Abundant Life Christian School

Tragedy at Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin

A 15-year-old girl opened fire with a handgun at Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin, killing a teacher and a fellow student and teacher in a heinous crime that shocked the community of Madison, Wisconsin.

Students in kindergarten through 12th grade attend the Christian school. Police said the shooting was in a classroom during a study hall “full of students from multiple grade levels.”

The motive appears to be a combination of factors, Madison Police Chief Shon Barnes said at a news conference

Victim

Rubi Patricia Vergara

Rubi Patricia Vergara – 2010 – 2024

Rubi Patricia Vergara was born on March 17, 2010, in Madison, the daughter of Vicente and Jennifer (Remus) Vergara. She was a bright, artistic 14-year-old freshman who attended Abundant Life Christian School. Known for her vibrant personality, Rubi had a deep passion for art and music. She spent much of her free time drawing, painting, and exploring her creativity through various artistic mediums. Her love of music was evident in her participation in school music programs, where she was admired by her peers and teachers for her talent and enthusiasm.

On December 16, 2024, Rubi’s life was tragically cut short during a shooting at Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin. She was one of the two individuals killed in the incident, leaving her community in mourning. A vigil held in her honor highlighted the profound impact she had on her school and her loved ones.

Victim

Erin West

Erin West

Erin West, a 42-year-old teacher from DeForest, Wisconsin, has been identified by the Dane County Medical Examiner’s Office as one of two victims killed in the shooting at Abundant Life Christian School. West was pronounced dead at the scene following the shooting. A forensic autopsy completed at the medical examiner’s office confirmed she died from homicidal firearm-related trauma.

On December 16, 2024, Erin West life was tragically cut short during a shooting at Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin. She was one of the two individuals killed in the incident, leaving her community in mourning. A vigil held in her honor highlighted the profound impact she had on her school and her loved ones.

December 16, 2024

  • 10:50 AM Samantha Rupnow walked to a study hall and opened a fire, injuring six others including two students who were in critical condition.
  • A substitute teacher and three students had been taken to a hospital with less serious injuries, and two of them had been released by Monday evening.
  • A second-grade teacher called 911 to report the shooting
  • 10:57 AM Officers were dispatched to the school, which is located on the city’s east side. Medics with the Madison, Wisconsin, Police Department were conducting training nearby before they responded to a school shooting on Monday, Madison Police Chief Shon Barnes said.
  • “They left the training center immediately and came down here — and doing in real time what they were actually practicing for,” Barnes said at a news conference.
  • Five engine companies, four ladder companies and 15 ambulances.
  • First responders took four people to St. Mary’s Hospital and three others were taken to University of Wisconsin hospital
  • “Officers located a juvenile who they believe was responsible for this deceased in the building,” Link
  • The victims: a 14-year-old student, Rubi Patricia Vergara, known for her love of art and music, and a teacher whose identity has not been publicly disclosed. Among the injured, two students were critically wounded, while others sustained non-life-threatening injuries
  • 12:22 P.M. Police Announces: The shooter was a student at the school and is deceased. Evidence suggests the shooter died by a self-inflicted gunshot wound, Chief Shon Barnes said at a Monday night news conference and was pronounced dead on the way to the hospital. At this time, three people have died as a result of the shooting, including the suspect. At least seven others are injuried. Their injuries range from minor to life-threatening. 
  • 2:32 PM. The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) is on the scene of a school shooting in Madison, Wisconsin, as officials work to learn more about the gun that was used.
  • ATF is running a trace on the firearm
  • The shooter at Abundant Life Christian School used a 9mm pistol, according to a law enforcement source.
  • 2:48 P.M. Police Briefing: At this time, three are deceased. During the media briefing earlier this afternoon, it was erroneously shared 5 were deceased. Again, three are deceased. Seven are injured. Their injuries range from minor to life-threatening. The next media briefing is at 2:30 p.m. at Fire Station 14 at 3201 Dairy Dr.
  • 4:30 P.M. Police Briefing: Three people died as a result of this shooting, including the suspected shooter. The shooter was a teenage student at the school. A teacher and another teenage student also died. Two people are in critical condition with life-threatening injuries. Four people are recovering from non-life-threatening injuries. At this time, detectives are working to determine a motive. 
  • 11:15 PM The Madison Police Department responded to a shooting at Abundant Life Christian School on Monday morning.
  • Officers were dispatched to the school, which is located on the city’s east side, at 10:57 a.m.
  • They arrived to find multiple people, both students and staff, injured. 
  • Three people, including the suspected shooter, are dead.
  • The shooter has been identified as 15-year-old Natalie Rupnow, who went by Samantha. She was a student at the school and evidence suggests she died from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound. The official cause of death will be released by the Dane County Medical Examiner’s Office pending the conclusion of their thorough examination. She was pronounced dead on the way to the hospital.

Reunification is underway for parents and guardians at the Dean Clinic at 1821 S. Stoughton Road. Community members are asked to not show up to this location unless they are picking up a student. The reunification process will take some time, please be patient. The next media briefing is scheduled for 5:30 p.m. at Fire Station 14 at 3201 Dairy D.

  • Two people are in critical condition with life-threatening injuries. 
  • Four people are recovering from non-life-threatening injuries.
  • At this time, detectives are working to determine a motive. 
  • Reunification is underway for parents and guardians at the Dean Clinic at 1821 S. Stoughton Road. Community members are asked to not show up to this location unless they are picking up a student. The reunification process will take some time, please be patient
  • The next media briefing is scheduled for 5:30 p.m. at Fire Station 14 at 3201 Dairy Dr. Three people died as a result of this shooting, including the suspected shooter. The shooter was a teenage student at the school. A teacher and another teenage student also died.

Rupnow’s family home was raided by SWAT teams following the school bloodbath – with investigators speaking to her father, who is said to be cooperating.

  • 4:07 PM Mayor issued a statement on the school shooting at Abundant Life Christian School today in Madison. Link

December 17, 2024

  • 11:56 A.M. Members of the media, questions for today’s press briefing must be submitted ahead of time. Please email [email protected] by 12:30 CST with your inquiries.
  • The Madison Police Department is investigating a shooting at Abundant Life Christian School.
  • Multiple injuries have been reported. This remains an active and ongoing investigaiton. More information will be released as it is available. 
  • We currently need people to avoid the area. 
  • Roads will be blocked off along 4900 Buckeye Road. Drivers and community members are asked to find alternate routes in travel is needed in this area.
  • December 19, 2024: A 20-year-old Alexander Paffendorf California man was detained for allegedly planning a mass shooting at a government building in a parallel and coordinated attack with the teenage girl who gunned down two people at a Wisconsin Christian school on Monday.
  • April 28, 2025: A 22-year-old Damien Blade Allen arrested and linked to WI school shooter accused of 7 mass shooting threats.
The Shooter

Natalie (Samantha) Rupnow

Natalie Rupnow born in 2009 to Joseph and Mellisa Rupnow had attended the Abundant Life Christian School.

On December 16, 2024, a tragic shooting occurred at Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin. Fifteen-year-old student Natalie “Samantha” Rupnow opened fire with a handgun, resulting in the deaths of a teacher and a fellow student, and injuring six others. Rupnow died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound at the scene.

Abundant Life Christian School

Samantha Rupnow

Natalie Rupnow aka Samantha Rupnow was born November 7, 2009 to Jeffrey William Rupnow and Mellisa Dahleen Rupnow, she had attended Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin. Before the start of the school she changed her name from Natalie to Samantha.

  • 2009 – Jeffrey changed his name from Jeffrey Thomas Tuttle to Jeffrey William Rupnow
  • May 10, 2010 – Jeffrey Purchased a home 4 blocks from his moms house .
  • 2011 – Natalie Rupnow parents first married in 2011, about two years after she was born.
  • Mellissa Rupnow had been previously married and divorced, and she had another daughter with a different man to whom she was never married. Court records indicate that this girl — Natalie Rupnow half sister — had other permanent legal guardians.
  • 2014 – Mellissa and Jeff Rupnow divorced for the first time in 2014, agreeing to joint legal custody of their shared daughter, Natalie, but specifying that she would live primarily with her mother.
  • 2017 The couple remarried in 2017.
  • October 2017 – Natalie has achieved the rank of purple belt in a martial art
  • 2020 divorced for a second time in 2020, again agreeing to share custody but, the court records show, dividing Natalie’s time more evenly between them. During this period, Natalie would spend two days with her father, two with her mother, then three more with her father, before reversing the schedule the following week.
  • Shortly after Rupnow’s parents split up for the second time, the couple remarried once more.
  • April 2021 they were petitioning for a third divorce. A judge granted it a month later but noted that “parties [were] admonished concerning remarriage,”
  • July 2022 – After seeking mediation to determine custody of Natalie, they agreed in July 2022 that they would share legal custody but that the girl would now live mostly with her father. By this time, Natalie Rupnow had been enrolled in therapy, which was supposed to help guide decisions about which parent she would spend weekends with, the records show.
  • The 2022 custody papers said Rupnow’s parents were on cordial terms.
  • “The parents report a generally positive co-parenting relationship,” the document reads, “and will continue to communicate with one another by text messages and phone conversations.”
  • Natalie ‘Samantha’ Rupnow was in therapy over troubled home life that saw parents repeatedly divorce
  • Custody Agreement: Natalie spending two days with her father, then two days with her mother, followed by three days with her father again in a schedule that would alternate weekly
  • They attended Bethel Lutheran Church in Madison, WI

May 2024

  • Natalie and Jeff Rupnow Joined NBSC North Bristol Shooting Club – is a gun club in Sun Prairie, a suburb of Madison

Natalie Rupnow had changed her name to Samantha before she transferred to Abundant Life. Samantha Rupnow “was very much to herself. She wore a collared shirt with a tie, jeans, and combat boots.

December 16, 2024

  • Rupnow took the bus to school
  • It was middle school pajama day at the school.
  • Before shooting Samantha Rupnow told her teacher she had to go to the nurse

10:50 AM – 15-year-old Natalie (Samantha) Rupnow –walked past the classroom with open door on her way to the study hall where she opened fire. Samantha Rupnow opened fire. Shortly after loudspeaker warned all students of an active shooter: “This is not a drill.”

  • Rupnow shot to death a substitute teacher who was running the study hall, killed a teenager, and shot another teacher and five other students. Two of the students are in critical condition

10:57 AM – Police arrived to the school after 2 nd grade teacher call 911

Samantha Rupnow died by a self-inflicted gunshot wound, Chief Shon Barnes said at a Monday night news conference and was pronounced dead on the way to the hospital. Multiple people have died as a result of the shooting, including the suspect. At least seven others were injured. Their injuries range from minor to life-threatening. 

Officers raided the family’s home and are sifting through a manifesto that she may have left behind. Her family is said to be cooperating with investigators, who are working with the shooter’s friends and loved ones to determine how she acquired the firearm, what led to the rampage, and whether they knew of an attack plot or had been warned of the violence that was to come. Police said they believe the attack was premeditated.

‘A document about this shooting is circulating at this time on social media, but we have not verified its authenticity.’

Rupnow was present from the start of the school day on Monday and eventually opened fire on a study hall full of students from various grades, Chief Barnes said.

Investigators believe Rupnow used a 9mm pistol to carry out her attack.

The official spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the ongoing investigation.


Abundant Life Christian School

Abundant Life Christian School shooting:

Investigation Timeline: December 16, 2024

  • 10:57 AM: A second-grade teacher calls 911 to report gunfire inside the school.
  • Shortly after: Emergency services arrive at the scene and evacuate the school. Multiple victims are found with gunshot wounds.
  • Casualties:
  • Deceased:
  • 14-year-old student Rubi Patricia Vergara.
  • A teacher (identity not disclosed).
  • The shooter, Natalie “Samantha” Rupnow (15), died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
  • Injured: Six others, two critically, were transported to local hospitals.
  • Preliminary Autopsy: Preliminary autopsy results confirmed that she died as a result of “firearm-related trauma,” and additional testing is underway.

Investigation Timeline

  • December 16, 2024: Law enforcement begins an investigation into the shooter’s motives. Reports emerge of potential bullying and indications of premeditation, including a possible manifesto.
  • Officers raided the family’s home and are sifting through a manifesto that she may have left behind. Her family is said to be cooperating with investigators, who are working with the shooter’s friends and loved ones to determine how she acquired the firearm, what led to the rampage, and whether they knew of an attack plot or had been warned of the violence that was to come. Police said they believe the attack was premeditated.
  • December 17, 2024: A photo surfaces showing Natalie Rupnow at a gun range wearing a T-shirt linked to the Columbine shooting, raising concerns about the influence of past school shootings.
  • December 18, 2024: Authorities continue investigating the weapons used and whether they were legally obtained.
  • 8:51 PM: A San Diego Superior Court Judge approved the restraining order for Alexander Paffendorf on Tuesday, December 17, at 8:51 p.m. 
  • Not long after the judge signed the order, more than a dozen police cars enter the Paffendorf’s apartment complex. 
  • This is a civil action, not a criminal action. But it does allow officers to seize weapons.
  • December 19, 2024: A 20-year-old Alexander Paffendorf California man was detained for allegedly planning a mass shooting at a government building in a parallel and coordinated attack with the teenage girl who gunned down two people at a Wisconsin Christian school on Monday.

Community Response

  • December 16, 2024 (Evening): A vigil is held in Madison, Wisconsin, to honor the victims and support their families.
  • December 17, 2024: President Joe Biden and Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers issue statements of condolences and call for gun safety reforms.


Damien Allen

Damien Allen accused of planning mass attack

Damien Allen, 22, was arrested Tuesday night after the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office said he was potentially planning an attack and had engaged in threatening communications through online platforms.

Allen previously talked to Natalie Rupnow, 15, who later died after conducting a mass shooting at a school in Madison, Wisconsin, on Dec. 17, 2024. During their investigation of Allen, the arrest report said he posted a video on Instagram on Oct. 8, 2022, with him inside a Ford Crown Victoria, which is commonly used by law enforcement. Deputies said the video started with Allen inside the driver’s seat of the vehicle and a computer that looked like a Palm Beach County sheriff’s laptop. “After Allen shows the laptop, he shows a rifle rack behind the seat with a rifle in the vehicle,” the affidavit said.

Damien Allen

Damien Blade Allen, 22, was arrested April 29, 2025 by the Palm Beach Sheriff’s Office on charges including intimidation-threatening a mass shooting

Damien Blade Allen, 22, was arrested Tuesday by the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office for allegedly threatening a mass shooting and impersonating a deputy.

Investigators say Allen used TikTok, Instagram, and Discord to post threats and shared plans for attacks at seven locations. He had communicated with 15-year-old Natalie Rupnow before she carried out a school shooting in Madison, Wisconsin, in December 2024.

In a May 2024 message, Allen allegedly wrote, “My loadout is set up for war… Strike the police dept. also. Guerrilla warfare tactics, ambushing and blitz.” He detailed having two firearms, 118 rounds of 9mm ammunition, bulletproof vests, smoke grenades, and steel plates.

In one Instagram video from October 2022, Allen appeared inside a Ford Crown Victoria showing what looked like a PBSO laptop and a rifle rack. He also posted photos in full PBSO-style uniform with a badge, Taser, and gun belt. Authorities later confirmed he was not a deputy.

Sheriff Ric Bradshaw said Allen “was ready to do it,” and his arrest likely saved lives. Allen is being held without bond at the Palm Beach County Jail.

Damien Allen

Investigation Timeline: Damien Blade Allen

2021

  • October 28, 2021: Victim reports that Damien Allen (DOB 10/14/2002), a fellow student aged 19 at the time, made her uncomfortable during school hours.

Victim’s Statement

  • Female Victim first noticed Allen watching her during gym class.
  • As she walked to lunch afterward, Allen began following her. During a conversation, she asked about his fashion choices. Allen responded he was aiming for a “1999 Columbine vibe” — referencing the mass school shooting in Columbine — and said he wanted to wear a black trench coat “with stuff strapped to me.” This made her feel “incredibly uncomfortable,” so she tried to walk away. Allen followed her and groped her, after first placing his hand on her shoulder.

Allen’s Response

  • When interviewed, Allen was read his Miranda rights, which he acknowledged. He denied the groping and claimed Coombe invented the allegation due to being afraid of his “Columbine” comments. He admitted they discussed outfits, but refused to answer further questions and became evasive.
  • Based on the investigation and the sworn statement of the victim, the officer determined there was probable cause to arrest Allen for: Lewd and Lascivious Molestation of a Victim Aged 12–16 by Offender Over 18Florida Statute 800.04(5)(c)2.

2022

  • July 8, 2022: Damien Allen posted a video on Instagram (@callsign_kiro) wearing a full Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office (PBSO) Class B uniform and holding a rifle. The uniform included PBSO patches, badge, name tag “ALLEN,” and a police radio​
  • October 1, 2022: Allen posted a TikTok video titled “Riot Controller Mode” wearing a PBSO uniform.
  • The video transitions to him in military gear with a caption threatening force.
  • October 8, 2022: Allen posted another Instagram video from inside a Ford Crown Victoria (a police vehicle lookalike), displaying:
  • A mounted PBSO-style laptop.
  • A rifle rack with a visible firearm labeled with the “Senpai” sticker — one of his online aliases.
  • This video helped confirm the link between his alias and real identity.

2024

  • May 19, 2024: Allen, using the alias “Senpai_Kiro,” shared his Snapchat and Discord accounts with Natalie Rupnow in a TikTok conversation​. Allen offers his Snapchat (lapdl001) and Discord (KiroSenpai) usernames. These social accounts would become key evidence.
  • May 21, 2024: Allen notes: “No more posting… account might get banned,” suggesting evasion of detection.
  • May 23, 2024: Allen claimed to own AR500 steel plates, a Level 4 helmet, and IFAK kits — all military/tactical gear. Allen stated: “Once you get to a point there’s no going back” and threatened “gorilla warfare tactics” and “striking 7 places including the police dept”​
  • Rupnow states: I wanted to do a black church that was near me…”
  • Allen responds within 1 minute: “I got AR500 steel plates, a level 4 helmet, and IFAK kits. My loadout is set up for war.He claims to have:
  • 10 magazines holding 30 rounds each,”
  • Flashbangs and smoke grenades,”
  • 5 pistol magazines of 17 rounds and 1 stick of 33.”
  • 7 places I would strike… police dept also… guerrilla warfare tactics.”
  • “Once you get to a point, there’s no going back.”
  • June 7–9, 2024: More TikTok chats between Rupnow and Allen: Allen and Rupnow exchanged affectionate and conspiratorial messages suggesting a coordinated mass shooting. Allen said, “We go down together” and discussed tactical outfits​
  • “We go down together,” “I love you more,” “What’s your favorite tactical outfit?” (Rupnow replies: “Something full black.”)
  • Rupnow encourages Allen to make a new TikTok video with his “kit” (tactical gear).
  • June 24, 2024: More exchanges between Allen and Rupnow including flirtatious and supportive messages​. Allen and Rupnow discuss:
  • Suicide ideation: “Wish I wasn’t [alive] but yk…”
  • Allen expresses affection: “Best gift I got was being with you.”
  • Personal items: toothbrushes, broccoli, tactical equipment, July plans.
  • Allen jokes: “I’d shoot a mf over [mint toothpaste] XD.”
  • July 10, 2024: Allen posts a video titled “many different lives I have” showing:
  • PBSO radio, gun belt, PBSO uniform, and cosplay clothes.
  • Reinforces dual life: law enforcement impersonation + fantasy shooter identity.
  • July 12, 2024:  Allen posts a Glock handgun and ammo photo on Instagram with caption: “Loyalty, Respect, and my Glock.”
  • July 18, 2024: Rupnow posted inflammatory and antisemitic/misogynistic remarks; Allen responded dismissively​. Rupnow posts extremist commentary:
  • Derogatory claims about mass shooters.
  • Allen replies: “Just posted without any context… womp womp.
  • September 23–26, 2024: Emotional exchanges occurred between Rupnow and Allen. Allen suggested switching to Snapchat (“Callsign_allen”) after his account was banned.
  • Rupnow apologizes for unadding Allen and expresses continued love.
  • Allen posts about his Snapchat (Callsign_allen).

Allen’s Instagram profile lists: “Florida Deputy, MilShop Airsoft CEO, Forklift Mechanic.”

  • October 1, 2024: Allen again posts video impersonating PBSO on Instagram, titled “Riot Controller Mode.”
  • December 17, 2024: Natalie Samantha Rupnow, 15, carries out a mass shooting at Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin: A phone recovered from her body led authorities to communications with Allen.
  • Kills one teacher and one student.
  • Wounds six others.
  • Commits suicide at the scene.
  • Law enforcement retrieves her phone from her body.

2025

  • Early 2025: FBI obtains search warrants for: Rupnow’s TikTok and Telegram accounts. Allen’s linked aliases: “Senpai_Kiro” and “@callsign_kiro.” Analysis confirms:
  • Conspiracy to commit mass shootings.
  • Multiple posts threatening violence.
  • Allen posted in PBSO uniform and claimed to be a deputy.
  • Allen owns or claims to own body armor, weapons, and tactical equipment.
  • FBI alerts Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Internal Affairs believing Allen might be a real deputy (he was not).
  • April 21, 2025: FBI Milwaukee reviewed messages and provided further information about Allen’s threats and impersonation of law enforcement​
  • April 25, 2025: FBI Guardian Tip received indicating Allen may be planning an attack. He was under investigation for impersonating a deputy and making mass shooting threats online
  • April 27, 2025: Damien Allen was arrested by Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office and charged with:
  • Written Threats to Kill or Commit Mass Shooting (F.S. 836.10(2)(b))
  • Unlawful Use of Two-Way Communication Device (F.S. 934.215)
  • Unlawful Use of Badge or Indicia of Authority (F.S. 843.085(1))
  • April 30, 2025 – Circuit Judge Donald Hafele ordered Allen held without bail during a brief hearing at the jail .
Alexander Paffendorf

Alexander Paffendorf accused of coordinating attack with Madison school shooter

Alexander Paffendorf from Carlsbad California. Detained by FBI. Authorities say he plotted with Natalie “Samantha” Rupnow to commit an additional mass shooting at a government building.

According to a gun violence restraining order obtained by CBS 8, FBI agents served Alexander Paffendorf after discovering Paffendorf was in contact with Rupnow and coordinating an attack at a local government building.

Alexander Paffendorf

Abundant Life Christian School

Alexander Paffendorf accused of coordinating attack with Madison school shooter

  • December 18, 2024 
  • 8:51 PM: A San Diego Superior Court Judge approved the restraining order on Tuesday, December 17, at 8:51 p.m.
  • Not long after the judge signed the order, more than a dozen police cars enter the Paffendorf’s apartment complex.
  • This is a civil action, not a criminal action. But it does allow officers to seize weapons.

Paffendorf, according to the restraining order, admitted facts to FBI agents in a subsequent interview. “During an FBI interview, Paffendorf admitted to the FBI agents that he told Rupnow that he would arm himself with explosives and a gun and that he would target a government building,” reads the two-page restraining order from the Carlsbad Police Department.

The order said that FBI agents “saw the messages from Paffendorf to Rupnow.”

Paffendorf’s gun violence protective order comes two days after 15-year-old Natalie “Samantha” Rupnow entered the Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wisconsin, and opened fire, killing one student and a teacher before turning the gun on herself. Rupnow also shot five other students and one teacher.

  • Paffendorf is due in court on January 3, 2025