. Prosecutors sought to restrict or exclude Loper’s testimony while questioning whether they had sufficient access to the underlying data to independently evaluate his conclusions. Source
- Assistant U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Riley asked Judge Casper to prevent the defense from suggesting to jurors that Farwell had consented in 2021 to an unrestricted search of his phone. Riley argued that investigators understood Farwell’s consent at the time to be limited to communications with Birchmore. Lead defense attorney Kimberly Stevens said that if the defense addressed the issue before the jury, she would limit the presentation to what Farwell’s written consent document actually stated. Source
- Judge Casper did not issue a final ruling on the remaining motions concerning portions of Loper’s proposed digital-forensics testimony, leaving the dispute unresolved immediately before jury selection. Source
- Judge Casper finalized the jury-selection procedure. Two groups of 40 prospective jurors are scheduled to report on October 6, 2026, with the first group arriving at 9:00 a.m. and the second at 12:30 p.m. Prospective jurors will complete handwritten questionnaires before attorneys and the court review their responses. Source
- The court plans to seat 16 jurors: 12 regular jurors and four alternates. Individual questioning is expected to begin October 8, 2026, with additional questioning available on October 9, 2026, if necessary. After challenges are exercised, the final panel will be reduced to 16 jurors. Source
- Judge Casper instructed both sides to be prepared to deliver opening statements as early as 9:00 a.m. on October 9, 2026, if jury selection is completed in time. Trial proceedings are generally expected to run from 9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., Monday through Friday, in Courtroom 10, with testimony expected to take approximately 20 trial days. Source
- Judge Casper also addressed courtroom conduct for the high-profile trial. Clothing, buttons, signs, or other items displaying support for either the prosecution or defense will not be permitted in the courtroom. Source
- Jury selection is scheduled to begin in U.S. District Court in Boston. Source
Records:
- 2014-12-03 Devine IA Investigation Files Open
- 2020-12-01 Canton Police Report – Birchmore Open
- 2021-02-17 MSP Reports Open
- 2021-02-08 IAB Internal Affairs Investigation Open
- 2021-03-08 Matthew Farewell Attorney Letter Open
- Death Certificate Issued on March 4, 2021 Open
- 2022-04-04 Stoughton Town Manager Release Open
- 2022-09-13 Email from Donna McNamara Open
- 2022-09-13 Email from Chief Donna McNamara Open
- 2022-10-25 Aug–Sep 2022 Manager Report – Sandra Birchmore Open
- 2022-11-02 Canton Police Supplemental Report – Birchmore Open
- 2022-10-12 Investigation File Open
- September 2022 Statement of Chief Donna M. McNamara Open
- September 23, 2022 Abington Police Department Press Release Open
- September 30, 2022 The Norfolk District Attorney Press Release Open
- 2022-03-18 Norfolk DA Report Sandra Birchmore Open
- 2023-01-24 Birchmore Civil Complaint Open
- 2023-04-04 Joint Status Report Open
- 2023-07-10 Joint Status Report Open
- 2023-09-12 Joint Status Report Open
- 2023-12-13 Joint Status Report Open
- 2024-02-07 Joint Status Report Open
- 2024-04-12 Joint Status Report Open
- 2024-07-11 Joint Status Report Open
- 2024-10-10 Joint Status Report Open
- 2024-10-15 Initial Status Report and Order on Excludable Delay Open
- 2024-11-27 Affidavit of Compliance Open
- 2024-11-27 In Camera Review of Material From Massachusetts State Police Open
- 2024-11-27 Joint Status Report Open
- 2024-11-27 The Town of Stoughton’s Submission of Listing of Documents Open
- 2024-12-02 Order on Excludable Delay Open
- 2024-12-03 Robert Devine – Mass State Police Investigation Files Open
- 2024-12-04 Estate of Sandra Birchmore’s Joint Motion to Extend Tracking Deadline Open
- 2024-12-04 General Correspondence Regarding Email Open
- 2025-01-29 Joint Interim Status Report Open
- 2025-03-12 Matthew Farwell Defendant Order on Excludable Delay Open
- 2025 William Farwell –DV Incident Report Open
- October 28, 2025 – Superseding Indictment Open
Sandra Birchmore Investigation – Autopsies
Investigation Source
In Birchmore’s case, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner in Massachusetts ruled Birchmore’s 2021 death a suicide. State Investigators later discovered tens of thousands of text messages between Farwell and Birchmore, many of which implied an inappropriate relationship, as well as surveillance video showing him entering and exiting her apartment.
February 5, 2021- Autopsy: Dr. Mindy Capó Martinez conducted Sandra Birchmore’s autopsy. Source
- At the time of the autopsy, Dr. Capó Martinez relied on a death notification report containing information from state and local law enforcement describing Birchmore’s death as a “suicide by hanging.” Source
- No members of law enforcement attended Birchmore’s autopsy. Source
- Dr. Capó Martinez was again informed by Massachusetts State Police that investigators were treating Birchmore’s death as a suicide. Source
- Investigative Update: Dr. Capó Martinez contacted Massachusetts State Police investigators to determine whether there were any investigative updates in Birchmore’s case. Source
- State Police investigators told Dr. Capó Martinez that there were no investigative updates. Source
- Cause and Manner of Death: Dr. Capó Martinez issued Sandra Birchmore’s death certificate, ruling the cause of death asphyxia by hanging and the manner of death suicide. Source
- Dr. Capó Martinez documented a furrow mark around Birchmore’s neck and petechial hemorrhages involving the bulbar and palpebral conjunctivae, facial skin, and larynx. Source
- She also documented hemorrhage of the left sternothyroid muscle and a fracture of the right hyoid bone. Source
- Dr. Capó Martinez documented and photographed a 2.3 × 2.0 centimeter dry red-brown abrasion on Birchmore’s right upper chest. Source
- According to the federal prosecution filing, Dr. Capó Martinez is expected to testify that Birchmore’s physical findings were either more prevalent in homicidal strangulations than suicidal hangings or at least equally present in both. Source
- Despite those physical findings, Dr. Capó Martinez originally ruled Birchmore’s manner of death a suicide based on the investigative information, including the lack of subsequent investigative updates, provided by law enforcement. Source
- Independent Forensic Review: Dr. Michael Baden, a forensic pathologist retained by the Estate of Sandra Birchmore, issued a report concluding that Birchmore died from homicidal strangulation, contradicting the Massachusetts medical examiner’s original suicide ruling. Source
- Dr. Baden determined that Birchmore’s physical injuries were commonly associated with homicidal manual and ligature strangulation, rather than suicidal hanging. Source
- Dr. Baden stated that, in his 50 years of experience, a fractured hyoid bone occurs rarely, if at all, in suicidal hangings. Source
- He noted that Birchmore’s hair was extensively tangled in the ligature, which he considered inconsistent with his experience examining suicidal hangings. Source
- Dr. Baden previously served as Director of Medicolegal Investigations for the New York State Police for more than 25 years and as Chief Medical Examiner for New York City. Source
- Dr. Baden concluded: “Ms. Birchmore did not die of suicidal hanging … The cause of Ms. Birchmore’s death is ‘Strangulation,’ and the manner of death is ‘Homicide.’” Source
- Federal Investigation: Members of the federal prosecution team and FBI met with Dr. Maria del Mar Capó Martinez before charging Matthew Farwell with murder to determine whether any information had been overlooked. No additional information was identified that altered the prosecution team’s assessment. Source
- Dr. Capó Martinez requested access to extensive investigative materials that had not been generated or made available to her before her original May 2021 ruling. Source
- Government Forensic Review: Federal prosecutors retained Dr. William Smock to independently review the crime scene photographs, autopsy photographs, and the medical examiner’s autopsy report. Source
- Dr. Smock made several findings that prosecutors stated called the prior suicide determination into question and supported a conclusion that Birchmore’s death was a homicide. Source
- Birchmore was approximately 8 to 10 weeks pregnant when she died, and toxicology testing was performed during the autopsy. Source
- Toxicology testing was negative for substances other than sertraline, which was consistent with Birchmore’s prescribed antidepressant medication. Source
- Dr. Smock determined that the fracture of the right superior horn of Birchmore’s hyoid bone was inconsistent with the position in which first responders found her body. Source
- Birchmore was found sitting, which Dr. Smock described as an incomplete hanging, where only partial body weight is applied to the neck ligature. Source
- Dr. Smock noted that the autopsy documented a patterned imprint on Birchmore’s right upper chest. Source
- He concluded that the patterned imprint resulted from a buckle or buckles on the ligature strap being forced downward into Birchmore’s chest. Source
- When first responders discovered Birchmore, the buckle believed responsible for the imprint was positioned just below her right ear. Source
- Dr. Smock determined that the chest imprint’s location was inconsistent with an incomplete ligature hanging. Source
- Photographs showed abrasions and areas of missing skin along the inferior and lateral portions of Birchmore’s nose. Source
- Dr. Smock stated that these types of injuries are commonly observed in suffocation cases when a victim moves their nose back and forth against a surface while attempting to breathe. Source
- Dr. Smock noted that Birchmore regularly wore a chain necklace with a flamingo pendant and that investigators found the chain broken around her neck. Source
- Dr. Smock considered the broken necklace consistent with a struggle. Source
- Medical Examiner Reverses Original Suicide Determination: Federal prosecutors met with Dr. Capó Martinez for a second time to prepare her expert witness notice, which was due May 1, 2026. Source
- After reviewing investigative materials unavailable to her in 2021, Dr. Capó Martinez told prosecutors she no longer agreed with the conclusions in her original May 2021 autopsy report. Source
- Dr. Capó Martinez amended Sandra Birchmore’s death certificate, changing the cause of death from “asphyxia by hanging” to “asphyxia” and the manner of death from “suicide” to “undetermined.” Source
- The amended death certificate no longer classified Birchmore’s death as a suicide. However, the revised determination of undetermined did not independently establish homicide as the official manner of death. Source
- Death certificate issued for Sandra Birchmore.
- The death certificate listed Birchmore’s manner of death as suicide.
- The death certificate listed Birchmore’s cause of death as asphyxia by hanging. Death Certificate
- An Office of the Chief Medical Examiner (OCME) pathologist ruled Sandra Birchmore’s manner of death to be suicide. Maria Del Mar Capo Martinez, MD.
- The report noted that Birchmore’s hyoid bone, a U-shaped bone at the front of the neck, was fractured on the right side.
- The report noted petechial hemorrhages of the bulbar and palpebral conjunctivae.
- The Medical Examiner determined that Birchmore had a hemorrhage of her left sternothyroid muscle.
- The Medical Examiner concluded that Birchmore killed herself by hanging.
- The Medical Examiner concluded that Birchmore’s cause of death was asphyxia by hanging.
- The Medical Examiner concluded that Birchmore’s manner of death was suicide.
- The Medical Examiner concluded that Birchmore was approximately 8 to 10 weeks pregnant at the time of her death.
- The autopsy included toxicology testing. Toxicology results were negative for all substances except for sertraline. The presence of sertraline was attributed to antidepressant medication Birchmore had been prescribed.
- The Massachusetts Office of the Chief Medical Examiner amended Sandra Birchmore’s death certificate. Her cause of death was changed from “asphyxia by hanging” to asphyxia, and her manner of death was changed from suicide to undetermined. Source
- Massachusetts State Police Crime Laboratory testing detected sperm cells on Sandra’s underwear, DNA from fingernail clippings, and male DNA on the ligature recovered from her neck. At that stage, investigators had not obtained a Farwell comparison sample for the ligature DNA.
- Dr. Michael Baden, retained by Sandra’s estate, concluded after reviewing the records and evidence that Sandra died from strangulation and that the manner of death was homicide. His analysis cited the hyoid injury, ligature findings, patterned chest injury, and other scene and autopsy evidence. Source
- Dr. William Smock, who reviewed the case for federal investigators, also concluded that Sandra was strangled rather than having died from suicidal hanging. Federal prosecutors later identified Smock as a principal medical expert for trial.
- Federal prosecutors stated that later FBI testing identified Farwell’s DNA on the ligature. Prosecutors also said Farwell’s sperm cells were identified on Sandra’s underwear. The defense has disputed the government’s characterization of the DNA evidence and has described the ligature profile as a complex mixture.
- Federal DNA testing excluded Farwell as the biological father of Sandra’s unborn son. Prosecutors contend, however, that Sandra and Farwell believed Farwell was the father during the pregnancy and argue that belief is relevant to motive. Source
- The Massachusetts Office of the Chief Medical Examiner amended Sandra’s death certificate, changing the cause of death from “asphyxia by hanging” to “asphyxia” and the manner of death from suicide to “undetermined.” Source
- Judge Denise J. Casper ruled that Dr. William Smock and Dr. Michael Baden may testify at trial about their conclusions that Sandra was strangled. The defense intends to counter the government’s medical evidence with forensic pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew. Source
- 9:10 p.m., Sandra texted Farwell that the apartment door would be open for him. The message is identified in the case record as Sandra’s last known outgoing message from her cellphone.
- Apartment-complex surveillance captured Farwell entering Sandra’s building and leaving after the final known visit. The surveillance evidence is a central part of the government’s reconstruction of Sandra’s final known hours.
- Stoughton Deputy Chief Holmes transferred Farwell’s department-issued cellphone to Massachusetts State Police investigators as part of the unattended-death investigation.
2024 to 2026 Federal Investigation
- Federal investigators obtained and analyzed additional phone, iCloud, electronic-message, and computer evidence. Prosecutors say the material documents the long-running relationship between Sandra and Farwell, Sandra’s pregnancy-related communications, and statements relevant to the government’s motive theory.
- Farwell sought suppression of evidence from searches of his phone and iCloud account, arguing that investigators presented a misleading or false narrative to obtain the search authority. Judge Casper denied the suppression request on June 5, 2026. Source
- At the final pretrial conference, the court addressed an additional dispute involving computer and digital evidence shortly before jury selection. The issue concerned data the defense intended to use at trial and how the court handled computer evidence. Source
Witness evidence developed during the investigation
- Sandra told friends, relatives, and other contacts that she believed Farwell was the father of her unborn child and discussed conflict with him concerning the pregnancy. Prosecutors intend to use certain statements under evidentiary rulings entered before trial, while Farwell disputes the government’s interpretation of the relationship and denies killing her.
- Prosecutors disclosed evidence from a former Stoughton Police Department employee who said Farwell became angry after learning Sandra had disclosed their sexual relationship and allegedly told the employee not to discuss it.
- Federal prosecutors filed a list of 68 potential witnesses. The list included Matthew Farwell’s twin brother William Farwell, Sandra’s friends and relatives, current and former Stoughton police personnel, law-enforcement investigators, Sandra’s former mental-health counselor, and medical and forensic experts. Source
- The defense filed a list of 97 potential witnesses. Thirty-one names reportedly appeared on both sides’ lists. A person’s appearance on a witness list does not establish that the person will ultimately testify.
- Judge Casper ruled that prosecutors may introduce certain statements Sandra made before her death, including electronic communications, statements to witnesses, and portions of her handwritten journals. The court also allowed testimony from her doctor, counselor, family members, and friends for permitted evidentiary purposes. Source
Sandra Birchmore case
IA Investigation
Timeline of Internal Affair Investigation
Internal Affairs Findings Timeline – Source
- Case: Sandra Birchmore Case
- Agency: Stoughton Police Department
- Report: IA Report 21-1-IA
- Date: Report submitted August 29, 2022
Overview
This timeline documents the administrative investigation conducted by the Town of Stoughton Police Department into the conduct of three former officers, Matthew Farwell, William Farwell, and Robert Devine, in connection with Sandra Birchmore.
Deputy Chief Kevin Holmes led the investigation, designated Internal Affairs Case 21-1-IA. It examined policy violations, misconduct, improper relationships, untruthfulness, and misuse of departmental resources. The inquiry ran parallel to the Massachusetts State Police death investigation into Birchmore’s death in Canton, Massachusetts.
Sustained Findings by Officer:
- Matthew Farwell
- Conduct unbecoming an officer.
- Improper relationship with a minor.
- Lack of sound judgment.
- Failure to pay attention and devote to duty.
- Untruthfulness during a State Police interview.
- William Farwell
- Conduct unbecoming an officer.
- Improper communications while on duty.
- Lack of sound judgment.
- Failure to pay attention and devote to duty.
- Untruthfulness during a State Police interview.
- Improper use of departmental computer systems.
- Robert Devine
- Lack of sound judgment.
- Untruthfulness during an Internal Affairs interview.
- Failure to pay attention and devote to duty.
Investigation Scope and Methodology
- Parallel coordination with Massachusetts State Police.
- Review of:
- Text messages
- Facebook Messenger communications
- Department attendance records
- Paid detail logs
- Explorers Program records
- Electronic device data
- Handwritten notes from Birchmore’s residence
- Status
- All three officers resigned prior to formal disciplinary action.
- Internal Affairs did not file criminal charges based on its findings.
- Administrative findings were finalized on August 29, 2022.
- Notes: End of Internal Affairs Findings Timeline
2024: Matthew Farwell indicted for Sandra Birchmore’s murder
- Matthew Farwell Indictment: Federal prosecutors allege that on February 1, 2021, Matthew Farwell killed Sandra Birchmore by strangulation and used his knowledge and experience as a law-enforcement officer to stage her death to appear to be a suicide. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and denies killing Sandra. The investigation into the death of Sandra Birchmore, initially ruled a suicide, has involved multiple agencies and spanned several years, evolving significantly as new information emerged. Matthew Farwell was indicted by federal authorities and taken into custody in August 2024, pleading not guilty to killing a witness or victim.
Detective Matthew Farwell Charged in Sandra Birchmore’s Death Source
- Detective Matthew Farwell has been charged in connection with the death of Sandra Birchmore. He is accused of killing Birchmore “with malice aforethought, willfully, deliberately, maliciously, and with premeditation” to prevent her from providing information to law enforcement regarding potential federal crimes. According to the indictment, the possible charges Farwell could have faced include deprivation of Birchmore’s rights, coercion and enticement, and wire fraud. If convicted, he could face the death penalty. Source
- Ms. Birchmore’s death was not a sudden or isolated tragedy but the devastating culmination of nearly a decade of manipulation, grooming, and repeated assaults by police officers she once trusted. Her early years were marked by the profound loss of her grandmother and mother, leaving her vulnerable and struggling to find her way. Despite the hardships, she admired authority figures, particularly police officers, viewing them as protectors and guides. This admiration led her to join the Stoughton Police Department Explorers Program as a teenager, where she met Defendants Devine, M. Farwell, and W. Farwell.
- Robert Devine, who led the Program, along with the Farwell twins, who served as officers and educators, were initially seen by Ms. Birchmore as mentors. However, beneath this facade of mentorship lay a dark and exploitative reality. The police department’s internal investigation would later reveal that Defendants W. Farwell and Devine had engaged in inappropriate sexual relationships with Ms. Birchmore, taking advantage of their positions to repeatedly assault her while on duty. The investigation further uncovered that all three officers, including M. Farwell, manipulated and abused Ms. Birchmore, exploiting her trust and vulnerability. Source
- Robert Devine, in particular, played a pivotal role in this disturbing narrative, mentoring the Farwell brothers in how to use their authority to prey on minors within the Explorers Program and on Ms. Birchmore herself.
After Sandra Birchmore’s death, law enforcement agents obtained Birchmore’s cell phones, both Apple iPhones, and laptop and reviewed the data on those devices. During that review, agents discovered messages between Matthew Farwell and Birchmore. The messages confirmed that Matthew Farwell frequently communicated with Birchmore for years. The messages also indicate that Matthew Farwell had sex with Birchmore when she was a minor, starting in or around April 2013, when Birchmore was 15 and Matthew Farwell was 27.
Matthew Farwell Indictment
February 4, 2021- Sandra Birchmore is found dead in her Canton apartment after a well-being check. Source
- Canton PD and Massachusetts State Police conduct a second search of her apartment. Source
- The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner rules her death a suicide by asphyxia by hanging. Source
- Matthew Farwell, a Stoughton police officer, provides false statements to investigators about Birchmore’s death. Source
- According to court documents, Farwell searches online for terms related to cell phone recovery and consent, then deletes them. Source
- POST Commission seeks to strip or suspend Devine’s authority to work in law enforcement. Source
- Matthew Farwell agrees to ban with state law enforcement oversight agency Source
- Sandra Birchmore’s death is ruled a homicide by prominent pathologist. Source
- Assistant United States Attorneys, District of Massachusetts (August 27, 2024). Source
- US Attorney’s Office, District of Massachusetts (August 28, 2024). Source
- POST Commision Attorney Shaun Martinez outlined the allegations that Robert Devine contacted Sandra Birchmore on the day of her death. He also detailed Devine’s claims that he was “hacked” and did not contact Sandra using a “Marty Riggs” Facebook account. Source
- A former Stoughton police officer who was previously indicted for allegedly murdering Sandra Birchmore, a pregnant woman, to prevent her from disclosing information about his sexual exploitation of her beginning when she was a minor, has been indicted for allegedly causing the death of Birchmore’s unborn son. Source
- The new indictment filed in U.S. District Court for Massachusetts details about Birchmore’s pregnancy: the child was male, conceived about 8-10 weeks before. Indictment Source
Matthew Farwell Records:
- February 1, 2021: Federal prosecutors allege Matthew Farwell killed Sandra Birchmore by strangulation and used his law-enforcement knowledge and experience to stage the scene to appear to be a suicide. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and denies killing Sandra.
2022 – Sandra Birchmore Estate – Civil Suit Timeline
- Sandra’s aunt filed a civil suit against Stroughton PD, Firewell Brothers, Devine, and Heal.
December 29, 2022
Estate of Sandra Birchmore files a wrongful death lawsuit:
- In February 2021, the Canton Police Department responded to a welfare check request after Sandra Birchmore, a reliable and dedicated young woman, had not been heard from in days. Officers found her lifeless in her apartment. Paramedics could not revive her. Sandra was later believed to be three months pregnant, possibly with a child fathered by one of the officers who had long exploited her.
- Sandra’s death marked the tragic culmination of nearly a decade of grooming and abuse by officers in the Stoughton Police Department. Orphaned at a young age, Sandra sought structure and joined the department’s Police Explorers Program as a teenager. There, she met Robert Devine and twins Matthew and William Farwell, who presented themselves as mentors but used their authority to manipulate and assault her over the years.
- An internal investigation later confirmed that Devine and William Farwell had sexual relationships with Sandra while on duty. Matthew Farwell, who had known her since she was 13, began a relationship with her when she was just 15. The report also revealed that Farwell used location-tracking technology to monitor her movements.
- Surveillance footage confirmed that Matthew Farwell was the last person to see Sandra alive, entering and exiting her apartment on February 1, 2021, just days before her body was found. Adding to the disturbing findings, Animal Control Officer Joshua Heal was suspected of facilitating Sandra’s acquisition of a cat in exchange for a sexual favor, fully aware of the ongoing abuse she endured.
- Sandra Birchmore’s story is a heartbreaking example of systemic exploitation by those in power. Despite personal hardship, her family continues to seek justice.
- Event: Estate files wrongful-death lawsuit
- Details: Darlene Smith, Sandra’s personal representative, filed a lawsuit in Norfolk Superior Court. Defendants include Matthew Farwell, and the broken chain was consistent with signs of a struggle, contradicting the state medical examiner’s suicide finding
- Key Facts: Disputed the suicide ruling, concluding the death was a homicide by strangulation, not hanging. His key observation: hyoid fracture and ligature placement inconsistent with hanging, furthermore consistent with homicidal strangulation
June 18, 2024: Sandra’s Estate retained Dr. Michael Baden – Sandra Birchmore Second Autopsy
- Statement of Chief Donna M. McNamara reveals misconduct by Farwell brothers, Devine in internal affairs report Statement
1998 – In September 1998, 12-year-old twin brothers Matthew and William Farwell enrolled in the Police Explorers Program in Stoughton, a town that promised to shape young minds toward law enforcement careers. The program was a beacon for adolescents eager to learn the ropes of police work, but the Farwell brothers brought a reputation for disciplinary issues that had followed them through their school years.
2010 Police Explorers Stoughton
The Stoughton Police Department ran the Explorer program for about 15 years but could locate only a single one-year agreement with Learning for Life, the Scouting affiliate that oversees the national Explorer program. Robert C. Devine has led the Stoughton Police Explorers Program since 2003, a youth initiative under the department.
The agreement, signed by Devine in 2010, required the department to encourage officers to take Youth Protection Training and undergo an annual evaluation by Learning for Life. However, the department has not found any records indicating that any officers involved in the program completed the training, nor has it located any records of evaluations.
Records
Robert C. Devine has led the Stoughton Police Explorers Program since 2003, a youth initiative under the department. Devine invited former Explorers, Matthew Farwell and his twin brother, William, to serve as guest instructors. The Explorers, a co-ed branch of the Boy Scouts, is designed for older teens and often centers on specific fields like law enforcement. Although the program existed before Devine became an advisor, it struggled with low attendance and enthusiasm. To revive interest, Devine surveyed members and proposed a mock police academy. Initially, the Explorer post had just five participants, but after promoting the academy, the number increased to 14. By 2011, the program was attracting 25 to 30 kids annually. The post met year-round, with the academy running from March to June, two nights a week.
Read MoreYouth Explorer Program
The Civilian Youth Explorers Program is for motivated teens under 21. It is a ten-week, physically and mentally demanding program based loosely on an actual police academy experience.
Graduates are eligible for department ride-alongs during the summer months. The primary purpose is to give the youth of Stoughton and surrounding towns an activity that keeps them occupied during high-risk times of the day and provides non-confrontational interactions with Stoughton Police Officers.
The program is geared toward young people interested in policing, medical, fire service, military service, or serving their community.
More Here
2013 – Sandra Birchmore
December 9, 2013 – Facebook Post by Stoughton Police Department
On this date, the Stoughton Police Department shared a festive image on their official Facebook page featuring members of the department’s Police Explorers program—a community-based initiative designed to introduce young people to careers in law enforcement. The photo captured a group of teenagers standing in front of a brightly decorated Christmas tree, all smiling and celebrating the holiday season. Among them was 15-year-old Sandra Birchmore, whose radiant smile stood out.
The post was cheerful in tone and intended to highlight the department’s engagement with local youth. The caption read, “Smile Birchmore,” referring to Sandra directly. At the time, she was actively involved in the Explorers program and appeared to be a well-liked and enthusiastic participant.
In retrospect, the photo stands in stark contrast to the troubling revelations that would emerge later, involving then-Officer Matthew Farwell, a man more than a decade her senior, who was also involved in the Explorers program and abused Sandra.
Come and learn crucial life skills that will serve you well into adulthood. The Police Explorers academy is a demanding ten-week course that covers the following:
- Physical Fitness
- Police Customs and Courtesies
- CPR Certification
- Self Defense
- Criminal, Constitutional, Motor Vehicle Law
- Drug Awareness
- The Court System
- K-9 Demonstrations
- Crime Scene Investigation
- Much More!
Orientation and sign-ups for the 2014 Explorers Academy will be on March 27 at 5:00 PM at the Stoughton Police Station.
The Academy is for motivated teens under 21 and will meet Wednesdays and Thursdays at 5:30 PM starting April 2. Graduates will be eligible for the department ride-along program during the summer months. The program is geared toward young people interested in policing, medical, fire service, military service, or serving their community.
More Here2014 – Sandra Birchmore
April 17, 2014 – Twitter Post by Stoughton Police Department
On April 17, 2014, Denise Birchmore sent a letter to Robert Devine. In the letter, Denise Birchmore thanked the Stoughton Police Department, and in particular Devine, for running the police Explorers program.
On June 12, 2014, on what seemed like an ordinary day in the small town of Stoughton, Massachusetts, the Stoughton Police Department’s official Twitter account posted a tweet. The tweet read, “Waiting for their turn #policeexplorers,” accompanied by a photo of a group of young Police Explorers—aspiring law enforcement officers—standing in a line, eagerly waiting for their next activity.
On that fateful day in June, while the young Police Explorers were “waiting for their turn” to participate in training exercises, Sandra Birchmore was enduring another cycle of abuse by those very officers. The tweet, meant to showcase the department’s commitment to nurturing future officers, starkly contrasted with what was happening behind closed doors.
The abuse continued for years, hidden in plain sight, with Sandra suffering in silence. The cheerful photos and tweets masked a grim truth—a truth that would only come to light years later when Sandra’s life was lost.
Sandra Birchmore Case file
Sources and Structure: Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy and integrity of the reported information. All records come from family trees, family social media accounts, court records, and investigation records.
Summary:
- Name: Sandra Birchmore
- Born: May 13, 1997
- Died: February 1, 2021
- Age: 23
- Cause of Death: Asphyxia. Manner of Death: Undetermined. The death was originally certified as suicide by asphyxia by hanging before the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner amended the death certificate in 2026
- Alleged Perpetrators: Officers Matthew Farwell, William Farwell, Robert Devine, and former Animal Control Officer Joshua Heal
- Key Investigators: Massachusetts State Police (MSP), Stoughton Police Internal Affairs, Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office
- Legal Status: Matthew Farwell has pleaded not guilty to federal charges of killing a witness or victim and causing the death of Sandra’s unborn child. He remains detained pending trial. Jury selection is scheduled to begin October 6, 2026, with opening statements scheduled for October 9, 2026
Sandra Birchmore deeply admired law enforcement. At just 13 years old, she joined the Stoughton, Massachusetts Police Explorers Program, a youth mentorship initiative led by Officers Robert Devine and twin brothers Matthew and William Farwell. Soon after, the officers began grooming her.
By age 23, Sandra was pregnant and believed Matthew Farwell was the father. Federal DNA testing later excluded Farwell as the biological father. Prosecutors nevertheless allege that Sandra and Farwell both believed he was the father during the pregnancy, which the government says is relevant to its motive theory. Sandra confided in friends, co-workers, and family members that Farwell was the father and that he had pressured her to end the pregnancy, including an alleged warning to “take care of it.” She also told others that if anything happened to her, investigators should look at Matthew. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and denies killing Sandra.
In early February 2021, after missing several days of work, someone requested a wellness check. On February 4, Canton Police officers found Sandra’s body in her apartment seated on the floor, a ligature around her neck, tied to a closet door handle. Although the medical examiner ruled her highly suspicious death a suicide, many still ask: Was Sandra Birchmore really suicidal, or was she silenced?
References & Source Documents
- MSP interviews, IA report (2022), autopsy (2021), internal memos
- Civil case filings, indictment documents
- Press coverage
- All sources will be linked inline where appropriate and listed here with PDF access
Note: All timeline entries, biographical details, and associated narrative content were compiled using official records, including police reports, internal investigation documents, court filings, and autopsy findings. Additional context came from family statements, publicly available family tree databases, and verified social media profiles to ensure accuracy and continuity.









